“He was not here when you searched,” said Nox. “I did not know he was coming.”
“You say,” said the farmer.
“I say,” said Nox, “and you know my word is good.”
“How do we know that?” asked the blacksmith.
“Because I pay my bills promptly,” answered Nox, “even when my tenants haven’t paid me.” Then she called more loudly. “Tegay!”
“You don’t have to shout,” said the cobbler softly, from behind them. They moved aside a little, so Nox and Tegay could see each other.
“Why do you accuse this boy of killing your son?”
“Because my boy Umbo watched him throw Kyokay over the falls.”
“He did not,” said Nox.
“I did too!” cried Umbo, taking a step closer to the porch.
“I’m not calling you a liar,” said Nox. “I’m saying that you are telling, not what you saw, but what you concluded from what you saw.”
“Same thing,” said the blacksmith.
“Umbo,” said Nox. “Come here.”
Umbo stepped back and stood close to his father again.
The cobbler said, “I’m not letting him into that house, not while that child-killer is there!”
“Umbo,” said Nox, “what did you actually see? Don’t lie, now. Tell us what your eyes actually witnessed.”
Rigg knew that Umbo would tell the truth—he was no liar. Then he’d realize for himself that Rigg hadn’t thrown or pushed, but had only reached out to try to save.
Umbo looked wildly from Rigg to Nox and then up at his father. “It happened like I said.”
It surprised Rigg that Umbo would persist in his mistake. But perhaps Umbo was afraid to change his story now. Everyone knew how Tegay beat him when he was angry.
“I see,” said Nox. “You were supposed to be watching Kyokay, weren’t you? Keeping him out of danger. But he ran away, didn’t he? Ran ahead of you, and when you got to the top of Cliff Road, he was already out on the rocks.”
Tegay’s face changed. “Is that true?” he asked his son.
“Kyokay didn’t obey me, but I still saw what I saw,” Umbo insisted.
“And that’s my question,” said Nox. “Scrambling up that road, you were out of breath. You had to watch your handholds and footholds so you wouldn’t fall. There are moments you can glimpse the falls and see what’s happening. But you wouldn’t have stopped to look, would you?”
“I saw Rigg throw Kyokay into the water.”
“While you were still coming up the road?” prompted Nox.
“Yes.”
“And when you got to the top, what did you see?” asked Nox.
“Kyokay w
as hanging from the lip of a stone, dangling over the falls. And Rigg was stretched out across two stones trying to slap and pry at Kyokay’s hands! And then he fell.” On that last sentence, a sob burst from him at the memory.
“And then what did you do?” asked Nox.