“I—I don’t know. I wasn’t thinking clearly.” I drew a breath in as Andy walked around the table and put his hands on my shoulder.
“You don’t have to hide from what you want, because right now, we want the same thing.” Andy leaned down and pressed his lips to my neck. “You can have us both. Just admit that you want it.”
Both? Oh my god.
“I—I can’t.” I pushed my chair back and hopped to my feet. “Thank you for dinner, but I should be going now.”
Andy
“Don’t go.” I caught Holly’s arm as she started to walk towards the door. “There’s nothing to be afraid of.”
“Just let her go, Andy,” Zach growled under his breath and stood to his feet. “I didn’t ask you to share your date with me.”
“You didn’t have to.” I looked over at him and grinned. “I’ve only seen that look in your eyes a few times, and I know how much you like her.”
“This is heading in a direction that I didn’t expect.” Holly shook her head quickly and pulled away from me.
Holly started walking towards the door at a hurried pace, but as she got closer, her steps slowed to a halt before her hand touched the doorknob. She took a deep breath and turned around to face us. I had shared girls with my brother before. I knew how intoxicating the idea of being shared was for some women. If they looked at me with the lust-filled stare, then it was hard for them not to have those same thoughts when they saw Zach. Holly had that look in her eyes even if she didn’t want to admit it to herself. It wouldn’t have been fair for me to claim a woman as hot as her without giving her a chance to have us both. We didn’t have to fall in love, but we could set the bedroom on fire, even if the fire burned out when the sun came up. I liked her more than I was willing to admit, and perhaps I was trying to pull my brother into the mix in order to keep myself from falling for her. That would be a lot easier if we shared her.
“Let that hesitation guide you towards what you truly crave.” I walked up to Holly and took her hand. “You don’t have the strength to run because you know what you want.”
“I’ve never done anything like this before.” She looked up at me and swallowed hard.
“Let us show you how amazing it can be.” I pulled her close and ran my fingers across her lips. “You wanted to make the naughty list. We’ll show you that it is so much better than being nice.”
She looked away from me and looked at Zach. He was still standing by the table, practically frozen in place. Her stare snapped him out of his stupor and he slowly walked towards us. I took a step back as he approached and watched as the fire raged inside both of them. He took Holly’s hand and I saw goosebumps form on her arm. She wanted to be shared, and her inhibition was slowly fading away. Zach pulled her close and hesitated for a moment, but her lips were begging for his and he didn’t disappoint. As soon as he started to devour her gorgeous lips, I walked over and put my hands on her arms. My lips teased Holly’s neck and I lightly nibbled her earlobe until she started to squirm. There was no way s
he was going to run after that. She was letting her need flourish and it was beautiful.
“There’s something you should know before this goes any further.” Holly took a deep breath as her lips pulled away from Zach. “When I said I’ve never done anything like this before, I didn’t just mean being with two guys.”
“You’re a…” Zach’s eyes got wide.
“A virgin.” I grinned and took a step back. “Well, this is the best Christmas present ever.”
“That doesn’t bother you?” She looked at me and then turned towards Zach.
Bother us? No—that just makes tonight even more special than I realized.
“I really don’t know what to do—and I’m a little terrified of losing my virginity to two guys at the same time.” Holly sighed and looked down at the floor.
“We will take very good care of you.” I looked at my brother. “Won’t we Zach?”
“We’ll make it a night you’ll never forget.” Zach took her hands and smiled.
“Okay.” She swallowed hard and I saw the final lingering hint of concern fade from her eyes.
Now she belongs to us, and I’m going to enjoy devouring that gorgeous cherry.
“After tonight, you won’t even remember what it’s like to be a virgin.” I put my hands on her hips and slowly moved them down to cup her ass.
Zach
Things spun out of control before I even realized what was happening. I had no intention of encroaching on my twin brother’s girl. I wouldn’t have even followed her in the mall if I realized she was the one he was talking to. I couldn’t stop thinking about the kiss and even a slice of pie didn’t make me stop wishing for something a lot sweeter—the lips that were mine for a second. I did my best to conceal things, but Andy could read me like a book. He saw the way I had to quickly look away anytime my eyes wandered in her direction—he sensed the desires I was struggling to bury. Holly was different than the girls we shared before. She wasn’t just looking to hook up with twins—and she was a virgin. Normally that would have made me want to run in the other direction, but Holly was so enticing I couldn’t imagine pulling away from her if she wanted us both.
“Are you sure this is what you want?” I brought my lips up to Holly’s ear.
“Yes.” Holly moaned as Andy’s lips moved up the opposite side her neck and teased her ear.