Temptation & Trouble (Surrender to Them 2)

I had been living with Harlan and Gabe for a month. My situation was a lot better than it was when I arrived. I actually liked coming home to spend time with them, even if I got disinterest from one and lust-soaked stares from the other. I didn’t need alcohol to numb the pain, because they could always make me laugh. I felt like I had been put in the friend zone by Harlan, but it didn’t mean I couldn’t enjoy having a conversation with him. Gabe was ridiculously charming, even if he was a bit of an asshole at times.

The best part about the arrangement was that neither one of them seemed to want me to leave. I thought I would only be staying with them long enough to get back on my feet, but that wasn’t the case. When I suggested getting a second job and looking for an apartment, Gabe countered with an offer to let me enroll in college and stay with them until I graduated—he even offered to pay my tuition. It was quite a commitment from a man that only seemed to be interested in getting my panties off. Harlan immediately backed up Gabe’s offer by telling me I would be foolish to turn him down.

I guess Harlan is upstairs?

I was excited to let them both know that I had stopped by the university on the way home and registered for classes. I walked up the stairs and when I got to the top, I noticed that Harlan’s door was closed. I had every intention of knocking, but when I got closer, I saw that it wasn’t closed completely. There was a thin sliver of light and I could hear a noise on the other side that sounded like he was watching a video on his laptop. I put my hand on the door and pushed it gently, which caused it to open wider. I wasn’t prepared for what I saw. Harlan was sitting in his computer chair with his laptop open in front of him. The sound I heard wasn’t just a video—it was porn. He was naked from the waist down and his hand was gently stroking his fully erect cock.

Oh my god! Fuck, this was a mistake.

I wanted to look away, but I was mesmerized by what I saw. I had never seen a cock before when it was erect. I had certainly never seen a man masturbate. I had felt Chad’s through his pants when we fooled around, and I even made him cum, but we never went past that point. Watching Harlan’s hand move up and down his shaft as he watched the girl on the screen devour the dick she was sucking made my panties wetter than they had ever been before. My hand slid down my shirt and I unfastened my jeans. What I was doing was dirty and wrong, but I couldn’t control myself. I shifted my jeans down my hips until I could get my hand between my legs and started furiously rubbing my clit through my panties.

I would love to walk into his room and do exactly what he’s watching—I’d replace his hand with my lips in an instant.

“What a dirty girl.” A voice startled me from my trance and I nearly jumped out of my tennis shoes when I turned to see Gabe behind me.

“Shit, fuck!” I yanked my hand out of my jeans and started down the hallway, but Gabe blocked my path.

“Where do you think you’re going?” Gabe shook his head back and forth with a smile on his face.

“What the fuck is going on out here?” I heard Harlan’s voice and he pushed his head through the crack in the door.

“We seem to be living with a spy.” Gabe took a step forward and pushed my shoulder with a playful nudge. “Why don’t you tell Harlan what you were doing, dirty girl? Or maybe the fact that your ass is hanging out of your jeans is enough for him to figure it out.”

“You were watching me?” Harlan’s tone was a mixture of shock and confusion.

“She was doing more than watching, man, this dirty girl was rubbing one out along with you.” Gabe chuckled and shook his head.

“Wow.” Harlan’s voice went flat. “You really are all grown up now.”

“I don’t know about that.” Gabe continued to chuckle. “If I were you, I’d take this invasion of privacy very seriously—I think she needs a spanking.”

“What? No!” I shook my head back and forth. “Harlan, I’m sorry—I came up the stairs—I saw you…”

“It’s fine.” Harlan exhaled sharply. “I guess I should have made sure the door was completely closed. I thought I had plenty of time before anyone got back.”

“I still think she needs a spanking.” Gabe took another step towards me and I stepped back, standing with my back to the wall so I could see both of them.

“Well, she has been quite naughty.” Harlan laughed and I saw a half-smile form on the edge of his lips.

“What about it, dirty girl? Are you going to let Daddy Harlan give you the spanking you deserve?” Gabe bit down on his lip and grinned.

Oh my god, is this really happening?

“Do you… want to give me a spanking?” I turned towards him completely and felt my heart beating hard in my chest.

“Right now, I’m thinking about doing a lot more than that.” Harlan exhaled sharply and his eyes traced my body.

“He’s going to make you scream.” Gabe’s closed the distance between us and I felt his breath on my neck. “But he’s not the only one. I’ve wanted you since the second I laid eyes on you, and I’m not waiting anymore.”

“Hold on…” I felt my legs shaking when Gabe gave me a gentle push towards Harlan’s room. “I’ve never done this before.”

“That’s okay, you’ll learn that two is a lot better than one.” Gabe’s lips were so close to my neck that I could feel his words against my skin.

“No—I mean—I’m still a virgin.” I looked at Harlan and saw his eyes open wide with surprise.

“Huh? How?” Harlan face twisted into a confused stare. “You were engaged to that dumbass who cheated on you for two years!”

“What kind of idiot doesn’t pop this cherry the first chance he gets?” Gabe’s tone had as much confusion as what I saw on Harlan’s face.