Instead of fucking me right away, though, Cooper plunged a second finger deep inside me, making me gasp as I took Nolan’s cock deep to the back of my throat again.
God, he was going to tease me with those thick, insistent fingers before finally giving me what I needed so badly.
And I loved every second of it.
“Keep going, beautiful,” Nolan rumbled, slowly raising his hips to meet me as I bobbed up and down on his length. “Yeah, just like that. So, so good.”
Cooper’s hand came down on my ass, first on one cheek and then on the other, the hard, loud smacks nearly making me choke on Nolan’s cock as I tried to cry out around it.
“Such a pretty ass,” Cooper said, gently rubbing the spots he’d just smacked. He leaned in and kissed me right on my ass cheeks, then continued to rub each one some more. “I could come purely from looking at this ass, and touching it. And kissing. Fingering...”
“Yes,” I nodded impatiently, Nolan’s cock slipping away again. “Please, God. Do it now.”
He took his fingers away, leaving me empty and needy and greedy for more. When he finally, finally teased my slick folds with the head of his cock, it was nearly too much for me to take.
I whined as I went down as far as I could on Nolan, hoping the sensation of his thick length filling my mouth and throat would distract me from how much I wanted Cooper to fill my pussy.
“You’d better fuck her, Coop.” The vibrations of Nolan’s low, sexy voice rumbling through me as he fed me his cock. “She’s whimpering for it. Don’t make her stop blowing me to ask you again.”
Cooper laughed and gave my ass another playful smack, making my eyes roll back in my head as a rush of wet heat radiated out from my core.
Thankfully, I didn’t have to beg anymore. Cooper grabbed my hips with both hands and slowly slid his thick cock in with one long, continuous thrust that made every nerve ending in my body come alive at once.
I pressed back against him, rocking my body into his as he filled me with every inch of his length. “Fuck, baby,” he growled, his fingers digging into my hips. “So fucking hot and tight. I love the way your pussy grips me. Every. Fucking. Time.”
I loved it, too. Loved the way he started slowly and gradually picked up the pace. Loved the way he filled my pussy while Nolan filled my mouth and throat. Loved being right here between my two guys—the only people outside of Muriel and Jas who had ever truly understood me. The only people I’d ever wanted so badly I couldn’t stand it.
Even six years apart and a huge misunderstanding hadn’t extinguished those feelings. I still didn’t know how an actual, mature, grown-up relationship would work between the three of us, but I wanted to try.
So far it seemed easy to pick up where we’d left off, and I wanted to give us a chance.
“Damn, sexy,” Nolan held my hair back as I took him deeper and deeper, all the way down to the base until his short hairs tickled against my nose. “There’s no way I’m going to last much longer if you keep deep-throating me like that.”
I would have smiled if I could’ve.
I didn’t slow down, and I damn sure wasn’t going to stop. I wanted to feel him release, and then I wanted to taste him, and I was determined to keep going until that happened.
“I’m really fucking close, too,” Cooper exhaled in a burst of air as he went harder, faster, and deeper with each thrust.
I was sure I’d have bruises from where his hands held me in place, but I didn’t care. It was the best kind of pain, and it only served to heighten my senses as my climax steadily built inside me.
When Cooper finally moved his hands, he leaned in on top of me, wrapping one arm completely around my waist as he lowered his stomach and chest onto my back. His free hand reached down to find my most sensitive spot, teasing my clit and making my breath hitch as I bucked against him.
“Yeah, baby,” he panted into my ear. “There you go. Gonna make you come so hard for me. Are you ready?”
I only moaned louder and louder as he worked me into a frenzy. I needed to finish, needed to come, needed that release that was threatening to overtake me.
Cooper called out my name, and Nolan let out a long, low groan as they held me in place and filled me from both ends. My orgasm rushed through me, wracking my body and making my vision blurry until I finally closed my eyes and collapsed into their arms.
“So good,” one of them—Cooper, I think—whispered as they both cradled my body between them.