“Okay,” I told him. “It doesn’t hurt as much anymore.”
In fact, I was starting to cum from the pressure of his hand on my clit. He was pulling at it, rubbing it, sliding his finger into my wet pussy hole and then bringing it back out to rub my clit some more. It felt amazing and I felt a warm, good sensation as he pushed his big cock further into my little ass hole.
“Mmmm,” I moaned. “Mmmmm. Phil. Wow. Mmmm.”
“See?” he asked. “I told you. You need to trust your stepbrother. I know how to make you feel good. Just let your stepbrother fuck your tiny little asshole. Let me go all the way in.”
“Mmmm, okay, stepbro,” I said, as I came onto his hand while his cock was crammed most of the way inside me. “I’m cumming. You’re making me cum.”
“Well, stepsister, you’re not being enough of a slut for me,” he scolded me. “I’m not all the way in.”
As I came down off the high of my orgasm, I realized it was true. He was rather stuck, his dick crammed most of the way, but not all the way, inside me.
“Don’t be selfish,” he said, slapping my ass. “Be a better slut. Let me all the way in that ass. Come on.”
It was kind of hot, how angry he was because he wanted me all the way but couldn’t have me that far yet.
“I’m sorry, step bro,” I said, tears springing to my eyes because it stung now, how wide he was stretching me open, and now that he had stopped rubbing my hard, wet clit and making me cum while he plunged his big cock into my tiny little hole. “I’m trying. I want to be a good slut for you. I think you’re just too big. Your cock is so huge, and my ass hole is tiny.”
“Nonsense,” he said, spreading my legs and my ass cheeks open wider, spitting on his cock for more lube, and thrusting himself all the way inside me now.
“Owww!” I cried out, hoping I wasn’t too loud. “Stepbrother, that hurts. You’re hurting your little stepsister.”
“Be quiet,” he said, pulling my hair so that my head swung back, and I was forced to look at the fury in his eyes. “Do you want us to get caught? Do you want your dad or my mom to walk down here and see my big cock shoved into your tiny little ass hole? Do you want them to see us naked, with me rubbing that clit of yours that gets so hard and wet for me?”
As he said that, he started touching my pussy again, and I immediately started feeling better. I looked him in the eyes as he rubbed my clit, getting my pussy juices all over his hand. His other hand was still holding onto my hair, making me stare into his eyes.
“Do you want them to see me making you cum like this?” he asked. “So they can see what a little slut you are for me?”
“Mmmm, no, mmmm,” I said, as I started to cum again.
“No, what?” he said, taking his hand off my pussy and moving it to my nipple. “You want me to stop?”
“No,” I told him. “Please. Keep going. No, I don’t want them to see how you make me turn into your little slut. No one can know that I love when my stepbrother fucks my pussy and my cock.”
“Then you’d better be quiet,” he said, pinching my nipple, squeezing it and rubbing it between his fingers. “You’d better just keep your ass up while you’re on your hands and knees for me, letting me do what I want to you. Do you understand?”
“Yes, stepbrother,” I said.
To my delight, he put his hand back on my pussy and started pulling at my clit.
“I’ll show the world what you like me to do your pussy, if you don’t let me fuck your ass, all the way, nice and tight,” he said. “I’ll show them how I absolutely own my little stepsister. How she’s my dirty little slut.”
“Mmmm, no, stepbrother, don’t,” I said, and he stopped pulling on my clit just before I was about to cum.
“I mean, keep going,” I begged. “Please. I’m so close. I need you. I just meant don’t tell everyone what a slut I am for my stepbrother.”
“Oh, keep doing this?” he asked.
He was rubbing my clit so hard and good that I was bouncing up and down on his hand, jutting my butt backwards so that he could get further into my ass.
“Okay, if you keep doing that. If you let me all the way into your ass hole without fighting me or shouting out, so that we can keep doing this and no one will know how I like to cram my little stepsister’s asshole full of my cock, just like I like to fill up your little pussy hole and your wet, hot mouth with my cum.”