Our Love Story

“What is it then?”

“We know this started as a fling,” Mason begins. “As a vacation hook-up, but for all of us, it’s turned into something so much more.”

“It’s turned into something deeper,” Noah says, looking into my eyes.

“It’s turned into something we want to last longer than Jamaica—to last as long as you’ll let it,” Enzo says.

Ethan is still silent, but finally, he speaks.

“What we are trying to say is, this thing has turned into love.”

My breath catches, tears spring to the surface. My heart? It doesn’t know what to do.

“I love you, Chloe,” Mason says.

“I love you, Chloe,” Noah says.

“I love you, Chloe,” Enzo says.

“I love you, Chloe,” Ethan says. “And we aren’t expecting anything in return, we ju—”

I cut him off. “You should expect something. You should expect me to feel the same. And I do. I love you all so much. I didn’t think it was possible, to love anyone this way. So deeply, so fast. But I do. I love each of you in a distinct way, but I love you together in a complete way.”

The air in the room is charged. So much devotion has been exchanged. I would do anything for these men and I know they would do anything for me.

“Ethan and I talked last night,” I tell them. “And we decided we’re not going out alone today, we want to have our first time with you, all of us, together. Now.”

Noah takes a deep breath, his eyes immediately bright with desire. And he steps behind me pulling back my hair and breathing hot air in my ear. Mason laces his fingers through mine, not letting me go and Enzo drops to his knees and wraps his arms around my waist kissing my belly button through the hoodie I still have on.

Ethan steps toward me, and the dark clouds that seem to always follow him vanish. He looks at me with so much devotion and offers me a smile. I smile too, letting the memories of the horrible morning with Jordan wash away. And how could I not smile at this incredible, beautiful, over-the-top, absolutely perfect way to lose my virginity?

Enzo turns his head and sees Ethan’s grin. Then he tilts his head toward me as if giving him permission to take what he wants.

Ethan then steps forward and reaches for the hem of my hoodie. He pulls it over my head and sees that there’s nothing underneath. No bra, no panties, nothing but bare skin. He tosses it aside while looking at me. In fact, all of them look at me with hunger and desire and need.

“You are so fucking gorgeous,” Ethan tells me. As he speaks, Enzo runs his hands over my pussy, Noah squeezes my ass, and Mason finds my mouth.

Ethan, though, steps toward me. I break away from the kiss for a moment, telling Ethan to undress.

Then my mouth is back on Mason’s, my tongue meeting his, and we crash together in a perfect kiss. He kisses me slow and he kisses me hard and he opens me up with his mouth.

Ethan takes my hand and places it on his solid cock; it is smooth and hard at the same time. And big. So, fucking big.

I groan against Mason as I stroke Ethan up and down.

Enzo’s mouth is on my pussy. He’s tasting me, licking my folds the way I have been imagining. He is so smooth, so confident, that his mouth knows exactly what to do. I’m dripping for him as he moves his tongue over my slit, and I know I need to get in a different position. Otherwise, I’m going to fall onto the floor as I melt in their arms.

Noah is behind me, massaging my ass with his big hands, then wrapping them around my waist, reaching up to my breasts and plucking at my nipples from behind. Then I feel him undress and his hard cock presses against my ass. My nipples harden with excitement as I feel his massive cock against my backside.

My cunt is dripping wet, my mouth is hungry, my breasts eager, and Ethan’s cock is oh, so ready.

This. I need this.

I’m not sure of the logistics, but I don’t need to be. The men take over as if they know exactly what to do. And I bet they do; they have been dreaming of this moment since before we met.

Ethan pulls me toward the couch, and he sits down on it pulling me on top of him. I straddle him nervously, grateful that I have been on birth control shots since I started getting my periods, always finding the cramping painful.

I feel his cock nearing my pussy and I begin to inch myself closer to him. As I do, I see the other guys stripping down to nothing, their hard cocks ready. I bite my lip knowing things are about to get out of control in the most delicious way.