Monsters' Gift (Crude Hill High 2)

This was what I wanted.

Eyes closed, I sensed her.

I didn’t know how I could, but I knew the moment she entered my bathroom, then my shower. I turned to watch her. She was naked. Her hands were crossed over her chest, trying to hide those glorious tits from me.

“I thought you could use some company.”

As I held my hand out, she took it and came closer to me. Body to body, I pressed my face against her neck, breathing her in. She was the only woman I wanted. The instant I held her, the beast within me calmed. She was here, flesh and blood, and we were going to protect her. I did believe that.

Her fingers teased at the base of my neck.

“I’m here, Gael.”

“I love you, Emily.”

She pulled back, staring into my eyes. “I love you too. So much it scares me. I don’t … what if I’m not good enough for you? What if you do all of this and I can’t, I can’t be the woman you want?”

“Not going to happen.”

She went to protest and I silenced her with a kiss.

Both of her arms went around the back of my neck. Sliding my hands down to her ass, I cupped the flesh, hearing her moan. My cock was already rock-hard and I wanted inside her. Spinning her around to the wall, I lifted her, using the wall as leverage to keep her in place. I reached between us, gripping my cock, lining it up at her entrance, and sank her onto my length. Her cries filled the air as I started to fuck her.

I went slow, feeling every inch of her cunt wrapped around my cock, but when I couldn’t wait another moment, I fucked her harder. The angle was all wrong. Pulling out, I spun her around so she was bent over. Holding on to her hips, I found my way back inside her and wildly drove inside her, fucking her harder than ever before.

“Fuck, Emily. You have no idea what you do to me.”

“I’m getting an idea.”

Over and over, I pounded her pussy, taking what I wanted.

Just as my orgasm started to take over, I remembered I hadn’t brought her to orgasm. I held her tightly against me as I spilled within her walls. With my cock still balls deep inside her, I reached between her thighs and stroked her clit, feeling her pussy tighten around me.

I wanted to lick her pussy, but I also didn’t want to stop since I loved how she responded to being on my cock.

Over and over, I teased her clit, drawing her closer to her orgasm. When she went over, I closed my eyes, basking in the tightness wrapped around my dick. This was what I loved, and I wasn’t going to give it up, not for a second. She was perfect in every single way. Our dads had better watch out, because I was coming for them.

****

Caleb

I didn’t expect to find Emily in her bedroom, but there she was, sitting in the middle of her bed, book in hand. She’d followed Gael, so I thought she’d be with him.

“Hey,” she said.

“Hey. Ashley and Earl should be here tomorrow.”

“Great.”

“You’re not with Gael?”

“I…” She frowned. “I don’t exactly know how all of this works. I’m kind of new to more than one boyfriend. I don’t want to upset anyone.” She ran fingers through her still damp hair. “You all know that I’ve had sex with you. Admitted I love River and Gael, and now you.”

“You love me?”

She laughed. “Yes, I love you. I love you all. And Vadik. When I woke up seven years ago, I hated that I wouldn’t get the chance to tell you all that I loved you. I promised myself if I ever got the chance to tell you all how I felt, I’d take it. Only, it came and went, and I didn’t take it. I do love you all. This is so fucked up.”

I closed the door and moved toward the bed, sitting on the edge. “Why is it?”

“Because it is. How is it going to work? We haven’t even talked about protection and we’ve had sex. Each time we have sex, the risk of having a baby is higher. How is that going to work?”

“Isn’t it working now?”

“You’re all going to share me and I get passed around while you all have sex with me?” she asked.

“You only go with the four of us. It’s not like I’m going to let the soldiers have a chance at you.”

She wrinkled her nose. “But what happens when you get bored? Or I get tired? Or you don’t want to wait your turn?”

“Em, you’re overthinking all of this.”

“Am I? You guys are willing to share, but what if one of you takes me more than the other?” She blew out a breath. “I think I’m giving myself a headache.”