Keeley's Fight (The Protectors 1)

“I get the birth control shot every three months. You don’t have to… wear a condom that is. I mean I’m clean, I’ve never done this before.” Stopping at the look on Nathaniel’s face, she waited for his response with baited breath.

Slamming his mouth down on hers, Nathaniel pushed his large cock the rest of the way inside her. Tensing at the breaking of her hymen she cried out into his mouth, breaking contact, with tears streaming down her face. “Oh, gawd, that hurts,” she half whined, half sobbed out, while Tyler rubbed her head and kissed her neck. Nathaniel just kept looking into her eyes, waiting for her to say go.

Seeing his arms straining and his abs clenched, Keeley knew he was holding back. Just like she knew that once he started, he would still hold back. “Please, Nathaniel? And don’t hold back….anything,” she implored him. Seeing the relief on his face, she knew she’d said the right thing.

He started pulling out slowly and pumping his hips back in even slower, but hitting a spot inside her that had her toes curling with each pass; she begged for more. Grabbing her legs, Nathaniel wrapped them around his hips and tangled one hand in her hair while wrapping the other under her, pushing her lower back up so he could go deeper. He really started pounding inside her, causing her to scream on each inward thrust. “Fuck me, you’re so tight, Butterfly. Your pussy is so warm and just melts around my cock,” he told her harshly.

When her mewling started to get louder and she was wiggling her hips more, Nathaniel looked into her eyes and asked her, “What do you need, baby? You gotta tell me.”

“More, I just need… More,” she gasped.

Gripping her hair tighter, he slowly moved his other hand up her body and around her chest, pinching a nipple before moving the rest of the way up and wrapping it around her neck, just under her jaw and squeezing lightly. Gasping from the new sensation, with Nathaniel’s hand on her throat, Keeley could feel everything more intensely; the pleasure humming through her body was more sensitive. Having her air constricted just this little bit was both terrifying and enthralling. She could feel the pulse in her clit that much more, and her breasts felt heavier with every breath. Her womb contracting from her orgasm was much more intense. Everything was just… More. Looking into Nathaniel’s eyes, she could see he really enjoyed the power he had over her pleasure from just this one move. Everything started to spiral out of control at once with that look. Lights flashed, pleasure pulsed through every cell in her body, her breath stalled then it felt like she exploded

; her eyes rolled back in her head, her back arched and she dug her nails into his back on a long and loud scream while she came. He kept pounding into her pussy right through her orgasm and into another one, when he finally moaned out his own, squeezing her neck just a little tighter while coming, she came again. All Keeley could see were stars, her body was tight, and felt like it was on a cloud… pure bliss was the only way she could think to describe the feeling coursing through her veins.

With Nathaniel collapsed on top of her she couldn’t move, nor did she want to. His hands still on her throat and in her hair, he rolled them to the side while his semi-hard cock slipped out and he moaned. “Jesus fucking Christ that was hot as hell, darlin’,” Tyler said from behind her.

*******

Still trying to catch his breath, Nate looked at Keeley in wonder. Wrapping his hand around her throat was only a guess, but he remembered the way she reacted when Ty had done it in their kiss the other day. He was glad to be right that, that had been what she needed to get off. Waiting for her to open her eyes, all Nate could think was this girl is fucking perfect. She was their soul mate. He had to make sure nothing ever happened to her again.

“Butterfly, you doing ok?” Nate asked her while rubbing his hand up and down her back. Smiling at him without opening her eyes she asked, “Can we do that again?”

“I’m here and ready if you are darlin’.” Ty smirked at the dreamy look on her face. Turning her over and forcing Ty onto his back, he placed his hands on her hips and pulled her on top of him. “What do I do?” She whispered.

Climbing behind her, Nate placed his hands on her ribs, leaned forward, and whispered, “I’ll guide you, Butterfly,” causing her to shiver. Pulling her to her knees, Ty aligned his cock with her pussy, while Nate helped her slowly lower herself onto him. Once she was fully seated on Ty, his brother moaned out, “Oh, fuck baby that is one golden pussy.”

