Naughty & Nice (Surrender to Them 7)

“You know what happens to naughty girls.” Andy rubbed my ass and gave me a light smack.

“Yep—that’s what I’m counting on.” I gasped and moaned.

We moved to the bedroom and their hands traveled along my curves, pulling off my clothes with very little hesitation. I was grateful for any moment with them, especially when I thought the previous night was going to be our last. Every second was a gift that was better than any Christmas present—a true Christmas miracle. I was so wet and turned on by the time I was undressed that I was practically trembling with desire. I wanted more than I did the first night—because I knew it wasn’t going to be the last. There was no timeline in front of us ticking towards the eventual end. I was going to be in their arms as often as possible from the moment we were in until eternity consumed us. That was the best feeling in the world—to know that the two men exploring my body with their hands and lips didn’t want to stop. We found our own version of perfect in a relationship that few would actually understand.

“Have I been naughty enough for the switch tonight?” I wrapped my arm around Andy and grinned.

“I thought that was a little more painful than you liked.” He put his hand on my thigh and pressed his lips to my neck.

“It was different, but one wasn’t enough for me to find out if I liked it or not.” I pulled away and crawled onto the bed.

“I’ll grab your stocking.” Zach walked towards the living room, chuckling under his breath.

“You might have been naughty enough for Zach to punish you tonight.” Andy leaned across the bed and rubbed my ass. “He’s not normally into that sort of thing.”

Zach returned with the stocking, but he didn’t just pull one out—he took one switch for himself and handed one to Andy. They were both going to punish me. The thought of that made me tingle from head to toe. I couldn’t wait to spend a lifetime learning how much I enjoyed the combination of pain and pleasure with the both of them. They started off teasing me, letting the long, slender pieces of hickory rub against my skin with nothing more than a couple of light taps. That was enough to make me squirm, just thinking about the sting that would come with the first stroke of momentary agony landed. I moved my body against the wood, trembling and squirming as I prepared myself for the sting. I didn’t have to wait long—and to my surprise, Zach was the first one to raise the switch high in the air.

SWISH-CRACK, SWISH-CRACK

“Oh wow!” I exhaled sharply as Zach landed a quick swing, followed by one from Andy that crisscrossed the first mark.

“Did you like that?” Zach rubbed the spot where his switch has landed.

“Yes.” I moaned and shifted my weight until his finger was against my pussy. “Especially when I get a little bit of that after it.”

Zach rubbed my pussy for a few seconds and then the switch came again. The sharp sting was exhilarating. It really wasn’t the same as being spanked. The sharpness of the sting didn’t leave much hurt at first, but after I got a few, the sting started to persist for little longer. Having their fingers exploring my wetness to find out just how turned on it made me was enough for them to see that I didn’t want them to stop. I was pretty sure my ass was going to look like a candy cane by the time they were done, but I couldn’t control my own urges. I still didn’t understand why it made me so wet, but I wasn’t going to question it—especially since I had two men willing to take me to the depths of pleasurable pain without truly hurting me. I could tell by the bulges in the front of their pants that both of them were just as turned on as I was by what they were doing to me.

SWISH-CRACK, SWISH-CRACK

“Have you been punished enough.” Zach ran his finger along the spot where the switch had just landed.

“Maybe a few more—just a little bit harder.” I moaned and bit down on my lip. “Since I’ve been such a naughty girl.”

SWISH-CRACK, SWISH-CRACK, SWISH-CRACK, SWISH-CRACK

“Oh god!” I fell forward against the mattress and felt the pain course through my body.

“If we don’t fuck you soon, you’re going to orgasm before we even get started.” Andy tossed the switch on the floor and crawled into bed.

“I don’t want you to take turns tonight. I want both of you at the same time.” I gasped and lifted my ass back off the bed.

“We’re not going to say no to that Christmas present.” Zach slid his hand along my leg as he joined us on the bed.

Andy started kissing my neck and Zach pushed apart my punished cheeks. He rubbed my pussy and forced a finger inside of me until it was saturated with my lust. My untouched hole was theirs for the taking, and I couldn’t wait to find out how good it felt to have both of them inside me at the same time. It was a strange desire, but one that I was sure they could turn into a night I would never forget. Zach loosened me up with the finger that was inside my pussy while his tongue provided more lubrication, and then slowly inserted a second. It hurt, but I could feel my ass stretching for what would eventually be pushed inside it. Zach worked quick but gave me time to adjust. Andy ran his lips and tongue around my ear while tracing my neck, which kept me tingling the entire time. Once Zach had two fingers easily moving inside me, Andy dropped down on the bed and I straddled him.

“I bet you’re going to love finding out how hard you cum with both of us inside you.” Andy rubbed my pussy and guided me towards his cock once he had a condom on.

Zach slid a condom on his length as well and I felt him pushing between my punished cheeks. The head pushed past the band of resistance at the entrance of my ass and I grimaced when the pain of being stretched came with it. I tried to get some pleasure by slowly grinding on Andy’s cock, just trying to take my mind off it. I couldn’t move much or else Zach wouldn’t be able to enter me easily, but having Andy against my g-spot provided some relief. Zach started going deeper and stretched my untouched hole around his incredible girth. Every inch came with a few seconds of adjustment, and then he pushed a little more. It was different from the pain I felt when they took my virginity because there wasn’t as much pleasure from having my ass penetrated—not at first. After several minutes of agony, Zach was far enough in for Andy to start thrusting upward, and then I felt the first twinges of real pleasure.

“Oh!” My eyes opened wide and I dug my nails into Andy’s shoulder. “That—feels really good.”

“It’s going to get even better.” Zach pushed deeper and then started to slowly thrust.

Zach was very careful with me until my ass adjusted to taking his entire length. Once he gave me several gentle thrusts, he picked up the pace while Andy continued to drive his cock into my pussy. The combination quickly went from simply pleasurable to absolutely orgasmic. Their thrusts were timed so that both were going into me at the same time, and since they were twins, their cocks were identical in size. Having both of them go deep inside me made my body shake with bliss. The pace quickened and then they truly started to hammer me. I loved the way it felt. The pressure that built up inside me as my orgasm loomed was stronger than any orgasm I had with just one of them inside me. It made everything feel tighter and the pressure pushed against them as they slammed their gorgeous bodies into mine.

“You’re gonna make me cum!” I threw my head back and a squeal rushed across my lips.

“Hold out as long as you can.” Andy grabbed my hair and growled into my ear. “We’re both going to cum inside you at the same time.”