Pretenders (Firsts and Forever 3)

Eventually, he announced, “I only found nine white tattoos, thirteen in all.”

“Number fourteen is on the nape of my neck.” I tilted my head and felt his fingertips skim the stylized lotus flower just below my hairline. Then I met his gaze with a grin. “Now you know all my secrets.”

“No, I don’t. But I hope to, someday.” He kissed me tenderly, and I slid closer and parted my lips for him.

We worked each other up slowly. When we were both hard, I grasped our cocks in one hand and jerked us off as his tongue teased mine. After a while, he leaned back a little and said, “I have a question for you.”

“If you’re about to ask me to top you, the answer is hell yes. But can we trade off? I love having you inside me.”

“Perfect.” He grabbed the lube from the nightstand, and when he turned back to me he asked, “How do you feel about foregoing the condoms? We’ve both been tested, and since we’re a couple it goes without saying I’m going to be monogamous.”

“I am, too.”

“But if you’d feel more comfortable using them—”

“No, I’m ready for this. It’s wonderful, actually. I’ve never been with someone who wanted only me.” I smiled at him and said, “This feels like a big step.”

“It does, but it feels right, too.”

I playfully pushed him onto his back and climbed on top of him. As soon as we kissed, desire spiked in both of us. He ran his hands down my back and cupped my ass, and I rocked my hips, rubbing my cock against his.

He reached for the lube and took his time working me open, and then I did the same for him. I jerked him off as I fingered his ass, and he moaned and bucked his hips. It was so satisfying to watch him unravel at my touch.

It would have been easy to finish him off this way, but he rasped, “Fuck me, Ash.” He really didn’t have to ask me twice.

My hands shook as I lubed my cock, knelt between his thighs, and pressed my tip against his hole. After a moment, he opened up enough for me to slip inside him. His ass was warm and tight around my cock, and the sounds of pleasure he made as I slid in and out of him drove me wild.

Wes was insatiable. He kept saying, “Harder,” until I was absolutely pounding his ass, his legs spread wide and his skin flushed as both of us moaned and writhed and gave ourselves over to pure pleasure. I pinched his nipples and kissed him, and he bit my shoulder before pushing me onto my back.

He quickly lubed his cock and pushed it into me, and I muttered, “Fuck, that feels good.” When he paused to let me get used to feeling stretched and full, I grinned and said, “Don’t you dare be gentle with me.” He laughed at that, then dropped to his elbows on top of me and began fucking my ass with hard, deep thrusts.

As he met my gaze, I felt so connected to him, and so safe. It was freeing, in a way I never would have predicted. I knew I could totally let go, and it would be okay.

I rolled us over, straddled his hips, and rode his cock, driving him deep into me. He let me do that for a while, and then he sat up and held onto me as I bounced on his lap. He told me, “You’re absolutely beautiful, Ash,” before claiming my mouth in a fiery kiss.

I slid off his cock and slapped his hip playfully as I said, “Flip over.” He grinned and rolled onto his hands and knees, arching his back as I pushed my cock into his ass. He jerked himself off as I fucked him, our bodies slamming together as my moans mingled with his. All too soon, I murmured, “I’m close.”

“Come in me.”

Oh god. Hearing him say that was so hot that I came almost instantly, crying out, reveling in the sensation of his tight ass milking every drop of cum from my cock. My legs shook as I grasped his hips, pushing into him again and again as I filled him.

My head was spinning by the time I finished, but I wasn’t about to leave him unsatisfied. I stretched out on my back and parted my legs for him, but because he could tell I was tired, he asked, “You sure?” When I nodded, he slid his cock in my ass and fucked me with quick, hard thrusts.

Moments later, he yelled as he came in me. I loved seeing him like that, primal and uninhibited, worlds away from the side of him everyone else got to see.

Afterwards, we both took quick turns in the bathroom to clean up before returning to that soft, comfortable bed. I curled up on my side, and he pressed against my back and wrapped himself around me like a shield. I was grinning as we both fell asleep.