Pet: A Dark Menage Romance

I made my thrusts harder and fucked her like I was punishing her. She was holding back. I could tell by the way her body tensed up impossibly, so desperate for one of us to tell her to just let the fuck go.

Her pussy made wet sounds as I bottomed out inside her. She gripped the bedsheets so tightly her knuckles cramped around the fabric.

“I want to come,” she whispered. “Please let me. Tell me I’m allowed to, please. I have to hear you, please.”

I bit my fucking tongue, but that bastard pulled on her hair and groaned so loudly she cried out.

“More,” she said. “Please, more. I need to hear you.”

He leaned closer to her and her lips parted for him. She was fucking desperate.

He kissed her. My fucking Pet. The sweetest of kisses, his tongue sliding into her mouth and teasing her, making her moan my name against his lips.

She thought it was me.

She thought he was fucking her pussy and that’s why she was fucking holding back. So she wouldn’t upset me.

I grunted and pulled out of her. She cried at the loss desperately, and I forced her on her back. I didn’t need to tell the guy what to do. He ripped the blindfold from her eyes himself.

For a second, we both just stared at her. Her eyes were dilated as fuck. I could tell she was so close, just from the situation we were in. And it wasn’t fucking working.

“Hold her the fuck still,” I growled at him, and he grabbed her waist and held her down. His breaths were ragged. His cock was inches away from her lips and she opened her mouth to lick him, but he was too far away.

Her eyes went to me and she begged silently.

“Pet,” I said. “This was a bad fucking idea.”

“Yeah,” Stranger groaned. “Really fucking bad.”

“Very b-bad,” she stuttered.

I smacked her thighs apart, “So now,” I said. “You’re going to pay for making me do this.”

She nodded vigorously. “Yes, please, I want to. Let me.”

I looked at her for a long time, knowing how nervous the waiting was making her. Then, I beckoned Stranger to me, and he joined me in front of our little toy.

“I want her ass,” I told him in a growl, and Pet whimpered, whether in anticipation or fear, I wasn’t sure.

But for once, I was sure of what I wanted. I was going to have that tight little butt of hers, and she didn’t have a say in it. I’d kept myself away from her for too long, and I’d forced myself to not even think about it. But then to think he’d had it before me… It drove me fucking insane. I couldn’t let him inside her again.

Stranger joined her on the bed, and I watched in absolute seething jealousy as she settled on top of him. She was about to feel him inside her pussy for the first time, and it drove me insane with red-hot rage, but I knew it had to be done. Everything there that night was going to happen for a reason, and I couldn’t disrupt the order of things.

I stared at his hands going to her ass as she positioned herself over his crotch. His cock was so hard it looked painful as it throbbed beneath her. Pet moaned so loudly as she sunk her cunt onto it I could feel it reverberating in my veins, and then she looked at me over her shoulder.

Those big baby blues, so wide and so very scared. She had tears in her eyes, but they never fell. She just looked at me, and in that moment, I saw inside her, every bit of her she’d kept hidden from me, from her family, and from herself. And in that moment, she was finally completely, and utterly mine.

She smiled then, a big smile with her pearly whites on display and her eyes rolling back in pure ecstasy as she rocked a little on Stranger’s cock. She moaned so sensually my dick throbbed, and she turned back to face him as she rode herself to an orgasm so fast I wanted to punish her for it.

I was up behind her, and I couldn’t keep away any longer. Not with his dirty hands all over my girl and her cheeks splitting open every time she slammed down on his cock. I needed to be inside her. I needed to show Pet who she belonged to.

I opened her ass cheeks and her tight ring of flesh stared at me, puckered and so tight. I had no idea how anyone had ever fit inside her. She whimpered when I spat on her, right on that sweet little spot that opened up so invitingly when I stretched her.

“Are you ready for me, Pet?” I groaned in her ear, and she mewled when my hot breath hit her long, pale neck. I grabbed her hips, trying to ignore how angry having my hands on Stranger’s hands made me, and I thrust inside her. All the way, no mercy, just rammed my cock inside that hungry little ass and she screamed for more.