A Justified Murder (Medlar Mystery 2)

Sara took time to answer. “My brother had an affair with Charlene when she was just fifteen years old. Randal was close to forty.”

Jack wasn’t going to show his disgust at that. “Explains why she likes Leland.” He felt her stiffen. “Okay. Sorry. It’s not a matter for jokes.”

“You overheard Tayla’s phone conversation.”

“Yeah, so?”

“When the White Lily Kidnapping happened, Charlene was sixteen.”

Jack drew in his breath. “Just because Tayla mentioned white lilies, you can’t think she had anything to do with it?”

“I don’t know what to think. Janet Beeson knew who the kidnapper was. Maybe Tayla’s niece and my brother were part of that. She said Charlene was heartbroken. That can cause you to do really stupid things. I know! I ran away from your grandfather because my heart was broken. Maybe Janet found out and Tayla had to keep her quiet. Maybe she —” She cut herself off.

“You’re jumping very far ahead, and you’re skipping a lot. Do you really think Tayla could murder another human being?”

“If someone was threatening you or Kate, I could kill.”

Jack kissed the top of her head. “Where was Randal nine months before the kidnapping?”

“Who knows? He never told anyone what he was doing when. He loved to sneak around. Loved to surprise people by being where they didn’t expect him to be.”

“Would his wife know?”

“I thought of asking her but she’d tell Kate I was snooping. She would—”

“I’ll ask her.” Jack got off the bed. “Give me her number and I’ll call now.”

“That could possibly work. Maybe.”

“We can try.” He took the phone and went into her big bathroom. He didn’t need the distraction of Sara staring at him with worry in her eyes.

Twenty minutes later Jack clicked off the phone and let out a sigh of relief. He hadn’t enjoyed talking to Kate’s mother. Ava seemed to think Jack was a predator after her helpless daughter. Jack had spent most of the time defending himself in a way he hoped soothed her.

It had taken work to get information out of her. In July 1994, Ava Medlar had been heavily pregnant with Kate and her beloved husband didn’t leave her side for over a year. In fact, they’d spent the summer before she gave birth in Mexico. “I don’t know what you’re implying but my husband was not in Lachlan, Florida, that summer. In fact, there were, uh, legal complications and he... I mean, he needed to be somewhere besides the US.”

With that cryptic comment, she hung up.

Jack went back into the bedroom and told all to Sara. “I guess your brother’s passport could be checked, but I don’t think there’s a record for border crossings. Maybe Tayla is worried about something else. She also mentioned witches, and we know that wasn’t about her.”

“I guess so. It’s just that my brother wouldn’t think twice about going to bed with a teenager. Especially since she came on to him.”

“Did Tayla tell you that?”

“She hinted at it.”

“Anything else you didn’t tell me?”

“Just that Charlene was hurt when Randal didn’t show up at their meeting place.”

“So,” Jack said, “a beautiful young woman—who looked much older than her years, I might add—offered herself to your brother, who was at an age when he was probably worried about getting older, and he said yes. But later he had second thoughts and ended it. It seems that he went home to his wife and created Kate. Maybe we should thank Charlene.”

Sara gave a half smile.

“What did Mrs. Medlar mean when she said there were ‘legal complications’ that kept them out of the US?”

Sara groaned. “I’m sure it was law enforcement. My brother was always running from the police. But then, he stole whatever wasn’t bolted down. And even then he still took it. When he was a kid I had to empty his pockets, then figure out how to secretly return the items he’d stolen.”

“A klepto?”