Tatum squeezed my hand as we approached the diner’s glass doors. Our bodies moved in sync before he held the door open for his mom and then for me, giving my butt a quick smack as I walked in front of him. The diner wasn’t crowded, but every person in the room turned to stare the second we entered. I figured that the news about my being in town had gotten around a while ago and that it wouldn’t cause any problems, but I quickly realized that they weren’t only looking at me.
“Maybe this was a bad idea?” I said apologetically toward Mrs. Montgomery.
She leaned toward me. “It’s not you, dear. It’s me. And Tatum holding your hand probably doesn’t help.”
“Emily. Tatum. Young lady I don’t know. Sit anywhere,” an aging waitress shouted from behind the long white counter, and I stifled an uncomfortable laugh. Three men sat on bar stools watching us, and I shifted toward Tatum, feeling a little uncomfortable. He wrapped an arm around my waist and pulled me against him.
Mrs. Montgomery slid into a corner booth away from the majority of prying eyes and forced a smile. “I don’t get out much since Tatum’s daddy passed. It was just too hard at first. Not just to leave the house, but to leave the bed,” she said with a sigh. “But this is good.” She nodded, as if trying to convince herself. “This is a good step. These are my friends and I’ve ignored them for far too long.”
I sat next to Tatum, silently listening as his mom confessed things I was certain she usually never talked about. Before I could feel guilty for forcing her out of the house, she assured me with a smile that this had been a great idea. I wasn’t entirely convinced.
When Tatum rested his hand on top of my thigh, I both relaxed and tensed at the same time. He had this calming effect on me that mixed with his ability to turn me on with just a touch, which of course caused complete chaos inside my body. Excitement tore through half of me while utter comfort settled the other half. It made zero sense, but I chalked it up to the Tatum Effect and all that feeling “red” he seemed to do to me. Quinn would have a field day with that.
Air blew past me as someone stopped abruptly in front of our table. “Hi, y’all. I’ll be your server tonight.”
I looked up to see Brina standing there glaring at us with a notepad and pen in hand.
“Hi, Brina, I didn’t know you worked here,” I said sincerely.
Her face soured as her voice turned bitter. “It’s not like we’re friends, so how would you know?”
“Be nice, Brina,” Mrs. Montgomery said in a warning tone.
“Can I get y’all
anything to drink?” She tapped her pen repeatedly.
“I think we’ll all have some tea,” Mrs. Montgomery said before Brina turned on her heel and stomped away.
“Do you think she’ll spit in them?” I whispered toward Tatum’s mom.
“She most certainly better not or I’ll be paying her mama a visit. What happened to that girl? She used to be so nice.”
Tatum’s grip on my hand tightened. “She wasn’t ever nice, Mama. She’s a fake. A fraud. A phony.”
I squeezed Tatum’s fingers before letting go. “She’s not worth it,” I reminded him, and he leaned over, placing a kiss on my cheek.
“Do we get to talk about this now?” Mrs. Montgomery waggled her finger between us, and my cheeks warmed.
“I hope it’s okay. I meant to talk to you.” I glanced at Tatum. “Alone. I just—”
“Paige.” She reached across the table for my hand. “It’s more than okay. You’ve brought light to my son’s eyes again and a smile to his face. It’s been too long since I’ve seen either.”
Tatum squeezed my thigh and nodded in agreement at his mom’s words. A smile spread across his face, and my eyes instantly filled as I fought to keep back the tears that threatened to spill. I refused to be the girl who cried at dinner because some nice words were spoken about her. Focused on holding back my emotions, I’d almost forgotten my manners. “Thank you, Mrs. Montgomery. That was really nice of you to say.”
“I wasn’t being nice, dear. I only speak the truth. So, thank you.”
Tatum’s mouth breathed against my ear, “She’s right. You’ve made me believe in love again. I’d all but given up any hope for it existing before you came along. Thank you for reawakening my heart.”
I ducked my head, and the tears I’d fought so hard to stop from falling spilled down my cheeks. I quickly wiped them away as Brina sauntered over to our table. Perfect timing.
“Make her cry already, Tatum? Great job, sweetheart,” she snapped as she placed the three drinks on the table.
“Brina Marie Ward, I know for a fact that your mama didn’t raise you to have such a smart mouth. I’ll ask you one last time to act like the Southern woman you were raised to be before I start lodging complaints. And you know how much I’d hate to do that.” Mrs. Montgomery cocked her head to the side and smiled.
Brina straightened her back and lowered her head. “Yes, ma’am. You’re right. I apologize. I’ll be back in a minute to take your order.” She quickly shuffled away.
“Wow. That was impressive,” I said, somewhat intimidated by Mrs. Montgomery’s attitude.