Bad Ideas (First & Forever 4)

I laughed at that, then rolled onto my side so I was facing him. “And yet, I’m completely under your spell.”

He traced the curve of my smile with a fingertip before leaning in and kissing me. When things started to heat up, I caressed his ass and slid a fingertip between his cheeks. He’d prepped and lubed himself, which I always found deeply erotic.

After a while, he sat up and asked, “Remember when we were just a day or two into this and there was some mention of spanking me?”

I sat up too and nodded. “You hadn’t brought it up again, so I figured you weren’t ready to go there.”

“You’re right, I wasn’t. It’s one of those things that both turns me on and makes me feel vulnerable. But I feel confident enough to ask for it now.”

I pushed his robe off his shoulders, and it slid down his arms and pooled behind him. “Sounds fun. Any instructions?”

As I ran a fingertip up the length of his swelling cock, he murmured, “Don’t be gentle.”

“Wouldn’t dream of it.” I grinned at him and climbed out of bed, then grabbed the lube and my towel.

He yelped and then started laughing when I tossed him over my shoulder. I carried him across the room to the square ottoman near the fireplace and put him down on all fours, with his knees right at the edge of the padded surface. I placed the towel and lube off to the side, then reached underneath him and started jerking him off. It was so gratifying to watch him respond to my touch.

After a while, I circled around to the front of him and stroked his hair as I said, “Get me ready to fuck you, baby.”

Theo dove onto my cock and sucked me almost frantically. It felt incredible, and I let myself enjoy it for a few minutes. Once I was rock hard, I slid my cock from his lips, then ran my hand from his shoulder to his ass as I circled around behind him. I caressed one of his cheeks before bringing my hand down in an experimental slap.

He moaned with pleasure and bucked his hips. Seeing how much it turned him on made my cock throb. I started spanking his cute little ass with a steady rhythm—not all that hard, because it didn’t take much to make him moan, but enough to turn it nice and pink.

When I reached beneath him and stroked his cock, it was harder than ever and leaking precum. I stepped between his legs and lubed up, then worked some more lube into him before lining myself up with his hole. As I pushed into him with one long thrust, the most wonderful sound tumbled from him—need in its purest, most uninhibited form.

The sensation of being inside him with nothing between us was so erotic that I almost came on the spot. I had to hold still for a moment and take a breath before I could start moving in him. But soon I was fucking him hard and fast as I grasped his hips with both hands.

With each forward motion, my body slammed into his spanked ass, and the sensation seemed to drive him wild. He braced his hands against the ottoman and started rocking back forcefully, meeting each thrust while moaning with pleasure.

In a matter of minutes, my orgasm crashed into me. Theo ground out, “Fuck yeah, come in me,” which made everything that much more intense.

As soon as I finished, I slid out of his hole and dropped into a crouch to catch my breath. He still hadn’t come, and my plan was to suck him off. But he sat up and asked, “How do you feel about me finishing inside you?”

“I can’t imagine anything better.” It was the truth. The very thought of it made me shiver with pleasure.

We switched places, and Theo took his time working me open. I just relaxed and let him lead the way. He kissed me and whispered to me soothingly as he finger-fucked my tight hole, and I marveled at how easy it was to let him take charge. Then I realized it all came down to the fact that I felt safe with him, and I trusted him completely.

When he thought I was ready, he lubed up and wiped his hands on the towel, then pressed the tip of his cock against my hole. I was on my back on the ottoman with my knees bent and my feet firmly planted, and I exhaled slowly. It had been years since I’d bottomed, and I wouldn’t exactly call those times pleasurable, so there were definitely a few mental barriers to overcome.

It helped a lot when Theo instructed me to push out while he pushed in. As soon as I did that, I opened up enough for his cock to slip into my ass. My breath caught, and it stung for a moment. He held still and told me, “You’re doing great, Casey.”