When it was fully inside her, he turned it on high. He stroked his cock as he watched, until he realized the thing was vibrating itself out of her. That wouldn’t do, and he pushed it back in with the hand not holding his shaft.
Then he had a better idea.
“You ever been fucked up the ass, Kelsey?”
She didn’t answer right away, and he tore away his gaze from her sex to look at her face. “I asked a question,” he said warningly.
“Yes, sir,” she answered.
This annoyed him. He’d wanted to be her first. Who had taken her anal virginity? That Adam guy she was with in college? That dick Steve Hardin? Never mind. It didn’t matter. He would forgive her for every guy she’d ever been with. She belonged to him now, and him alone.
He pulled the vibrator out of her and set it carefully upright on the shelf. He reached for the lanyard he now wore around his neck, on which he’d placed the padlock keys to her cuffs. Leaning forward, he released her wrists cuffs, leaving them dangling from the chains so he could lock her up again when he was done with her.
“Turn over,” he said brusquely. “On your hands and knees. I’m going to fuck your ass.” He didn’t admit he himself was in fact the virgin in this particular equation. He’d wanted to have anal sex with Emily, but the bitch had refused him. Kelsey wouldn’t refuse him, though. She wouldn’t dare.
He watched with satisfaction as she rolled over and pulled herself up on her hands and knees. He crouched behind her, his cock bobbing at full erection. “While I fuck your ass, your job is to make sure that vibrator stays inside your cunt. You hold it in place. If it falls out, I’ll have to punish you.”
She twisted her head back to face him, the fear ripe in her clear green eyes. “Please, James, I don’t want—”
“I didn’t tell you to speak, Kelsey!” James shouted over her. He would have to write up a list of rules for her like he saw on so many of those training sites. Number one would be: no talking unless asked a direct question.
She turned her head forward again and hunched her shoulders. She made a snuffling sound. He realized she might be crying, and his heart seized suddenly with pity. What was he doing?
Then he remembered the hatred that had twisted her features into something ugly as she’d pointed the gun at him, ready to shoot him at point blank range, and his heart hardened. He grabbed the vibrator from the shelf and pushed it back inside the girl. “Hold on to it,” he commanded as he flicked it to high. He smacked one welted ass cheek for emphasis. “Go on, do it. Now.”
He was pleased when she obeyed, reaching back and covering the base of the vibrator with her fingers. How many lonely nights had she fucked herself with that thing, while dreaming of her one true love?
“He’s here now,” James wanted to say, but of course he did not. She wouldn’t believe it. Not yet.
He reached for the tube of lubricant from the shelf and rubbed it on the head of his cock, smearing the excess left on his fingers over the tight bud of her asshole. She pulled away from his touch. “Don’t move,” he ordered tersely.
He touched her asshole with the tip of his finger and then pushed it in to the first knuckle. “Relax,” he soothed. “It’ll be a lot easier if you can relax.” He pushed his finger in to the second knuckle. Kelsey yelped and jerked again. James ignored this as he moved his finger, working to relax her sphincter muscles. He would hold her still while he fucked her.
He withdrew his finger and positioned himself between her legs. When he nudged the head of his lubricated cock between her cheeks, Kelsey’s hand fell away from the vibrator as she jerked forward.
“Damn it, Kelsey. I’m warning you. Get back in position. Hold that thing in place.” He waited, silently counting until she reached again for the dildo. “Good girl,” he said encouragingly, pleased he’d only had to count to two. “Now, just relax.”
He nudged again against her sphincter with his cock, and pushed past the ring of muscle. Kelsey grunted, but stayed in position. As James eased himself into her ass, he could feel the vibrator’s girth pressing against the thin membrane that separated her rectum from her cunt.
Fucking her ass was different from fucking her cunt, which hugged his shaft like a warm velvet glove. This felt more like a tight band that stroked his cock as he moved in and out, and the vibrations from the dildo made the experience all the more intense.
Kelsey cried out as he pushed himself deeper inside her ass. He gripped her hips and began to thrust in and out of the tight, hot hole. She was being a good girl, her fingers still curled around the base of the vibrator in spite the awkwardness of her position.