Hell (Black Heart Romance)

“I’ll give one choice today. Only one, so choose wisely,” I say as I stand and walk toward the hidden wall closet. As soon as I open it and the large shelving with sex toys comes into view, I can hear Rowan struggle against her restraints.

“Please, don’t do this,” she starts begging.

“You don’t even know what we’re going to do yet.” I pull out a vibrating butt plug, lube, and an open mouth gag. “Here is the choice you can make. You can either have this in your ass, and we take turns fucking your cunt, or I shove this in your cunt, and we fuck your ass?”

Her eyes go even wider as she considers my question.

“Tick tock, Rowan. I’m about to gag you, and it will be hard to understand anything you say once you have a cock in your throat.”

Alexei is already taking off his pants, his dick hard and ready as I position himself in front of her face. Her eyes ping pong between the plug in my hand and Alexei’s cock in front of her.

“Plug in my ass,” she blurts out, her voice shaky.

“Ass it is.” I nod, handing Alexei the gag.

I watch him put the gag ring into her mouth, so she is forced to keep it open. He fastens it around her head, making sure it’s tight enough but not too tight. Rowan is breathing heavily, her body is shaking, and her eyes are pleading.

“Fuck her face,” I order Alexei, who is all too eager to oblige.

Cradling her head in his large hands, he angles her face so it’s lined up with his cock. She whimpers as he pushes into her mouth, her eyes finding mine one last time, begging me not to hurt her.

I remain still, watching as Alexei thrust into her throat until she gags. She closes her eyes, tears running down the side of her beautiful face.

“Fuck yeah,” Alexei groans, shoving into her throat deeper and harder.

Slowly, I walk around until I’m behind her. Her ass bounces slightly every time Alexei thrusts into her. When she gags, I can see her puckered hole constrict as her whole body convulses.

Fuck, that’s gonna feel great around my dick.

Flipping the cap of the bottle open, I pour a generous amount of lube over her ass and the plug. I take my time working it in her ass, enjoying the way her puckered hole opens up and gives way to the intrusion while the sound of her gagging on my friend’s cock fills the room.

Once the plug is fully seated, I free my own cock and bring it to her waiting cunt. Lube from the plug drips down to her pussy, making me glide in with ease. In one hard thrust, I am all the way inside her. Rowan whimpers and struggles against the restraints, but I won’t show her any mercy, not today… or ever.

“Fuck, your cunt is even tighter with this plug in your ass,” I grunt.

Dropping the bottle of lube, I grab onto her hips and start fucking her furiously. My balls slap against her skin as I dig my fingers into her flesh with bruising force. Alexei and I fall into a rhythm, alternating thrusts.

Slowing down just a bit, I snake my hand around her front, find her clit, and start rubbing punishing circles over it. It doesn’t take her long before her distraught whimpers turn into moans.

“Be a good fuck toy and come for us,” I order, and she does almost immediately. Her whole body tightens, and her thighs quiver with her release.

Her cunt is squeezing me so tightly, I know if I don’t slow down, I’m gonna come soon.

“Let’s switch,” I tell Alexei. He looks over at me, giving me a quick nod.

I pull out of her and walk around to her front while Alexei takes his place behind her. Rowan’s head is hanging low, spit dripping from her open mouth as she catches her breath.

I take her head between both hands and force her to look at me. “You like getting fucked from both sides? Having all of your holes filled?”

She doesn’t nod or shake her head. Instead, she simply looks at me through teary eyes. “You look so beautiful right now. Tied up with your mouth forced open—completely helpless.” I wipe her tears with my thumbs and lean down to kiss her forehead. It’s an oddly gentle gesture compared to the rest of what we’re doing to her body.

When I stand back up, I guide my cock to her mouth and slowly press in. Her tongue caresses the underside of my cock, and my balls ache for release. I flex my hips and shove my cock into her wet mouth until I feel the back of her throat.

Heaven… that’s what this feels like. Pure heaven.

Her throat is trying to push me out, but I keep forcing my cock down as far as she can handle. Every time I pull out, she gasps for air, coughing out spit.