Caged: A Dark Mafia Romance

Could he be doing this as a way to scare me? Maybe he wanted me to beg and plead. Maybe this was a form of punishment—make me think he was going to shove that tail into my ass. A sick mind game.

“As I was saying. I can’t give you a small or simple tail. You have to be the most impressive. In my world, bigger is better.” He motioned for me to lie down on the bed. “And after your actions this morning, I’m not really going to feel sorry for you. Consider it a consequence.”

I didn’t move. This was not a bluff or a threat. This was really going to happen, but I froze rather than doing what I knew he wanted me to do. Not out of defiance but because the shock of what was happening paralyzed me.

“Lie down on your stomach. I’ll be gentle unless you test my patience.”

Imagining Eddie being anything but gentle with that tail had me quickly complying as he asked. I positioned my body just as I had the night before when he had taken his belt to me.

“Every pet tonight will have a tail of some sort. Though all the pets are different, which makes it all the more interesting. You’ll be the most elegant of them all by the time we’re done.”

I heard the lube squeeze out again and then felt Eddie’s finger touch the seam of my ass. He didn’t stop there, but continued on until his finger pressed against my anus. I tightened up and tried to squeeze my ass cheeks closed.

“Trust me. You’re going to thank me for this when the tail gets inserted. I advise you to allow me lube you up.”

Was this man fucking serious? I would thank him?

“Spread your legs wider,” he said as he nudged them apart with his legs. The action made it easier for his slick fingertip to reach my anus.

I gasped at the invasive touch and closed my eyes tightly. I needed for this to just get over with, and I made a mental decision right then and there not to fight it.

He applied some pressure on my hole, which sent an electric shiver up and then back down my spine. I expected to hate every second of this, and yet my throbbing pussy once again betrayed me. I hated that my legs were spread wide because I was almost positive that Eddie had a full view of my sex that was getting wetter with every swirl of his finger on my anus.

“It’s a shame this ass of yours hasn’t been fucked before. You’re truly missing out,” Eddie said as he pressed his finger a little harder on my puckered flesh.

“Says the man who I’m sure hasn’t had his ass fucked either,” I countered back, trying hard not to focus on my growing desire.

Eddie laughed loudly. “Touché.”

I was rewarded for my snarky retort by having the metal plug placed on my asshole and pressed in without giving me enough time to prepare. It slid in but spread me the entire way.

“Oh, my God,” I moaned as I clung to the bedding on the mattress. “It’s too big. I can’t. I can’t.” I felt sweat beading on my skin and my breath hitched as the tail burrowed deeper inside of me.

“You’re doing just fine,” Eddie said as he placed one of his large hands on my lower back to ensure I stayed in place.

I mewled like a kitten as I writhed on the bed.

I had truly become his pet.

The plug was deep inside of me, and I could feel the fur of the tail against my still sensitive ass from the earlier punishment.

Eddie reached for my upper arm and took hold. It didn’t hurt, but his grasp was tight. He forced me to sit on the edge of the bed even though the tail was now being pressed inside of me even deeper. He knelt down and reached inside the box, pulling out a long chain and metal choker. The metal was adorned with diamonds all around it. I had no doubt it was by far the most expensive torture device ever made.

“You don’t need to chain me,” I said as panic began to set in. “I have no intention of trying to escape.”

He didn’t reply but instead grabbed me by the back of the neck, pulled my head into him, and clasped the collar around my neck, securely locking it into place. It was tight enough that when I swallowed, I could feel my flesh connect with the cool restraint.

Tugging on the collar to make sure it was locked, Eddie said, “You’ll remain collared and in this tail until I say otherwise.”

I reached for the collar and tried to pull it away from the front of my neck to no avail. “Please. It makes it hard to breathe.”