Jenny (Babysitter's Club 5)

She teased the head up and down her slit, and I wanted to know where the fuck she’d learned that, but told myself maybe it was just instinct. Her blood had been on my sheets that night; no one else had ever had her, no one else ever will. The words whispered through my head.

When she was through playing, she slipped just my cockhead inside her tight cunt and held it there. I looked down at her dazed eyes and brushed the hair back from her face. “Ready?” At her nod, I fucked through the fingers she still had around my shaft and buried my cock in her belly.

She screeched and arched off the bed at the force of my cock, hitting bottom. I eased out and drove back in, watching her eyes for any sign that I was hurting her. Her tight pussy clung to my cock like a second layer of skin, making it almost impossible to fuck into her at will. Fast and hard was the only way to go.

But I wanted to take my time, to savor, so after a few hard strokes to loosen her up, with the help of my precum and her pussy’s natural juices, I was able to hit her the way I wanted. Nice, slow, deep. She cried out each time I bottomed out in her, but they were screams of pleasure.

For the first time in way too long, I felt the true pleasure of making love. It wasn’t the rush of something new I’d experienced as a kid with his first taste of snatch, neither was it the pleasure I’d experienced with one woman for the past six years.

This was different; being inside her filled my head and heart with things that I’d never felt before with anyone else. I looked down at her in wonder to find her staring up at me with all the love she’d professed shining in her eyes.

I almost pulled out of her in surprise at the intensity of what I felt. I never knew that a pussy was supposed to make you stupid. Didn’t know that one could get inside your head and make you start weaving shit in your head. Like happily ever after and sleepy mornings spent in bed wrapped around each other.

I saw that and more as I moved inside her. And when she reached up and stroked my cheek before pulling my head down to hers, I felt that shit in my heart and gut. My head was full of her; I couldn’t think of anything else.

Everything about her wrapped itself around me until there was nothing else but her. Her pussy breathed around my cock and sucked, pulling me in even deeper, and I never wanted to leave her, never wanted the wild feelings beating away at me to end.

I almost gave her the words that I knew deep down was too soon to share. “What’re you doing to me?” She lifted up and put her lips to my ear. “Have you ever heard of the power of the pussy?” She bit my ear, and I pulled back and looked at her.

“The what?” She didn’t answer, not with her lips anyway, but she used her pussy to prove her point. Her pussy tightened and released around my cock in a kind of rhythm that I couldn’t help but follow. The more I tried to go slow, the more she squeezed my cock until I picked up speed.

“You’re too tight, stop, I don’t want to hurt you.” She dug her nails in my ass and wrapped her legs around my waist, opening her pussy more, tilting her hips so that now my cock was drilling into her without obstruction.

I felt somehow like she was spurring me on to something like she had some hidden agenda, and I got my answer with her next words. “Let go, Derrick, just let go you won’t hurt me, you didn’t that night, you won’t now.”

So that’s her game, she wanted me to treat her the way I did that night, she wanted to relive the night I’d stolen from her by not remembering. I pulled out without warning, and she fussed at me. “Behave!” I slapped her ass after putting her on her hands and knees in front of me.

This time when I drove into her, I didn’t hold back. She went wild, tearing at the sheets, throwing her pussy back at me hard as she looked back over her shoulder at me, just like I remembered.

I didn’t think about protection until my balls drew up against my body, and I felt the first volley of cum fly out of my cock into her unprotected womb. “Fuck, Jenny, are you on the pill?” She didn’t answer, and when I tried pulling out of her in a fruitless effort to protect her, she clamped down on my cock and sucked my balls dry.