I guess the years of waiting had taken their toll. That's not to say I wasn't thrilled. Of course I was. I was about to get everything I had ever wanted. Ushering Kora from innocence to experience in every way.
I guess I had been fantasizing about it so long it was hard to believe it was finally really happening. I would have pinched myself, but it seemed inappropriate under the circumstances.
I went up to the edge of the bed, putting my hand on Kora's beautiful ass, stretching it out even wider. She moaned softly, flinching slightly.
Now I finally felt that feeling I think I had been looking for. Euphoria. Love, even.
This wasn’t just any old conquest like back in the day. This was me finally claiming the woman I had always loved, finally.
Holding Kora open, I pressed the head of my cock against her well-prepped asshole. I looked at her face for any signs of pain or discomfort but there were none. Keeping her ass open with one hand, I put the lube on the base of my cock and slid my cock into her ass. I was surprised how easily it went in. I had prepared her the best I could, but my cock was pretty huge and as far as I knew Kora was still an anal virgin. It only stood to reason as she clearly hadn't been fucked in the pussy before.
Either she was being a trooper or butt plugs were even more effective than I had thought. I kept pushing in until half my cock was deep in her sweet little virgin asshole. Still not a peep out of her, or any expression telling me what was going on in her head.
I wasn't exactly expecting screams of ecstasy and certainly didn't want her in pain, but this expressionless state was pretty disconcerting. I put my hand on her back and felt a chill run up it.
I still didn't know for sure, but I was almost all the way in before she made a noise. Just the smallest of cries. I stopped instantly and eased off by a couple of inches. Kora relaxed again and seemed contented enough.
Putting a hand on her hip, I started to, very slowly, move inside her. Pumping my cock in and out of her sweet virgin ass. She may have been quiet when I was first entering, but that fell apart almost as soon as I started to pump her asshole. Her stoicism was now giving way to soft grunts and gasps as I fucked her, forging open a new area on the geography of her hot young body.
None of the sounds came out as expressions of pain so I started to fuck her harder, taking hold of her ponytail as I did so. Her sounds turned louder and she started to move along with me, bucking her hips in rhythm with my thrusts, pushing herself down further onto my cock taking even more into her ass.
I kept gaining in speed, Kora seeming to be enjoying herself, until I was pounding my huge cock into tight little asshole. She reached down and started fingering her pussy as I fucked her. That was when the screams of ecstasy started.
We came together, Kora actually squirting again, apparently liking anal even more than I had expected. Even with it being her first time.
A shudder sacked her entire body. I stayed in her ass and stroked her belly as she came down, her breathing slowing down to a steady rhythm. Keeping my hand on her hip, I gently worked my way out out of her ass, Kora making a small moan as the head of my cock pulled there.
"Are you okay?" I asked.
"Yes, I'm fine," she said, coldly, pulling away.
Kora tried getting up into a sitting position but winced and got back on her side.
"I wouldn't -"
Kora pushed her way to the end of the bed and awkwardly stood up, having to catch herself on the bedpost to keep from going over. I reacted on instinct, taking her by the waist.
"I'm fine!"
I let her go and stepped away.
"I'm going to head home," she said, picking up her dress.
"Would you like to stay the night?" I asked.
"No, I have to go," she said, struggling into her dress, not really able to bend over.
I helped put her dress on, pulling it down to her thighs, which was really as far as it reached on her.
"You can lose my number. We both got what we wanted, it's over, right?"
I couldn't believe what she was saying. She seemed so into it at the time. It wasn't quite like when she said no up on the mountain, but it was pretty close. Worse, in a way.
I had really hoped things might have changed and I might have had a chance at actually having the relationship I had always wanted with Kora but was too messed up at the time to have. I was stupid to have been so optimistic.