“They don’t have to.” She finally opened her eyes and looked up at me. “I got you to do that for me.”
She was everything I had been searching for even if I didn’t know it. I knew there were some who would see what we did as a sin, but I felt like my relationship with God was already on thin enough ice—sharing Samantha with other men was hardly the worst thing I had done. Somewhere in the balance between good and evil, what we were doing was necessary. I couldn’t love another or have a traditional relationship. There wasn’t even a woman in Granite Falls I could pursue it with even if I felt that was the case. I could sleep easy at night believing God had sent Samantha to me and the arrangement was a test of my faith. If I could share her with the other men, then I would have a woman who let me live out my darkest fantasies—thing I was never able to tell anyone. I knew I would have to leave her, but I wasn’t going to go until she was ready for our embrace to end. I was cherishing the moment too much to do it on my own. We stayed there for nearly thirty minutes before she finally pulled away.
“Who do you want me to send up next?” I leaned up and reached for my pants.
“I think you can send them all. They’ve been waiting a long time.” She grinned and crawled back over, putting her arms around my shoulders.
“All three?” I raised my eyebrows in concern.
“It’ll be okay. I can handle it. I want to see you first tomorrow though.” She moved back to the center of the bed and leaned against her elbow.
“You got it...” I slid on my pants and started towards the door.
Chapter 10: Blue
I was getting a little impatient waiting on my turn with Samantha. Luther had been upstairs with her so long it felt like an eternity and I was going to be too drunk to get my dick hard if he didn’t show up soon. Major seemed to be fairly complacent and wasn’t pushing to be the next guy up the stairs, so I hoped I could get my turn next. Mayor Danvers seemed more interested in making sure the house was perfect that getting his rocks off. Jesse, Axe and Steve were pounding shots faster than I normally did, sharing tales of their time with Samantha which didn’t do much to help the throbbing erection begging for attention. I figured it would be a little easier as the days went on since we wouldn’t all be there at the same time during the day. I just hoped there was enough of Samantha left for me to pleasure. If the other guys had done their job, she was likely exhausted by that point. I stood up when I heard Luther close the door upstairs, watching as he walked down the stairs.
“Did you pray over her before you fucked her—damn.” I tilted my head as he walked into the living room.
“No, I had to punish her for her sins.” He smiled and chuckled.
“What?” That comment quickly got Mayor Danvers’ attention.
“She loved it.” He walked back to his chair. “So much so that she’s ready for all three of you.”
“She...she is?” Mayor Danvers stammered over his words.
“Yep, I got her so turned on that one man isn’t enough.” He looked around the room. “Are you going or do you plan to keep the lady waiting?”
“Hell no—heavens no—whatever.” I started towards the stairs.
Mayor Danvers was behind me and Major was following him. The three of us probably looked a bit ridiculous scampering up the narrow staircase with our prize ready to be claimed. I was the first to the door and when I pushed it open, I saw exactly what Luther meant by punishment. Her ass had been scorched and there were outlines of his fingers on her flesh. The smile on her face suggested she asked for it—or at least wanted it. I never imagined the quiet preacher being a freak, but it was very clear that he was no quite devoted to Sunday morning as he let on. There were demons from his past and apparently some of them were quite kinky. I stepped into the room and peeled off my shirt. Samantha got her first look at my tattooed chest and I could desire in her eyes. Four men had claimed her and she was still aching for more. Mayor Danvers seemed a bit overwhelmed by the whole thing, but it was his idea, so he was going to have to man up. I walked to the edge of the bed and leaned over, pressing my lips to her breast and kissing it. My tongue rolled around her nipple and she let out a gasp.
“You don’t waste any time.” She ran her fingers through my jet-black hair. “I like that.”
“I don’t waste any time and I take what I want.” I slapped her ass and pulled her towards me. “And I’m about to take this...” My finger ran between her thighs, but I passed her pussy and dug a finger into her anus.
“I’m not sure about that...” She looked at me with concern.
“I’ll show you how amazing it can be.” I slid into the bed and pushed her spanked ass apart so I could lick the clenched tightness I wanted to fuck.
“Oh my God!” Her fingers clenched the sheets when I ran my tongue around the circumference of her star shaped paradise.
Mayor Danvers didn’t wait. He started taking off his clothes while I licked Samantha’s anus and prepared her hole to be fucked. Major seemed a bit out of sorts with everything going on and he simply took a seat in the chair near the bed. Apparently he wanted what I was having because he didn’t show any interest in taking the other two holes that were available. Once Mayor Danvers was undressed, he climbed into bed and positioned himself in front of Samantha. She was gasping and moaning with excitement, eyes closed from the pleasure she was feeling, when Mayor Danvers drove his cock into her throat. She was surprised at first, but once she felt him in her mouth, she started moving up and down his dick with a fury guiding her lips. I placed a finger on her clitoris and started massaging it while I rimmed her beautiful ass. The combined pleasure made her moan and struggle to keep up the pace on Mayor Danvers’ cock. I pushed on her anus with a finger while I continued to lick it and felt the tightness squeeze me. It was going to feel awesome on my cock and I was definitely going to be the first man to have it.
“You don’t want to join us?” Mayor Danvers looked over to Major.
“In a minute...” I saw his hand moving along the zipper of his pants and I assumed he was playing with his cock. If he wanted to watch, I didn’t give a fuck.
My tongue moved in a circle while I worked a finger into her tight, virgin asshole. She moaned, practically orgasmic from the feeling, even with Mayor Danvers buried in her throat. The stimulation on her clitoris was enough to make her relax and lower her inhibitions and it wasn’t long until my finger was moving in and out of her anus fairly quickly. My saliva coated her and got her ready for what was coming. My cock was going to destroy her asshole and she was going to scream from pleasure before I
was done fucking it. If she was going to live there with us, she was going to have to give it to me. I expected every part of my woman to be mine for the taking—regardless of whether or not she had been fucked there or not. I could feel my cock rubbing against the crotch of my pants, begging to be buried inside of her. As much as I wanted it, there was no way I could do it until she was ready. She had to be well lubricated or it would be a failed endeavor. I glanced up and saw a look of pure bliss on Mayor Danvers’ face. He was hammering her throat so hard her whole body was shaking.
“Save something for Major.” I leaned back and chuckled, stroking my cock through my pants. I unsnapped the button on the front and started pushing them down.
“Since neither one of you want her pussy, I guess that is where I’m going.” Major stood up and started to undress.
“I’m not sure I want to be that close to Blue’s dick. Who knows where it’s been.” Mayor Danvers shook his head.