Six Single Dads' Nanny (Love by Numbers 5)

“Do you really wanna feel good?” I asked. Jordan nodded her head. I took my hand from her mouth and poked her ass. “Do you remember when we fucked your ass?”

“I loved getting my ass fucked,” Jordan responded.

“Have you ever done both?” I asked. “Pussy and ass?” I rubbed her clit faster and faster until she started to shudder and came on Ethan’s cock. Ethan had a mischievous smile on his face as he heard me make the plan.

“No,” Jordan said, “but I want to.”

“Are you sure? It may hurt at first,” I told her.

Jordan nodded. “I like pain.”

Ethan smacked her ass hard, leaving a bright red imprint of his hand behind. “Yeah you do.”

I was thrilled. I pulled out some lube and prepared her the same way Ethan had before, starting with one finger until her hole was easily giving way, and then I added a second finger. I even went the extra mile to work her asshole until I could add a third finger. I wanted to reduce the pain as much as possible. Once she was loose enough, I added a copious amount of lube to my dick, and then I slowly started to move inside.

“Ah,” Jordan moaned, and I stopped but she pushed back against me. “No, keep going.”

I kept pressing inside of her and I felt like I was going to pass out. I could feel everything. I could feel every muscle of her asshole, and I could feel Ethan’s cock filling up her pussy. The feeling was beyond good. It was unlike anything I’d ever felt before. I started slowly, but Jordan was insatiable, and she increased our pace until Ethan and I were both fucking her at a rapid pace with her screaming out.

“Yes! Fuck me! Fuck my ass and my pussy!” Jordan screamed. “Come in my ass and my pussy.”

“Fuck, you aren’t gonna have to tell me twice,” Ethan said.

I shook my head. “Me either.”

We were going to have to get her going again at a later date, because neither Ethan nor I had prepared for how good it was going to feel filling Jordan up entirely and watching her come multiple times on our rock hard cocks up both of her holes. Finally, we both pushed all the way in and Jordan’s eyes looked like they were going to come flying out of her head. Her entire lower body started to shake as she dominated us with an overwhelming orgasm, and snatched our souls from our bodies, pulling equally powerful orgasms out of each of us. I wasn’t even sure what happened after that moment, I just remembered the feeling of having Jordan at her tightest squeezed around my dick.

When I woke up the next morning, neither Jordan nor Ethan was still in bed. I got up and went downstairs and found Jordan sitting on the couch.

“Good morning,” I greeted.

She smiled at me, tilting her head up. “Good morning.”

I met her with a kiss and then sat on the couch next to her. “How are you feeling? We didn’t hurt you, did we?”

“A little,” she replied honestly, “but I liked it.”

I rubbed her leg. “Well that’s all that matters. I did too, if that helps.”

She nodded. “It does.”

“Where’s Ethan?” I asked.

“He was gone when I woke up this morning. He said he had to go get the boys from his mom’s because Davin was sick,” she explained. “Is it weird that I wanted to go find them? Like it’s my kid or something.”

“No, that’s not weird,” I replied. “You love them. You love all the kids. You mean so much more to them than you realize. You’re so good to them.”

“I feel like it’s them who are good to me,” she responded. “The other day, Ricky told me that he thought I should be king of the world. Then when Nova told him girls were queens not kings, he said I should be queen and king of the world.” She giggled. “He’s so cute I can’t stand it.”

It warmed my heart to see how much she cared about my son. It was enough to make any man crazy about a girl. “He really loves you.”

“I really love him,” she replied, then she sighed. “And he’s not the only one.”

“No, it’s clear you love all the kids,” he said.

Jordan shook her head. “That’s not what I mean.” She turned and looked at me.

My heart pounded. “Me?”

She nodded. “All of you. I really feel like I’m falling in love with all of you. Is that possible for one person to love six guys? Can I love six men at one time?”

I didn’t know how to respond to what she’d just confessed to me, so I just remained quiet. Was Jordan really falling in love with us? More than that? Was I falling in love with her?