Temptation & Trouble (Surrender to Them 2)

And they are staying off until we’re done with her.

Chapter Ten

Gabe

I wasn’t just in trouble, I was in over my fucking head. The little temptress might as well have been spinning a web designed to entangle me. No woman had ever resisted me like she had. Hell, no woman was even worth the effort if their panties weren’t melting off the instant I whispered dirty things in their ear. I wasn’t one to waste an opportunity, and that was exactly what I saw in front of me when I caught Kacey spying on Harlan. He was too chivalrous to take advantage of her. He needed to see her lust before he could open his eyes. The woman he married had almost ruined him, but with any luck, Kacey was going to make him forget all about that manipulative bitch.

I knew Harlan’s desires after spending four years with him at college tag teaming every girl we could get back to our room. He liked being in control. That was what he lost when he married a woman who crushed the alpha inside him. I had tried to resurrect that spirit with the women I brought home, but none of them could draw his real desires to the surface. He loved having a woman over his knee. Hearing them whimper while they begged for more was the ultimate aphrodisiac for him. It was a risk to put Kacey in that position without knowing if she would be into it, but she wasn’t just into it—she loved it.

“Damn, what’s taking this delivery driver so long?” I reached over and checked the time on my cell phone.

“Anxious for some reason?” Harlan chuckled and sipped his beer.

“You’re not?” I leveled my gaze at him. “You’re not thinking about what we’re going to get to do once she’s ready for another round?”

“It’s all I’m thinking about.” A grin spread across Harlan’s face.

“Yeah.” I leaned back and sighed. “Me too.”

“So what does this mean for you?” Harlan put his beer on the table and tilted his head inquisitively. “Are you going to start bringing girls home again once you get what you want from Kacey?”

“I don’t think so.” I shook my head back and forth. “I don’t know what it is about her, but… it’s different.”

“Uh oh, you’re not going to fall in love with her, are you?” Harlan’s face twisted into a stare of concern.

“I’ve never been in love.” I scoffed and waved him off with my hand. “You know I don’t do that shit.”

“Maybe we just take it one day at a time—starting now.” Harlan looked over his shoulder when the doorbell rang.

I watched as Harlan headed to the door and a few seconds later, I heard footsteps on the stairs behind me. The doorbell had apparently woke up our sleeping princess. She walked into the kitchen rubbing her eyes. I was disappointed to see that she had covered her beautiful curves with a pajama top, but when she got closer, I saw she wasn’t wearing any panties underneath it. Just seeing the bottom of her heart-shaped ass peeking out at me was enough to make my cock hard again. I wanted to feel her virgin pussy wrapped around my dick. It was all I could think about when she sat down next to me.

Fuck dinner—I’m ready for my dessert right now.

Chapter Eleven

Kacey

I never sat across from Gabe without knowing that his eyes wanted more than just what he could see. Seeing that same look from Harlan was strange. We all knew what was going to happen once we were done eating. None of us ate very much. The real hunger couldn’t be satisfied by food. When I put my fork down, Gabe was the first to stand. He didn’t even walk around the table. He slid the table out of the way and created a direct path to my chair. His hand went behind my neck and he pulled me to my feet. His lips were on mine in an instant. There was passion in his kiss—a craving for more. Harlan joined him and started kissing my neck while Gabe ravaged my mouth, bruised my lips even more, and when he finally had to pull away to draw a breath, he pushed me towards Harlan.

Harlan’s kiss was euphoric. It was like fireworks in my head. There was a connection there—something that went further than lust. We both felt it. It had been inside me for a long time, but I finally felt it echoing from his soul. When Harlan broke the seal our lips had formed, I was gasping for breath, but I wasn’t done. I immediately turned to Gabe and started kissing him. I felt Harlan’s hands on my body, exploring my curves as he pulled at the only piece of clothing I had on. The three of us started moving towards the stairs, and when we got to the bottom step, Gabe picked me up in his arms.

“You walk too slow.” He grinned and started ascending up the stairs.

“That’s cause the two of you keep distracting me.” I put my hand on his chest as he continued carrying me. “Not that I’m complaining.”

Gabe dropped my naked body on the bed and the two of them climbed onto it. Their lips were on my body immediately. They kissed and teased my pleasure points, making me quiver until my pussy was extremely wet. Gabe rubbed my clit with his finger and Harlan started to push one inside me. I wasn’t sure which one would actually fuck me first, but when I saw Harlan moving down and positioning himself between my thighs, I was excited. He was the one I had wanted for so long, so it made sense for him to take my virginity. Gabe continued to kiss my nipples and rub my clit while Harlan lifted my legs. He unrolled a condom along his length and pressed his glans to my wetness. He started to push himself inside me and I let out a gasp.

“It won’t hurt long—just relax.” Gabe moved his lips up to mine and started kissing me.

There was pressure when my pussy was stretched to take the first inch of Harlan’s thick cock, and it started to hurt once he was against my hymen. I grimaced, but Gabe continued to crush my lips and kept me from squealing by rubbing my clit to give me a surge of pleasure. Harlan shifted his weight and I felt my hymen tear. There was a sharp sting followed by a little more pain when the torn flesh was stretched. He pulled back for a moment and then plunged himself past the point where the barrier once was. Gabe leaned back and smiled as Harlan went deeper. I watched as a couple of inches disappeared into my pussy, feeling each agonizing inch. I knew it would hurt, and I was ready for it. It was a lot better than I thought it would be with Gabe’s finger on my clit. Gabe squeezed my breasts and flicked his finger against my nipple, making my body tingle.

“As soon as he has you nice and stretched, I’m going to fuck you so hard that you’ll limp for a week.” Gabe growled and bit down on my nipple.

“I’ll leave a little left for you.” Harlan chuckled and grunted when he went deeper. “It’s so tight that I’m not sure a lifetime of fucking could wear it out.”

Gabe lifted up and rubbed his cock on my nipple for a moment before dragging it up near my lips. I kissed it lightly and started pulling it into my mouth. Harlan forced enough of his dick into me that he was able to start thrusting. The repeated motion hurt, but I adjusted to it fairly quickly. It focused on Gabe and tried to make his fat cock throb while Harlan penetrated me. Every inch that went inside me was another test of my resilience, but I knew it was necessary for me to lose my virginity. They had already made me feel so good. Their tongues were glorious, and I wanted to feel the majesty of sex. My body was already moving against Harlan’s dick, begging for more as he worked himself deeper.

“Just wait until he hits your g-spot.” Gabe ran his fingers through my hair and buried his cock in my throat. “You’re going to cum so fucking hard.”