She imagined Seanna at six, standing on her tiptoes to watch her teenaged aunt deal tarot cards.
"Teach me, Rose," she said.
Rose smiled and lifted a card. "See this one? It's yours. Four of cups. That means you're very much loved--"
"No, not that. Teach me to use the cards."
"I am, Seanna. If you understand the meanings, you can pretend to tell the future."
"I don't want to pretend. I want to do it. Like you."
"Here's a secret." Rose bent and pushed a dark curl behind Seanna's ear to whisper. "Most of the time I do pretend."
Seanna didn't giggle the way most little girls would have, pleased to be told a scandalous secret. Instead, she said, "But you can really do it. You have the Sight."
Rose's smile fell away as she nodded gravely. "Yes, Seanna, I do. And do you want to know another secret?"
"No." Seanna's small face screwed up. "I don't want your stupid secrets. I want the Sight."
There had been, deep inside Rose, the urge to snap at Seanna. To tell her not to talk to her aunt that way, not to talk to anyone that way. When someone offers a secret, it's a gift and an honor. You don't spit on it.
Rose reflected maybe that was where they'd gone wrong with Seanna. In Cainsville, children were cherished and loved and, yes, sometimes coddled. The same went in her family. The Walshes might steal and con outsiders, but family was family, and no family was more precious than children. Instead, they'd tried gently to guide Seanna to better behavior.
That day long ago, Rose had just taken a deep breath, pushed aside her own temper, and said, in a firmer voice, "Well, you're going to listen to this secret, because it's an important one, Seanna. Gifts are curses, too. They give you something special, but that makes you different, and different isn't always good. Even the gift itself isn't always good. Do you know why I usually pretend with others? Sometimes it's because the Sight won't work. Other times it's because what I see is bad, so I tell them something nicer while trying to help them avoid the bad thing. Does that make sense?"
Seanna scowled. "You just want the Sight all for yourself."
That was all her niece heard. Embedded deep in that explanation was the word "no," and it was all that mattered.
"I can't give the Sight to you, Seanna. Either you have it or you don't."
Rose remembered her niece's scowl again, and it brought to mind another face. A face she tried to forget. Bobby Sheehan. A boy who lived in the city and had family in Cainsville. A boy, she now realized, who'd been a changeling, taken from a dysfunctional fae blood family and placed into a normal one with Cainsville ties. A boy who always knew that he didn't belong--a cuckoo in the nest of very ordinary sparrows.
That realization had driven Bobby to murder while barely in his teens. Murder and then madness, condemned to a psychiatric ward. He'd given Rose the same look Seanna had, when Hannah had told him their secrets: that Rose had the Sight and Hannah could understand animals in a way ordinary people could not.
Hannah.
My, my, you're really piling on the punishment today, aren't you, Rose? Why not add Gabriel to the heap of mistakes you've made, people you've failed to help, failed to save.
But Gabriel was already on the list, wasn't he? Right at the top, and that was what had her up all night, begging the cards for answers. Rose Walsh, who never begged for anything. Now she was. Yet the cards stayed silent, taunting her instead with a never-ending parade of people she'd wronged and mistakes she'd made.
Hannah.
Her best friend from the day they'd met, too far back in memory for Rose to recall, though Hannah's mother always told the story of two toddlers fighting over a toy at a town picnic. Except they hadn't been fighting to take it from the other; they'd been trying to give it to the other. You want it, so you take it. No, you take it. True or not, Rose supposed it said a lot about them, and why they'd become such good friends.
Best friends as toddlers, as schoolchildren, as teens. Then Hannah went off to college. Rose had visited her on campus, where they'd gone to a party and had too much to drink. Ducking the advances of frat boys, they'd stumbled, laughing, into an empty bedroom and locked the door. Drunk and sleepy, they'd decided to take advantage of the bed and lie down, and they'd curled up together, as they'd always done, and then...
Rose never could quite remember how it started. Or who started it. They'd been cuddling, with the alcohol buzzing, and the cuddling felt so good, not quite like it did with boys, slower and sweeter and not necessarily better but not worse, either. And then the cuddling turned to nuzzling, and the hugging to touching, soft strokes on an arm or a back, fingers searching and then lips searching and a kiss. That first kiss answered all Rose's uncomfortable questions about boys and sex, and why she liked it--really liked it--but there was an itch it didn't quite scratch.
That kiss had seemed to go on forever, and somewhere in the middle of it, hands slid under clothing and then clothing fell to the side of the bed, and then hands on skin and hands everywhere, touching, exploring, and Hannah gasping. Rose had been alarmed until she saw her friend's face, eyes closed, lips parted, panting softly as she moaned, that gasp clearly not telling her to stop. So she didn't, and afterward Hannah whispered that'd been the first time that happened. Her first climax. So Rose did it again, and then Hannah did it for her, and that night, that perfect, endless night...
Then came morning, when the frat boys picked the lock, expecting to sneak in on one of their confederates, and instead finding the girls in bed, curled up together, naked.
Rose hadn't cared. Rose never cared. That was the Walsh way. Take your judgment and your so-called morality and shove it up your ass. I'll live as I want. I'll be happy however I want.
But that wasn't Hannah. It had never been Hannah. Even if today's society had not yet progressed quite as far as Rose would like, it had been so much worse for two girls caught together in bed forty years ago.
Rose sometimes felt the temptation to give Liv a shake and say, "Just go for it with Gabriel." But that impulse never lasted long because Rose understood, better than anyone, that even the strongest friendship could shatter, and the move from friend to lover was exactly the sort of pressure that could do it. Sometimes, you can't go back. You might wish it with all your heart, but you can't, because, sometimes, that isn't up to you.