Later that day
My head was spinning when I left the mall, but I had a huge grin on my face. I was apprehensive when Zach pulled me into the storage closet, but I didn’t regret one second of what we did once the door was closed. It was quick, dirty, and oh so fucking delicious. I probably should have let him pull out, but I was so consumed with my lust that common sense went completely out the window. I had no idea what would happen if I actually got pregnant, but I was pretty sure I was closer to menstruation that ovulation. It wasn’t something I had ever tracked—I never really needed to. Thinking about it did start to make me worry as I drove back home to get ready to head to their house. There was nothing I could do about it, regardless, and I wasn’t going to let it completely ruin Christmas. I only had a couple more days with the twins before our normal lives would tear us apart.
“Did you do anything fun today?” I stepped through the front door and Andy immediately wrapped his arms around me.
“No.” He shook his head back and forth. “Until now.”
I barely made it through the front door before Andy started to kiss me. His lips set me on fire every time I felt them crushing mine. That kiss was no exception. I could sense the hunger as he pushed his tongue into my mouth and began to kiss me with more ferocity. I had to pull away before I soaked the panties that had only been around my hips for an hour. Both of the twins were so fucking irresistible. Just looking into their eyes was enough to make me wet. I suppressed my desires, but not for long. As soon as we made it to the living room and sat down on the couch, he started kissing me again. His lips moved against my neck and he nibbled my ear—so much for not soaking my panties. I could already feel the lust spreading to the fabric between my legs. Andy unbuttoned my jeans, but before he could slide his hand into my panties, the front door opened and Zach walked in.
“Getting started without me?” He chuckled and tossed the Santa suit on the chair in the living room.
“I think we got started without Andy.” I looked at Zach and winked.
“What are you talking about?” Andy titled his head in confusion.
“Santa got a special treat today at the mall.” Zach sat down on the other side me and put his hands on my shoulders. “Best day ever.”
“Oh fuck, really?” Andy blinked in surprise as the realization spread across his face. “Now I regret not wearing the suit today.”
“Like you haven’t been putting your hand in the cookie jar while I’m at work.” Andy moved one of his hand down to my abdomen and flicked a finger against my unbuttoned jeans.
“Yeah, guilty as charged.” Andy chuckled and nodded.
“Did you at least make it to the grocery store today?” Zach pulled his hands away and leaned back on the couch.
“Yes, of course, I did.” Andy’s tone reflected disappointment that his brother would even ask the question. “We’ll have a wonderful Christmas dinner—part two.”
“Pie?” Zach cocked an eyebrow.
“Yes.” Andy sighed and nodded. “I didn’t get them from the grocery store this time though. I stopped at the bakery downtown that is supposed to have the best pie in Georgia.”
“Oh, they do!” I nodded quickly. “Can we—like eat some of that tonight? They’re so much better when they’re fresh!”
“The only pie I want is right here.” Andy rubbed his hand along my stomach and pushed a finger into the top of my panties.
“There will be plenty of time for that later.” Zach pushed his brother’s hand away. “I’m starving.”
“Easy for you to say when you’ve already had her today,” Andy grumbled under his breath.
We ate dinner, and Zach managed to convince Andy to slice into one of the pies once we finished with our meal. Once dinner was over, we made our way to the bedroom where another night of passion followed. Zach was as ravenous as ever, even after getting a visit from me at the mall. Andy decided that he deserved to fuck me twice since Zach had me earlier in the day, and I certainly wasn’t going to complain. I fell asleep between them with my body still aching from what we had done. Being there in the darkness with the two gorgeous men on each side of me was the best feeling in the world. I had no idea how I was going to crawl into my own bed once the vacation was over. I woke up the next morning and they were both in the kitchen, so I put on my clothes and walked in to join them.
“I was just leaving.” Zach stood and sighed. “I’m sorry—I have to be there early today because it’s Christmas Eve.”
“It’s okay. I’m sorry I slept so long.” I hugged Zach and gave him a kiss before he rushed towards the door.
“I guess it’s just the two of us again today.” Andy grinned once Zach was gone.
“You like that don’t you?” I walked around the table and traced his shoulders with my finger. “Having me all to yourself.”
“I don’t mind sharing you with Zach at all.” He leaned back against me. “I do like it when it’s just the two of us though—especially when you decide to be naughty.”
“I thought you already made me a good girl.” I wrapped my arms around his neck from behind and kissed his ear. “I seem to remember paying for everything I did wrong.”
“That doesn’t mean you won’t find a few switches in your stocking tomorrow morning.” He reached back and put his hand on my thigh.
“Do you really think Zach is going to let you use one of those on me?” I giggled and purred into his ear. “You wouldn’t hurt me anyway.”
“You were begging for more when you were across my knee.” He chuckled under his breath. “I think you liked it.”