I gave her more. Plunging in and out of her wet heat, the tension and rage I’d been carrying around all day went into every thrust. Chase went back to kissing her. Haley couldn’t get enough, she arched to meet my thrusts and she mewled through Chase’s kisses. Her hand came up to grasp his cock and I watched as she milked him. It wasn’t rhythmic. Trying to co-ordinate kissing, hand-jobs and fucking wasn’t some kind of orchestrated performance. It was raw. Chase broke the kiss to concentrate on the hand on his cock and her hand stopped as I rammed into her so hard she must have seen stars.
“Todd, I’m gonna-“
I flicked her clit with my fingertip as I continued to fuck her until her pussy contracted and she came all over my cock and fingers. Her pussy continued to throb against me for several seconds. I hadn’t come myself yet. I wanted to wait.
“Wait for a minute,” I told her and I took Chase’s hard cock into my mouth. With years of practice behind me, I placed my tongue up over the back of my throat, taking Chase into my tongue, making him feel like he was fucking the back of my throat. He grabbed my head as he guided me in a rhythm he would get off on. As I felt the giveaway signs that his come was approaching, I backed off, looking up at him and shaking my head.
“No. We fuck. Haley, move further left and turn on your side facing left.”
When she’d done it, I directed Chase. “Move behind her.”
I moved behind Chase. Chase brought his hand around the front of Haley and began to finger her clit, alternating with plunging digits into her pussy. “So wet, Haley, I hope you’re ready for me.”
She wriggled her ass at him indicating that she definitely was. “Oh that ass,” Chase groaned. “Wiggle it again, baby.”
He lined up his cock with her pussy and entered her slowly. This time we would take our time. I moved in be
hind Chase and lubing up my dick and his puckered hole, I slowly edged into him pushing through his outer ring. He moved back against me until I met the known resistance of his inner ring, waiting until it relaxed and let me push my cock in further. Chase gasped as I pushed all the way into him, my balls slapping against his ass cheeks. I held his hips as I followed his lead with my movements, mirrored my fucks to his fucking of Haley. Now we were all in perfect orchestrated motion. A trio of lovers searching for their crescendos. Leisurely strokes turned into animalistic movements and grunts as the pressure built and then Haley climaxed which set off a chain reaction. Chase spilled his load into her tight pussy and I jerked violently as my cum spurted inside Chase’s ass.
We laid back against the bed spent. But this time we didn’t leave. We took turns to visit Haley’s bathroom, then got back in the same positions, curled up and went to sleep. My anger was no more. Malcolm was insignificant. Haley was with us and we would protect her for as long as she allowed.
Chapter Eleven
Haley
I almost asked if we could have girl’s night on Saturday. I was absolutely bursting to tell the girls what had happened over the past week. So much had changed. After our date and my lesson in oral, they’d left me alone until the Friday night. I’d been surprised. I’d kind of expected a non-stop fuck-fest. I wasn’t sure whether I admired the fact they were respecting me and taking their time or whether to just go to them and demand they fucked me. I was becoming sex-crazed. Me!-little Haley Martin. The quiet girl who didn’t do sex, who wasn’t very good at sex, now had had two amazing experiences. I knew now that it wasn’t only down to me. The lovers I’d had were useless in bed and along with my lack of confidence it had meant that I’d struggled to develop any kind of sexual skill. I knew now that it was all about to change. Bring it on, I thought. I couldn’t wait for more. Friday had rolled around to Monday and although there’d been a lot of making out, we’d not had sex again. Instead, Todd and Chase had insisted on taking me to the movies on the Saturday night and bowling on Sunday. They were determined to date me. They were off to the gym tonight and then had got Brandon to agree to them hanging around at his apartment, while I borrowed his wife for the evening. By the time Kayla and Tiff arrived I was a bundle of nervous energy, had drunk half a bottle of red wine already and was feeling rather dizzy, but manic.
“Come in, come in,” I’d shouted at both of them, and they’d taken a seat at the dining table while I served some spaghetti and poured the last of the red wine into their glasses.
“What the fuck is going on with you, Haley? You’re like a bloody jack in a box.” Kayla said.
I squeezed my ass through the gap between the table and my chair and sat down, twirling spaghetti around my fork. “I did it! I did two blow jobs and I’ve had sex with both Todd and Chase!” Then I squealed because I was just so damn happy and excited about the whole thing.
Tiffany high-fived me and then Kayla took her lead and did the same. Tiffany beamed at me. “I’m so happy for you. Spill it. What was it like? What did you do? Did you see them fuck again? Are two men really hot together?”
“Jesus, Tiffany. One question at a time and give the girl time to eat her spaghetti or she’s going to choke on it.” Kayla chided. Then she turned to me. “Haley, eat the damn spaghetti so we know what happened.”
“Okay, so the first time I just did blow jobs, but they were so kind and patient. It wasn’t like they took pity on me or anything, it was still super sexy, but they gave me words of encouragement and advice, and it worked. I used some of the hints and tips you two had given me too but it was so much better to not suck and lick a piece of hard plastic or a mushed up banana.” I made a gagging face. “Then after we set up Malcolm--I’ll tell you about that in a moment--we came back here and Todd was all masterful and pinned me to the wall. I felt like I was in a movie.”
“Yeah, rewind this movie a minute, what did you do to Malcolm? I thought he’d been quiet this week.” Tiff said.
“We tricked him into giving a male porn actor’s a blow job on camera and then told him where to go.”
Kayla spat out her wine. “Holy shit! How did you pull that off?”
I filled them in on all the details of the porn shoot and how Eli King had also been part of proceedings.
“Wow, that guy really does know how to piss people off,” Tiff said.
“And now he knows how to suck a dick.” Kayla laughed. “That’s hilarious. Are you sure you don’t have a copy on hand that we can watch?”
“No, Todd actually wiped it so it couldn’t accidentally get out anywhere, but Malcolm doesn’t need to know that does he?” I giggled.
“Haley, you are becoming quite the minx. Tiffany, where’s our innocent little Hales gone?”
“I think she’s gone forever judging by the wide smile that’s almost permanently etched onto her face. Now you know why we got so hooked on ménage. It’s so decadent having two guys at once.”
“Yes, but Hales has even more holy hotness because then her guys bang each other. Mine won’t cross swords, I’ve asked them. Parker said I could go back to sleep because I was fucking dreaming.”