I gently slid my fingers in and out of Logan as the sound of the singers passed by the window.
“Ever think you’d get fucked to the sound of college students singing classic rock songs outside?”
He laughed, a low, sweet sound. “There’s a whole lot of things about tonight I never dreamed would happen to me.”
I took my fingers out of him and he made a small whimper, like he already missed the feeling. The sound of the students’ singing and laughter slowly faded away as they walked off down our street.
“I’ve got you,” I said, my voice low. I reached for the condom, unwrapping it and rolling it over my cock before slicking it up with lube. I pulled him up by his hips until he was on all fours in front of me, spread and waiting, a beautiful sight.
When I started to push into his hole he let out a low, deep moan like nothing I’d ever heard out of him before. Christ, he was warm. I wanted to sink into him all the way. I wanted so much more but I held back, going as slow as possible, letting him adjust.
“You really are tight,” I murmured, sucking in a breath of air.
“I want more,” he said, tilting his head back to give me a look. There was almost a ferocity in his gaze.
“I’m not giving you more than you can take,” I warned him.
He started to push back against my cock with his hips, sinking a little further back onto me, and my cock throbbed at the sensation.
“Fuck,” he hissed.
“I told you.”
“Still worth it,” he said, slowing down a little. “Now give me more.”
“Demanding, demanding,” I said, a smile coming over my face.
“You love it.”
“God, I do,” I said, biting my lower lip as I pushed just a little further into him. Every move I made elicited another delicious sound from Logan. He swore under his breath, moaned, and sighed more than I’d ever imagined.
There had been a lot of things I hadn’t expected with Logan, but this may have been the most unexpected of all. I was so used to seeing him keeping all of his feelings tightly under control. He went through life never showing too much to the outside world, but right here, right now with me, I was getting an unfiltered view.
He had totally let loose. And it only made me want to fuck him even harder.
In another couple of minutes, I was fully inside him. He definitely took my cock like a champ, and I could tell he loved the feeling of having something inside him. I squeezed his cheeks, trying to come back down to Earth. And then slowly, surely, I started to be able to sink into him, over and over. I waited to hear the change in his breath, to know that he was opening up to me.
When he started to push back against me, I knew he was ready.
And I also knew he trusted me, in a way he’d never been able to with anyone else before. It felt like a privilege, a responsibility I didn’t want to screw up. I got to show him just how good this could be.
“God, you feel so good,” Logan uttered, sliding back against me. “Is it always this fucking good?”
Strangely, I was having similar thoughts, even though I was way more experienced than him. This was the way sex was supposed to feel—the way I liked it best. I wasn’t just thinking about getting off, or wondering when it was the right time to come. It wasn’t sex just for the sake of having a hookup.
I didn’t just want Logan to come, I wanted him to feel fucking amazing.
“Touch yourself,” I said, my words coming out breathless.
“What?”
“You heard me,” I said. “Touch yourself.”
“I’ll totally ruin your sheets if I—”
“I’ve got another set.”
“Fuck,” he moaned, and I saw as he reached to grip his cock in his hand, slowly starting to tug. “I’m going to come so fast if I do this.”
I slowed down my thrusts, just for a while, letting the moment draw out. I fucked him deep and slow as he started to stroke his own cock, and I swore the sight was enough to take me to the brink of coming, too.
“I didn’t even know,” Logan was saying between breaths. “Didn’t even know it could feel this good.”
Hearing him say it shot a thrill through me. It had been a while since I was with a virgin, and part of me had wondered what it might be like. But in this moment, nothing could have been hotter to me. I got to be Logan’s first time. I got to give him this experience, to make it as good for him as I could.
I got to share something with him, for the first time ever. And it felt more like an amazing opportunity than any sort of burden.