Her Best Men

I watched his cock jump at that statement before he fell between my legs.

He positioned his cock at my entrance, and I smiled as I felt him tease my slit. He slid into me effortlessly, his long cock filling the depths of my pussy. Inch after inch of pure ecstasy filled me to my core, and it felt so good that goosebumps ricocheted across my skin. He rolled deeply into me, holding himself up on one arm and cradling the back of my head with the other.

The moans that fell from my mouth were loud, and I didn’t give a shit who heard.

His dick felt amazing. Long and full, with just the right amount of girth. He slid across points I didn’t know existed in my body, and soon my moans turned into begging. His lips descended on mine, soft and warm, swallowing my sounds as he rolled the two of us over.

I dug my fingertips into the strength of his chest as I began to ride his cock. His hands were planted on my hips, but still had a touch of delicacy to them. Never in my life would I have taken Andrew for a soft lover, but I was enjoying every moment of it. The way he slowly rolled into my body and the way my juices dripped for his motions. Our movements were synced as he grabbed my tits, massaging them and pulling them to his lips as I rode his cock.

“Andrew. I’m so close. It’s—I can—oh, please. Don’t stop. Your tongue feels so good.”

He moaned into my tit and the vibrations sent me over the edge. I jolted and shook, my pussy clamping down on his cock. My arms gave way, and I fell onto him, resting my head into the crook of his neck as he held me close. He whispered phrases of praise into my ear. Complimenting me on how incredible I was and how long he had wanted this moment.

I rose up, my arms shaking as I planted a kiss on his lips. But his cock kept growing inside of me. Pressing against my walls and reminding me that he was still there, and he was still ready, and he was still needy.

And I wasn’t going to leave him hanging like that.

“Can I try something?” he asked.

“Anything,” I said breathlessly.

He pulled out from my pussy and helped turn me around on his lap. He settled my hips back down onto him, then slid his cock back into my body. My head fell forward, and I groaned, feeling goosebumps trickling up my back. Andrew began massaging my ass cheeks, parting them and smacking them as I started grinding down on his dick.

“That’s it. What a sight, Katie. Oh, holy hell, you're beautiful.”

His words struck a chord with me, and I couldn’t help myself. I picked up the pace, pressing my hands into his shins as I slammed myself down into his lap. He was bucking up into me, his balls knocking against my body when he came up for his thrusts. His cock grew and pulsed, twitched and leaked. I could feel myself building again. I could feel my need for him growing stronger than ever.

“Andrew. Andrew. Oh, yes. You feel so good. Fuck, yes. Yes. Yes. Like that. Right there. So close. Yes!”

I threw my head back, my hands cupping my tits as I came around his cock again. His hands grabbed onto my hips, steadying me on his lap as his dick emptied within me. I could feel him lining my walls.

I collapsed onto him, stars bursting in my vision as he caught me in his arms.

“You’re okay, I’ve got ya.”

I curled into Andrew’s body, and he wrapped his arms around me. He covered us up with the edge of the blanket, shrouding our naked bodies in case anyone walked our way. I could see the stars twinkling off in the distance and the moon shining with its brightness. Andrew’s heartbeat was rapid against my cheek as our arousal continued to slide from between my legs.

“That was amazing,” I said.

I felt Andrew grab my chin again, pulling my head up to his. He crashed his lips down onto mine, a hard kiss that swelled my lips. He held me there for what seemed like ages, and I melted into him.

“Yes, it was,” Andrew said against my lips. “It was amazin’, pretty lady.”

We laid there underneath the stars until the bonfire started to dwindle. People were making their way back to their cars and trucks, which meant we’d have to get out of there soon. When the coast was clear, we untangled ourselves, even though I didn’t want to. Even though I wanted to stay in his arms all night, I knew I had to get back to the resort and get my car.

“Ya might want this,” Andrew said.

He tossed me my panties, and I felt my cheeks flush. The two of us pieced ourselves back together and shared one last beer before we left. He took me straight to the resort and walked me to my car, and I chanced one last kiss on his cheek before I left.

I watched him in my rearview mirror as he watched me, his body never moving until I was out of sight.

I pulled up to my apartment complex and saw Lizzie sitting on the staircase. I furrowed my brow as she got up, holding her arms out with a massive smile on her cheeks. What was she doing here? Had I forgotten something? She didn’t seem mad, and I couldn't recall any plans that we’d made.

“Hey!”

“Hey there,” I said as I got out of my car. “What’s up?”

“What took ya so long to get home?” Lizzie asked.