“Ready?” I asked but she only bit back a sob.
Fuck it. I pulled my thumb away, replaced it with my tip and pushed in, just past the tight muscle.
She howled with pain and I groaned with pleasure as her ass gripped me.
I had never in my life been inside an ass that tight.
“Fuck,” I breathed, just feeling my cock pulse inside her. She went rigid and motionless in my arms. “Have you had anything up your ass before, little girl?”
She nodded. Her eyes found mine in the window and I stared at her. I felt a little bad. But not bad enough to stop. Especially when she reached behind her and felt around, touching my cock. She gasped when she realized I wasn’t even fully inside her.
“Please,” she whispered. “I… I’m really scared.”
“Do you want me to stop?” I stroked her hair. Pretty curls. Pretty little blonde. Very hard to resist. “I’ll try to if you ask nicely.”
I still hadn’t started fucking her. Being inside her felt too good, and I wanted to relish the moment for a little while longer.
“I…” She stared at me in the window. Her eyes were really fucking wild. For a second I thought she was on something.
“Time’s up,” I told her with a grin. “Don’t worry, little girl, I’ll make sure you like it.”
I wrapped one hand around her waist and pulled on her hair with the other one. She let me, just like I knew she would.
I started fucking her little ass nice and slow. She felt unbelievably good.
She felt frozen in my arms, though. Her skin was really fucking cold and her eyes were glassy. Something was off.
“Jesus,” I groaned against her skin. “You need to… You need to meet me halfway here, little one.”
“I-I’m… okay,” she got out.
I licked her neck. Bit it. Sucked her skin. She melted slowly. First, her fingers stopped cramping behind her back. Then, she threw her head back a little, looking at me over her shoulder. And then she moaned for the first time. A hot fucking moan.
“Just like that,” I told her gently. I fucked her ass harder. She was so fucking… innocent, yet slutty. It was driving me insane. I needed her to want this as much as I did.
“It h-hurts,” she said, and I thrust a little less.
“No,” she cried out. “More like that, please don’t stop.”
I didn’t stop.
I used her sweet little asshole to pleasure myself and with every thrust of my hips, she let me have more of her. Submitted more, gave me another piece of her puzzle.
The silence in my head was deafening. Just her. It was only her that mattered, and it was the first time I had ever felt that way. Like I’d stumbled on a good place, a happy place, where I could tune out everything and everyone, and just make her mine. Because that was all that mattered in that moment.
I could’ve come a few times but I needed her to do it first. From a cock up her ass. Nothing touching her pussy. Nothing touching her tits. Just a hard cock up her asshole and a hand around her throat.
I gripped her neck tightly and fucked her ass so roughly she dug her nails into my skin.
“Oh my God,” she whispered. “You’re fucking crazy. You’re insane. This… it’s so wrong. He’s going to kill me.”
“Probably,” I grunted against her skin. “You need to come for me, little slut.”
“No,” she whispered. “Not from that, I… I can’t come from that.”
I took it as a fucking challenge.
I knew I was going to burst if I kept going at that pace. I could already feel my cock dripping precum inside her ass, mixing with my spit from before.
“You will tonight,” I told her, and she went so slack I had to hold her up so I could keep fucking her. “Oh, little one. You like being fucked like that? Like a fucking ragdoll?”
She couldn’t stop her next moan. It was long and delicious, and she didn’t want me to hear it, because she blushed all over when it left her lips.
“That’s right,” I said. “Moan just like that, and you’ll get your ass filled up just the way you want to.”
She struggled half-heartedly, more for show than anything else. I was really close. Too fucking close to worry about her own orgasm.
“Fuck,” I muttered against her shoulder, my cock making a really loud noise when it left her ass. She cried out.
“Put it back,” she begged. “Please fucking please, put it back inside me. All the way.”
“I thought you couldn’t come like that,” I grunted, rubbing my tip all over her wet little pussy. She was a mess. Such a loud little mess. “Did you lie again?”
“I…” She sobbed, just once, but no tears came. “I don’t know, just put it back, please.”