“Ready?”
He nods. “I’ve been dying for this.”
Just barely, I push into him, letting the crown of my cock get sucked into his tightness. Blinding pleasure rocks me to my core. The urge to drive into him is maddening, but I refuse to hurt him.
“Fuck,” he whispers, his eyes wild in the mirror.
“You make it sound like you like it,” I rumble. “You’re making me jealous. Maybe I want you in my ass one day.”
He groans, his ass clenching. “Whatever you want. I’ll give you whatever you want.”
I’m not sure if I want that, but I’m curious as hell. He’s coming undone and I’ve barely inched inside him. Slowly, I push into his hot, constricting body. All I’ve ever known is one pussy and Penn. His ass is the best fucking place I’ve ever had the pleasure of sticking my dick in. A low moan echoes around us, and I realize it’s mine. He feels so damn good. As soon as my pelvis presses against his ass, indicating I’m completely inside him, I lose control. My hands frantically claw at him, needing more. I pull him up right, seeking his mouth. He turns his head and meets my kiss at the awkward angle, just as eager for my lips.
“I’m fucking you,” I whisper against his lips. “I’m inside you. Deep inside your ass. How does it feel?”
He moans into my mouth. “It feels perfect. Long overdue. Everything.” His breath exhales sharply. “Now move your hips, Justice. Fuck me.”
His words send me over the edge. I push him back down so I can see over his head in the mirror. My hips piston slowly against him at first, but then I’m quickly unraveling. The urge to come is intense, but I want to prolong this feeling forever. It feels insane and wild and out of this world. I can’t get enough.
My fingertips dig into his hips as I fuck him hard. Relentlessly. Crazed. He pushes out against me, eager for the punishing my dick is delivering to him. I slide my hand around to his front to yank on his cock. He cries out in pleasure, his ass clenching tightly around me.
Fuck, this is blowing my mind.
His cock is hot and throbbing in my grip. Soon, he’ll climax. I bring him to the edge again and then let go, loving the flare of madness in his eyes.
When he goes to grab it, I thrust my hips hard enough that tears spring in his eyes.
“Don’t fucking touch it,” I growl. “I want you to come just watching me fuck you. Eyes here, McAlister. Look who’s fucking you. Your best goddamn friend in the world.”
His face scrunches up as he locks his eyes with mine. A choked sound escapes him and then my eyes are staring in the mirror as I watch cum shoot from his beautiful dick. It shoots into the bowl of the sink, making a mess, and it’s hot as hell. I let out a surprised sound when my own nuts seize up unexpectedly. Pleasure pulsates down my spine and through my cock as I come hard. My dick throbs in tandem with the clenching of his ass. I thrust and thrust and thrust until I’m dripping with sweat and no longer hard. I just want to fuck him forever.
Now soft, my dick slides easily out of his ass. The condom is full, but I wish it were his ass instead.
“I wish I could fill your tight ass up with my cum,” I tell him, grabbing his ass affectionately. “I want to prop you up on my bed and fuck you so many times, filling you to the fucking brim.”
He turns around and pulls the used condom from my dick. “So do it.”
“I…let me get tested first. I only slept with one person and used condoms religiously, but who knows who all she slept with behind my back,” I grumble. “I’d just feel safer getting tested.” Ivy was my girlfriend, but she’s a vindictive woman. So if she was mad at me, which she was often, then I wouldn’t put it past her to fuck someone just to sate her inner desire for revenge. And I’ll be damned if I ever put Penn in danger.
“Fine,” he concedes. “But then you get to fuck me bare whenever you want.” He smirks. “Were you serious about what you said or was that just heat of the moment?”
I walk past him to turn on the shower, not answering him at first. The idea of him inside of me is a forbidden one that entices me like no other. Six months ago, I would’ve laughed if someone told me one day I’d want a dick up my ass. Now…now I’m not so sure. As if hearing my internal thoughts, Penn picks up the bottle of lube before heading over to the shower. I frown at him, panic swelling inside of me.