His Sacrifice

I dug my nails into the leather horse and tried to breathe through my nose as panic welled inside me. My air was cut off, and Ted held me in place as Caleb pushed a finger into my asshole.

“I bet she’s a virgin.” Caleb pressed around the edges of hole, then added another finger.

“Her pussy took my cock like a champ, so I doubt it. Her ass, though.” Ted finally pulled back, and I gasped in air. “Maybe.” He pulled my head up to him, spit dripping down my chin. “Have you ever been fucked in the ass before?”

Caleb pushed his fingers in deeper, the feeling alien and nearing on pain.

“N-no.”

“Didn’t think so.” Ted pushed my head back down and shoved his cock into my mouth.

“Good.” Caleb pulled his fingers out, then spit on my hole. “I like being first.”

“Makes me jealous.” Ted pulled his cock out and slapped it on my cheek. “But I hate to give up this mouth.”

I winced as Caleb used his thumbs to spread my cheeks, then pressed his cock against my asshole.

“It won’t fit.” I tried to surge forward, but was met with Ted’s cock. He pushed it into my mouth and rocked his hips.

“Suck me. I want to feel your tongue on my balls, pretty Cate.”

My breath stopped as he lodged himself in my throat. I kept gagging, but couldn’t expel him.

He pushed deeper. “Tongue out.”

I eased my tongue over my lips, the tip tracing the skin of his balls.

He jerked back, then forward again. At least I could take a breath. But it was quickly erased by the searing pain in my ass.

“Jesus.” Caleb spread me even wider. “Her ass is tighter than anything I’ve ever felt.”

Tears came to my eyes as his cock entered me, then pushed slowly deeper.

I can’t take it. I screamed, but the sound ended on Ted’s cock as he kept my head still and face fucked me.

My ass burned, and my lips ached, but I couldn’t stop what was happening. There was no way out for me.

When Caleb reached around my thigh and found my clit, I fought his touch. But arching my back only sent him deeper, his cock like a piston in and out of my ass. And when I tried to bow my back instead, Caleb pressed two fingers inside my pussy.

My eyes rolled back, the heat in my ass and the fullness in my pussy overwhelming me.

“She likes it.” Ted grabbed my chin and pulled my gaze to his as his cock slid against my tongue. “Don’t you, Cate? You like being treated like this.”

I shook my head, a weak protest as Caleb’s fingers returned to my clit.

“Fuck, you trying to make me blow on your pretty face?” Ted gripped his cock. “Stick your tongue out.”

I obeyed. He slapped his cock head on my tongue, then rubbed it back and forth, smearing wetness on my lips and chin.

I panted as Caleb fingered my clit, his cock a thick intruder in my ass.

“You want to come again?” Ted teased his cock around my lips. “I know you do.” He reached down and unstrapped one wrist, then the other.

I sat up and tried to swing at Ted, but Caleb pulled my arms behind me and slipped his arm through my elbows. He pulled me tight against him, his cock still in my ass, and my ankles trapped in the leather straps.

Ted eased onto the horse in front of me, then grabbed a handful of my hair and pulled my head back. Caleb’s mouth found mine, his tongue invading me in the same brutal strokes of his cock. Ted’s hot mouth circled one nipple, and he snaked a hand to my pussy.

“No,” I cried into Caleb’s mouth.

He thrust inside me and increased the pressure on my arms, forcing my back to arch so he could slide deeper.

Ted grabbed my chin and turned my face to his, taking my mouth in a scorching kiss as he pushed two fingers inside me and used the palm of his hand to massage my clit.

Pressed between them like a flower in the pages of a book, I had no escape. Caleb kept fucking my ass, each stroke pain and pleasure mixed. Ted’s fingers played me, continually stoking the heat that pooled between my legs and drenched my hot skin. His mouth was just as wicked, his tongue teasing me and stealing my breath. Keeping one hand at my throat, Ted squeezed, stopping my breath until my lungs burned. When he let go, euphoria cascaded through my blood.

He constricted my breath again, and everything inside me wound tight, my legs trembling as he continued working my clit. Each stroke from Caleb’s thick cock had my eyes fluttering closed, the lack of oxygen making the edges of my vision go dark.

But when Ted let go, my release exploded inside me. I gasped as the pleasure sliced through me, cutting away my protests and drowning me. I moaned loudly as Ted bit down on my nipple, Caleb’s grip hardening on my hips as my pussy pulsed.