I finished removing her dress and she worked on my shirt. Her fingers traced my muscles when it was pulled over my head and I started to unfasten her bra. I pulled my finger free and she let her panties fall to the ground as she walked towards the bed. I finished undressing and by the time she was on the bed, I was on top of her, sliding between her thighs and positioning my cock against her pussy.
“Do you have a condom?” She looked at my bare cock that was poised for penetration.
“Shit...” I rolled to the side. “I can’t believe I didn’t think of that.”
“Some of the other guys have them. I could call downstairs.” She reached for the phone that could dial any of the other rooms.
“I’ll go.” I stood up and grabbed my pants, shoving a leg in and feeling my cock start to lose the excitement it had moments before.
“Don’t keep me waiting for long...” She grinned as I headed for the door.
Once I was outside of her room, it felt like my feet were made of lead. The reality of what we were about to do started to overpower my lust. She wanted the arrangement. She wanted all seven of us and she was willing to do whatever it took to get that. I questioned if I could do the same. I liked Lyn, but could I really share her with the other guys? Was that the relationship I was destined for because I grew up in a shitty small town that didn’t have someone I could spend my life with?
I started down the stairs and realized I was going to have to test my boundaries. Being with Lyn meant that we would all have to sacrifice something. I had to know if that was even possible for me. I had to push myself past the comfort zone I was used to and see if I could actually give her what she wanted. If I agreed to the arrangement, it wouldn’t be fair for me to dominate her time. It would have to be equal when there were others there. I knew what I had to do, but it was going to take a lot for me to actually go through with it. I walked into the living room and everyone immediately stopped talking to look at me.
“That was fast...” Markus raised his eyebrows.
“Markus... Dawson...” I looked at the two men Lyn had already been with. “Would you like to join us?”
“Hell yeah!” Dawson sat up with excitement etched on his face.
“I won’t turn that down.” Markus was on his feet before the words finished coming out of his mouth.
“What about us?” Adrian motioned to the others that were sitting.
“You haven’t been on a date with her yet.” I shook my head back and forth. “Wait your turn...”
I couldn’t believe I found the courage to ask, but once the words were said, I couldn’t take them back. My heart was in my throat one second and in my stomach the next, beating out of control as I walked towards the stairs with them following behind me. Lyn really had been a simple girl at one point—I saw that when I took her out. That part of her had found solace with a new kind of life after she left the South Side of Chicago behind. I wondered if I could do the same without Granite Falls hanging around my neck like an albatross. The cameras had filmed what I did and what I asked. There would be no way to close that iteration of Pandora’s box when the show aired. Even if the arrangement didn’t work out, I wouldn’t be able to go back home. I had made a choice and the choice was going to be one that defined me from that moment forward. I was risking everything to have Lyn—to join with her and the other guys in a union where we all found companionship. Charles brought me to the show for a reason and I felt like I was there to keep her grounded—to make her laugh and smile. That was something we both needed and I wasn’t sure I would ever find that in Granite Falls. We got the top of the stairs and I let my hand rest on the door.
“Can I borrow a condom from one of you?” I looked back at them.
“I got you.” Markus smiled and clasped his hand on my shoulder. “I got all we need.”
Chapter 11: Lyn
John made me feel something I hadn’t felt since I left the South Side. He made me feel a part of something—a piece of a community. He didn’t ask for anything in return. He didn’t do it because he was looking to get laid. He wasn’t even sure he could be part of the arrangement. That made me want him to be a part of it even more. I needed someone that could show me that I was still that girl from the South Side with big dreams. He was the only one who seemed like he could be there with me on a regular basis, and I needed that too. I was sure the others could make it work and change their schedules to make sure someone was always with me, but John could make that happen every day. His town sounded sad. I didn’t want to send him back there.
I refused to let the momentary lapse ruin the moment. I ran my hands between my legs and rubbed my clitoris while I waited, feeling the pleasure shooting through my body. It was nothing like what I experienced when I was with them and it felt like a poor substitute after having the real thing, but it kept my motor running. The door opened and I leaned up, hoping to find that John had successfully completed his mission. He walked in first and then my eyes opened wide when I saw Markus and Dawson behind him.
“John...” I blinked a couple of times in surprise. “What’s going on?”
“I found a couple of guys with condoms.” He smiled. “I think I’m ready to try something new.”
“Are you sure?” I felt my heart skipping a beat in my chest. “You said you weren’t sure about doing this.”
“If I’m going to be part of this with you, then I have to recognize your needs.” He moved towards the bed. “Because you certainly recognized mine.”
Dawson and Markus started to get undressed and John removed his pants once again. Markus handed him a condom and he started unrolling it on his cock. I was proud of John for having the courage to try something that he was obviously a bit unsure of. If we could get John on board, then I didn’t think Brando or Adrian would be an issue. Charles was definitely going to agree. The only person I wasn’t sure about was Anders. He was just confusing and he barely interacted with me.
I sat up on the side of the bed as Markus and Dawson approached. I took Dawson’s cock between my lips and started to suck it as I stroked Markus. I reached my other hand out and gripped John’s dick, squeezing it as I massaged the condom up and down his shaft. I wasn’t sure how I was going to please all three of them at once, but my pussy was definitely going to belong to John next.
Once I got a good rhythm going on all three of I felt my pussy getting wetter, ready to satisfy all three of my lovers. I pulled back from Dawson’s cock and climbed onto the bed. John was the first one to grab my legs and start to spread them, so I shifted towards him.
“John gets to go first.” I reached out and pulled him closer.
“I have no problem just settling for a blowjob tonight.” Dawson crawled onto the bed. “I think it is only fair that John get the opportunity to enjoy what we’ve both already enjoyed.”
“I agree.” Markus nodded. “But I got something else in mind—I’m going to fuck you in the ass.”