Five Masks of Sin (Haremworld)

“Well, this gentleman is leaving.” Xavier started towards the door, but Simon held his hand against it.

“Not yet.” Simon shook his head. “Like Maximo said, you’re still going to get to fuck her.”

“This really wasn’t what I had in mind. Maybe I should have known something was wrong because of how strongly you came onto me, but I guess I was just horny.” Xavier looked at the door again.

“You’re in the game now, my friend. You might as well play.” Maximo took a step closer. “You see, what we have here is a little cheater. A little cheater that is going to have to be punished.”

“I’m not a cheater!” I stomped my foot angrily.

“I’m definitely not into any of that.” Xavier shook his head again. “I don’t want to play whatever weird game you freaks have planned.”

“Okay.” Simon exhaled and pulled the door open. “You can go if that is what you really want.”

“It is—but.” He dug my pin out of his pocket. “Lyric? Are you sure you want me to just leave you here with these guys? You don’t have to stay if you don’t want to.”

“I’m staying.” I exhaled sharply.

“Okay.” Xavier handed me my pin and ran out the door without even trying to get his own back.

“So how are we going to punish this little cheater?” Simon pushed the door closed and chuckled.

“I don’t know.” Maximo smacked his lips and smiled.

“I can think of a few ways.” Lenny chuckled and rubbed his chin.

“I think we should start with a spanking. She already told me that she wanted one.” Simon stepped up and squeezed my ass.

“I like it when you were inside me, I don’t want to just get spanked!” I pulled away and ran into Maximo, who grabbed my arms.

“Yeah, I think a spanking would be a good place to start.” Maximo nodded. “It’s not really my thing, but would you like to do the honors, Simon?”

“Oh, absolutely.” Simon walked up and started pulling my dress up.

“Simon, stop it!” I struggled in Maximo’s grasp.

“After your done spanking her ass, I wanna fuck it.” Lenny nodded. “I always wanted to bugger a pretty thing like her.”

“What? No!” I shook my head back and forth as I looked over at Lenny. “You’re not fucking me there!”

“Maybe we should all three fuck her asshole tonight and send her to bed without an orgasm.” Maximo smiled again.

“What?” I looked back at Maximo and my mouth fell open.

“That sounds like a good punishment.” Simon finished pulling my dress up and then pushed my panties to the floor. “Okay, you little cheater. Time for you to spend some time over my knee.”

“You’re really going to spank me?” I looked at Simon and tried to pout. “Just do it like you did it the other night. I liked it then. You can spank me all you want if you’re inside me.”

“That was for fun—this is for punishment.” Simon shook his head and wrapped his arms around my waist, which allowed Maximo to let go of me.

I felt like madness had overtaken the three guys that had treated me so well up to that point. Simon carried me to the sofa and sat down, pulling me across his knee. My dress was around my hips and I had lost my panties somewhere along the way. My ass was on full display, and bent underneath his palm. He rubbed it slightly, letting his fingernails drift across my flesh. Maximo and Lenny took a seat across from us on the two chairs in the room. For a guy that didn’t like being called Daddy, he definitely seemed to like dealing out punishment like one.

“Do all of you really think I’m a cheater?” I looked Simon and then over to the other two guys.

“Yes.” Maximo nodded quickly. “I told you to go seduce a guy.”

“Sounds like cheating to me.” Lenny nodded along with Maximo.

“Fine...” I exhaled sharply and stared straight ahead. “Get it over with, then. Punish me for what I did—what you convinced me to do.”