When Nate let go of her she whimpered, grabbing his hands and putting them to her breasts she told him, “Please don’t leave, Nathaniel.” Kissing her temple, he pressed himself to her back and his cock nestled between her ass cheeks. Moaning at the contact she started to ride up and down on Ty’s cock.

*******

Having Keeley’s warm, wet pussy wrapped around his cock, Ty felt ready to explode again. Knowing he wasn’t going to last long, he grabbed her hips and slammed up into her causing her to scream, “Oh my God!”

“Come on darlin’, come for me. I ain’t gonna last long with that silky heat wrapped around me,” Ty pleaded with her. Pumping into her faster and squeezing her hips tighter, he heard Nate ask her, “You need it again, don’t ya, Butterfly.”

“Yes, please,” she mewled back.

Watching in fascination while Nate lifted one hand from her breast and up her torso to wrap around her throat, Nate squeezed slightly harder than before. Watching her mouth open on a silent scream and her eyes roll back in her head, combined with her pussy squeezing his cock like a vise, Ty slammed her body down onto his cock once more and came harder than he ever had before. “Fucking Christ, woman, that shit is hot as hell!” He told her once she collapsed on his chest.

“Relax Butterfly, I’m going to go run you a bath so you’re not sore before you fall asleep.” Nate then got up to leave. Hearing the water turn on in the bathroom, Ty started rubbing circles on Keeley’s back, thinking of the way she gave herself to them. She was completely selfless, and when she came, it was like a dream. Ty couldn’t remember the last time he was that turned on or affected by a woman. Seeing Nate’s hand wrapped around her throat to help her reach her peak was fucking hot, too. He’d never seen anything like it before. Should have had my fucking camera he thought. He and Nate loved taking pictures of beautiful things. They’d never thought to take pictures of the women they’d been with before, but with Keeley it felt natural. He wanted to capture everything on film, so it would last a lifetime. Seeing her absolute pleasure on film would be a huge turn-on, something he could look back on in fifty years or so and remember.

When he heard the water shut off, Ty started to gently shake her. “Come on, your bath is ready, darlin’.” When she just mumbled incoherently and burrowed further into his chest, he chuckled and carried her in. Placing her in Nate’s lap, since he was already sitting in the tub, Ty went back to the room to change the sheets; ’cause Nate wasn’t lying when he said their girl was a squirter.

*******

Lying in Nathaniel’s arms after making love to him and Tyler, Keeley felt heavenly. Her body was alight with pleasure. She was a little sore between her legs but figured that was normal for her first time. Plus, her men were very large in the penis department.

Thinking about how Nathaniel wrapped his hand around her throat to get her to come, she was shocked that it hadn’t scared her and, in fact, made her trust him all the more. Knowing he could do that and not hurt her was an amazing feeling. It was freeing in a way, because there were so many times when her father would try to choke her, and she figured she would be scared of such force. But all it did was turn her on more; it was like an instant way to make her orgasm. She also had doubts that maybe there was something wrong with her. Was her abuse so ingrained that she needed the violence to seek pleasure? Will they think less of her knowing she needs that to get off?

Not realizing she was mumbling about it, Keeley was shocked when Nathaniel grabbed her shoulders and turned her so she was facing him and said, “Butterfly that was fucking hot as hell. Knowing you trust me that much, to have that power and control over your mind and body, is incredibly arousing.”

“You don’t think there’s something wrong with me? My father choked me so many times, how can I not think that I’m some kind of freak?”

Startled by Tyler’s voice, she turned to look at him when he spoke. “Did it feel good, darlin’? You enjoyed what we did to you, right?”

“Yes, it was amazing. I’ve never felt so complete in my life.”

“Then there’s nothing wrong with you. If it’s something you consent to and enjoy, it’s natural. And believe me when I say, there was nothing sexier than seeing and feeling you let go the way did with Nate’s hand around that sexy elegant throat of yours,” Tyler interjected with hooded eyes and arousal in every line of his body. “Come on darlin’, the bed’s made and I’m wiped out.”