To have been that close to Tyler, share that kind of intimacy only for him to never look back must feel like you’ve lost something. I know he’s always been honest with them upfront, never leading anyone on, but at that moment, I felt a pang of sadness for the poor girls who had to know now that I was in the picture that their chances were null and void, especially when Ty crossed the room and took me in his arms for a kiss.
They made their excuses soon after, but not before another few pointed looks from Penny that I’m sure meant not to forget what we’d been discussing before he showed up. Ty didn’t say anything about what he overheard when he walked in, but I knew better than to trust that. Since I didn’t want to outright lie to him, I didn’t even dare bring it up.
TYLER
“What were you girls talking about earlier when I walked in?” She stopped moving beneath me at the whisper in her ear. All evening I hadn’t mentioned anything about it to her. One, I didn’t want her to have to lie to me, two, I didn’t want her to betray her ‘friends.’ This way, when I fuck it out of her, it would be all on me.
She looked like a deer in headlights as she looked up at me all flushed from the eating out I’d just given her and the fact that I had her pinned to the bed with my eleven and a half inches of rock hard cockmeat. She thinks she knows me so well. I knew the instant she thought she’d gotten one over on me.
At first, she didn’t believe that I’d bought that half-ass excuse about a surprise, but as the day went on and I didn’t bring it up, she’d started to let her guard down. Then once I climbed into bed and started making love to her, she thought it was the furthest thing from my mind; wrong.
I worked her over with my tongue first, making her cum in my mouth a couple times before sliding into her to the hilt. Now it’s showtime. ‘Tyler!” I snorted at her little hissy fit. She’s mad she got played like she hadn’t been trying to play me. I nibbled along her neck and up her jaw to her ear. I know all the places she likes to be touched, the places that with just one lick of my tongue or graze of my teeth will have her spilling state secrets.
I felt her pussy juice and tighten around my throbbing cock when I nipped her ear in the perfect spot. She started moving her hips again, but I wasn’t ready. And when she tried fucking herself on my length, I eased out of her leaving just the thick head of my cock in her, stretching her out. “Tell me!”
She grudgingly gave it up after a few short hard and fast thrusts, and I gave her what she wanted, pounding her into the mattress until her greedy little pussy had had enough. She was splayed out beside me in my bed, which is where I’d taken her this time when I sent off the two texts that were the last act in this farce of a play.
To Sherry, I texted the words, ‘I think things may have gotten out of hand. I’ve been thinking about or childhood and how close we were, and for old time’s sake, I’m willing to hear your side. Meet me at the aquarium tomorrow morning at nine. We should make it by the dolphin display since that’s the most private place and won’t be that busy at that time of day. If you’re even a second late, I’ll know that you’re not interested, and I won’t hang around.’
Then to Kevin, I wrote, ‘let’s meet by the dolphin display. You don’t want anyone else overhearing any of this. If you’re late by even a second, I’m taking everything I have to the police. I’m sure your conservative parents would love that.’
I had no doubt that they’d both show and was counting on Kevin to do the rest once I put one last touch on it. You see, I’m pretty sure of how things might go tomorrow, I’m hoping anyway, that the two of them will destroy one another in their own way. For Kevin’s part, he hates women. Why else would he drug and violate innocent young girls just for kicks?
And now that I’ve convinced him that Sherry betrayed him, I can only imagine what he’s going to do to get back at her. I draw the line at setting her up to be sexually violated in any way; that’s just fucking evil and not something I want any part of. But anything else goes.