When I finally began coming down from that intense high, I felt Garrett’s kisses moving up my body. When he stopped and put a nipple into his mouth, I could feel another orgasm beginning to build. He stopped, and the feeling quickly went away. Then, he moved to the other nipple, and the feeling began building again. Right before I thought I was going to explode, he moved his lips up to my neck as he positioned himself between my legs. I could feel his dick looking for entrance into my body, and I was scared and excited at the same time.
He stopped right before my lips. “Can I kiss you after what I did?”
I slid my hand around his neck and pulled him to my lips. At first, the idea of it made me feel a bit unsure, but soon, I was lost in Garrett’s kiss. He slowly began pushing against me, and I immediately tensed up.
“Emma, baby, I need you to relax.”
I looked into his eyes and nodded my head as I whispered, “Is it going to hurt, Garrett?”
His eyes filled with tears as he gently kissed me on the lips. He pulled back slightly and said, “At first, but then it will feel good. I promise.”
I wrapped my arms around him and opened my legs more to him. The moment he began seeking entry, I felt the burning sensation. I bit down on my lip and tried to relax.
Garrett started kissing me over and over. “I love you, Emma. I’ll love you forever.”
Then, he pushed in a little more, and I let out a gasp.
“I’m going to make you mine. You’re completely and utterly mine.”
“Yes!” I called out as he pushed in more. “Oh my God. I just thought you looked big, but…my God, I think you’re huge. Is it…will it fit?”
Garrett began laughing as he looked at me. “That is the sexiest thing anyone has ever said to me, and yes, baby…it will fit.”
I let out a giggle, and Garrett pushed in more.
“Oh God!” I cried out as he slowly began moving in and out. “Are you in all the way?”
Garrett began kissing me again as he moved gently and slowly. Each time, he pushed in more until I was positive that I wouldn’t be able to take another inch of him.
“I’m all the way in, baby,” he whispered against my lips. “I’m going to make love to you now, Emma.”
My heart slammed in my chest, and I felt a tear slide down my cheek. He moved so slowly, and at first, it burned like hell, but then it began to feel amazing.
“Garrett, I never imagined it would feel so…amazing, so…beautiful.”
As Garrett began to go faster and faster, I started to feel the buildup again. I instantly thought about Margie saying how Billy had yet to make her orgasm during sex. If it happened to me on my first time, I was going to rub it in.
“Garrett…can you go deeper? I mean…faster and deeper?” I reached over and grabbed the quilt.
I arched my body as Garrett picked up his pace.
He let out a grunt and said, “Emma…I’m so close.”
I thrashed my head back and forth. “Garrett, oh God…I’m going to come…yes! Oh God, yes!”
The next thing I knew, Garrett was calling out my name as I called out his. I could feel my insides pulsing down on him. It felt so incredible, and I’d never experienced anything so moving in my entire life.
“I love you, Emma. I love you so much,” Garrett said as he stayed on top of me.
He was still inside me, and I could feel him twitching. I smiled, knowing that Garrett would be the only person to make me feel like this for the rest of our lives.
“I love you, too, Garrett. That was wonderful. I can’t believe how amazing you feel inside me.”
Garrett jumped up and began swearing. “Motherfucker! Oh shit. No! Oh my God, no.”
I sat up quickly. “What? What’s wrong? Did I do or say something wrong?”
Garrett looked at me as he dropped to his knees. “Emma…I’m so sorry. I’m so very sorry. I can’t believe…I didn’t think…I got so caught up in everything, and I just…oh God.”