“Tonight, you are taking them. We’re here for you,” Ben added over her shoulder as he pressed his erection between her ass cheeks.
She closed her eyes and felt herself blush at the sensation.
Wyatt kissed her lips, rolled to his back, taking her with him.
Anna straddled his hips and was grateful that her hips weren’t the least bit sore.
They fought one another for control over the kiss, and Anna rubbed her mound against his hard cock. She felt the bed dip then give as Ben left the bed but returned a few seconds later.
Wyatt released her lips and scooted toward the edge of the bed so his legs hung off.
“I want to feel that hot, tight pussy, baby. Come on, now,” he growled at her, then effortlessly lifted her up, placing her onto his engorged cock.
Anna threw her head back and moaned at the intrusion. She was sore from last night but wet and ready for her sheriff.
The thought made her smile.
“I love the way your tits swing and bounce when we’re making love. It was all I dreamt about last night,” Wyatt whispered as he fondled and played with her breasts while she rode him. Anna picked up the pace until she felt Ben move in behind her.
“You trust us, baby, don’t ya?” Ben asked as he slowly pressed her down further against Wyatt’s chest.
She nodded, and Wyatt took her mouth again while he plunged up and down into her.
Anna joined the rhythm, lifting and thrusting onto his cock and loving the feeling of control.
She felt Ben’s hands caress her ass cheeks, and she paused a moment to catch her breath.
“Easy, darling. We’re going to take this nice and slow.”
“What, Ben?” she asked, out of breath with anticipation.
“I want to fuck this tight, pretty, virgin ass of yours, darling. I’m just gonna get you ready,” he whispered as he kissed her neck, sucking hard as he rubbed his engorged cock against her ass.
Wyatt reached between them and played with her lips before spreading some cream along her puckered hole.
Anna gasped at the sensation, while Ben lightly held her chest down against Wyatt’s.
Wyatt pressed his finger in, while he pumped up and into her channel.
“Ahhhh…Oh my.” Anna moaned while she held on to Wyatt.
Then she felt something cold and moist as Ben pressed his finger into her anus. She moaned, then wiggled her ass, wanting his fingers deeper to increase the pleasure pain she felt.
It was erotic and burned her insides, yet her pussy flooded with moisture in response.
“That’s it, Anna, just like that, fuck my fingers while you fuck Wyatt’s cock,” Ben whispered as he pressed his body against Anna’s and thrust his finger onto her. She moved up and down, back and forth whatever way possible so she could feel more of the strange sensation.
Ben added a second finger and thrust in and out while scissoring side to side.
Anna moaned then pressed forward as Wyatt pulled her mouth to his.
He kissed her deeply while he ground his hips up and into her. He scooted lower on the bed as Ben pulled his fingers out. Anna protested until she felt his cock take their place.
“Relax, honey, and we’ll make you feel so good.” Ben pressed forward, and Wyatt nibbled lightly on Anna’s tongue.
Anna lifted up, then back, forcing Ben to shove into her faster than he intended.
“Fuck, Anna!” he growled as he grabbed her hips to stop her movements.