My gaze wanders over her face, and even though I know I’m making a mistake and causing further damage, I can’t bring myself to do the right thing this time.
I wrap my other arm around her waist and draw her closer until her body is pressed right up against mine, until the gleam in those pretty eyes comes from vulnerability I don’t deserve.
She should push me away or slap me. She should storm off and tell me to go fuck myself for jerking her around the way I have, but as I draw her face closer, she wraps her arms around my neck instead. She closes her eyes and leans the rest of the way, and when my lips brush hers, she kisses me back.
Lust roars through my veins as her soft lips give under mine. It’s a slow, soft kiss, but I don’t take my time deepening it. My tongue darts out to push between her lips, demanding entrance. She grants it, opening up as she arches into me. My hand slides from her waist down to her ass. I grab it, pulling her against the hard bulge in my jeans.
The moan that slips out of her seals her fate. Before I can think better of it, I’m opening the driver side door and hoisting her inside.
Wordlessly, Alyssa scoots back to make room for me. She’s so fucking pretty lying there, propped up on her elbows, legs spread just enough to make me want more.
Before I climb in and get on top of her, I push up her flirty little dress and pull down her panties, flinging them over into the passenger side floorboard.
Fire rages through my veins knowing her pussy is uncovered now. I want to look at it and taste it and fuck it, and I don’t have time to do all of that during a parking lot quickie while her fucking date waits with her elephant ear and lemonade.
That’s so fucking twisted. Just thinking about it that way, I should stop, but it only makes me yearn harder to mark my territory. Let that little fuck hold her elephant ear while I’m driving my cock into her pussy and making her cry out my name.
I let my cock out to play and climb on top of Alyssa, pulling the door shut behind me. She looks up at me like she knows this is wrong, too, but she wants me enough to do it anyway, and for the first time, I can imagine how Theo ended up between her pretty legs. Convinced as I am that I’m better than he is, there’s not a goddamn thing that could stop me from fucking this girl right now.
This isn’t the time for tenderness and foreplay, so I shove her dress up, pry open her thighs, and sink a finger inside her to make sure she’s ready to take my cock.
Alyssa moans and writhes, her eyes drifting closed as she gives herself up to the pleasure of my touch.
The memory of her nestled between someone else’s legs just a few minutes ago makes me more territorial. I lean down to kiss her hard while I push a second finger in and tell her, “This is mine, you understand me? You don’t let anyone else play with it.”
Her eyes open and she narrows them at me. “You’ve got a lot of nerve, you know that?”
I rub my thumb across her clit and she gasps. Catching that delightful little sound on my lips, I tell her, “Yes, I do.”
“You told me to move on,” she reminds me.
“I was wrong,” I state, pulling my fingers out of her and grabbing my cock. “Turns out, I don’t want you going anywhere.”
“Sure, you think that now because you saw me here with somebody else and got jealous. What are you going to think two days from now when I’m in your bed and you actually have me? Will you be hit by another burst of fucking nobility and decide I deserve better?”
“Can’t say for sure,” I tell her truthfully, guiding my cock to her pussy and then shoving in without warning.
Alyssa groans, arching up off the seat and grabbing my sides as I sink deeper inside her. “You’re impossible,” she tells me breathlessly.
“Now you see why I’m single.” I’m feeling all sorts of relief now that she’s back where she’s supposed to be—under me, and full of my cock.
“The mystery is solved,” she agrees, even as she locks her legs around my hips to take me deeper into her body.
The time for talking is about to pass, so I let her know without a word, dipping my head and crushing my lips against hers. She responds to the hardness and hunger in my kiss with softness and nourishment of her own, offering and offering to me even though she knows I keep taking and taking.