“It’s okay. I trust you.”
Those words out of Sara’s mouth slayed me. Because even after all we’d done and been through, there was still a not-so-little part of me that worried she didn’t trust me. Or that she was just biding time with me. But Sara wouldn’t do this unless she was sure. And that trust, that faith she was putting in me, well, it was a gift.
“You can trust me too,” Sara said after a moment, and I realized I’d been sitting there, quiet. “I have an IUD, and I’m clean.”
“Oh, baby, you don’t have to worry about that. I’ve never trusted anyone with that before but it’s not even a question with you.” I brought her hand up to my lips and kissed her knuckles. “I’m just kinda in awe here, hippie. You’re the most incredible woman I’ve ever been with. And I never thought we’d be here, is all. I’ve wanted it for so long.”
Her head cocked to the side and she frowned, that plump bottom lip of hers jutting out the smallest bit.
“I never knew you felt that way.”
“I guess I didn’t let myself show it.”
She leaned close to me and I met her lips in a sweet, tender kiss. But it didn’t stay that way for long. The electricity between us rose with each swipe of our tongues and lips and teeth.
I stood up, pulled down my sweatpants and fisted my cock in my hand. It was throbbing, painfully hard after all that I’d done to her, and now, knowing she wanted me to fuck her raw, it was about to explode. I needed to calm down and think about baseball stats or something.
But then she reached for me. And I was under the spell of my magic woman all over again. I climbed on top of her, lined up at her entrance, met her lips with mine again, and then pushed into heaven.
We both gasped.
“Are you okay?” I breathed out. Please be okay.
“Yes… you’re just… so big. Give me a second.”
“I know, baby. Just relax. Take as much time as you need.”
I tried to not let my manly pride turn me into a douchebag, but fuck, that felt good to hear her say. I kept a straight face and stayed as still as my shaking muscles would allow. Sara’s pussy felt so fucking good, I was wired tight and about to explode. But then she breathed in deeply and I felt her body relax.
Her legs came up to wrap around my waist, and with the shifting of our bodies, my cock slid in the last extra bit to the hilt. Christ.
“Okay I’m ready. I’m good.”
“You sure?”
“Yes.” She looked me in the eyes and smiled. “Please fuck me.”
And that about did it. Without even realizing it, my body began to move. A slow pace that had me pulling almost all the way out before taking her again and again. Each time I pushed deep inside her felt like paradise. And when she started swirling her hips up to meet my thrusts, I couldn’t help it but go faster.
“God you feel so fucking good, baby. This perfect cunt is so tight around me.” I grunted out, barely able to speak with the quickening rhythm of my hips.
“Yes!” She cried out, her head falling back against the pillow and thrashing from side to side as my cock pumped into her again and again. Her muscles squeezed me and I moved faster, unable to control myself. I brought my thumb down to circle her clit, loving that she was so responsive.
“You love this dick, don’t you?”
“Yes yes yes…” she repeated over and over again, music to my ears.
“Open your eyes, baby.”
She complied and I was met with those gorgeous browns looking back at me through hooded eyelids, face full of pleasure.
“I need to see them when I make you come again for me.”
She cried out, a senseless noise, and kept her hips moving in time with mine. I thrusted, over and over again and again. More. I needed to give her more. I needed to give her everything.
I sat up higher, grabbing her legs and resting them on my shoulders. The angle gave me deeper access and my hips pumped harder than ever. Her face scrunched together, her lips parted, heaving breaths filling her lungs as she took my dick. And when I circled that little clit at the same time my cock thrusted upward to reach that perfect spot, she cried out my name and I felt her muscles tighten and contract as she came on me.
“Fuck yes, baby. Come on this dick.”
“Theo omygodomygodomygod Theo!”
“Mmm that pussy feels so good when it comes,” I said, slowing my rhythm but not much, because I was damn close and I couldn’t control it much longer.
“Where do you want me to come, baby?”
Her eyes were glassy with pleasure, but she looked up at me with so much adoration—and a good hint of seduction—I about lost it.
“I want you to come where you want. Anywhere you want.”
I almost shot my load right there at her words and the look in her eyes, but I held off. For at least another minute.
“Deep inside you, baby?”
“Mmm yes.”
“You want me to fill you up with my cum?”
“Yes, Theo, please!”
And fuck, but that did it. I thrusted deep into her once, twice more, and then exploded. My vision went blank as sparks flew off behind my eyes. I called out her name as I felt the biggest jolt of pleasure I could ever remember having, pumping myself into her sweet pussy.
Marking her as mine.