And Then She Fell (The Cynster Sisters Duo 1)

Chapter One

April 1837

London

It was time to dress for what was sure to prove a trying evening. As she climbed the stairs of her parents’ house in Upper Brook Street, Henrietta Cynster mentally rehearsed the news she would have to impart to her friend Melinda Wentworth when they met as arranged at Lady Montague’s ball.

Henrietta sighed. Reaching her bedroom door, she opened it and halted on the threshold, arrested by the sight of her younger sister, Mary, riffling through the jewelry box on Henrietta’s dressing table.

Mary acknowledged Henrietta’s arrival with a flick of her eyes and continued pawing through the jumble of chains, earrings, brooches, and beads.

Movement drew Henrietta’s attention to the armoire beside her bed. Her maid, Hannah, was lifting out Henrietta’s new royal-blue ball gown, simultaneously shooting disapproving glances at Mary’s slender back.

Stepping inside, Henrietta shut the door. Like her, Mary was still in her day gown and hadn’t yet changed. Curious, she studied Mary’s intent expression; the baby of the family, Mary had the single-minded focus of a terrier when it came to anything she wanted. “What are you looking for?”

Mary threw her an impatient glance. Shutting one drawer, she reached for the last, the bottom drawer in the box. “The—aha!” Inserting, then withdrawing, her fingers, Mary’s face transformed as she held up her find, suspending it between the fingers of both hands. “I was looking for this.”

Eyeing the necklace of fine gold links interspersed with polished amethyst beads from which a faceted rose-quartz crystal hung, then noting that Mary’s expression now held the satisfaction of a general who’d just learned his troops had captured a vital enemy position, Henrietta waved dismissively. “It’s never done anything for me. You’re welcome to have it.”

Mary’s vivid blue eyes swung to Henrietta’s face. “I wasn’t looking for it for me.” Mary held out the necklace. “You have to wear it.”

The necklace had been gifted to the Cynster girls by a Scottish deity, The Lady, and was supposedly a charm to assist the wearer in finding her true hero, the man by whose side she would live in wedded bliss for the rest of her life. Pragmatic and practical, Henrietta had always had difficulty believing in the necklace’s efficacy.

More, in the same pragmatic vein, she’d always considered it was unreasonable to expect that all seven Cynster girls of her generation would find love and happiness in the arms of their true heroes, that it was in the cards that one, at least, would not achieve that outcome, and if that were the case, then the Cynster girl destined to die an old maid would, almost certainly, be her.

As she and Mary were the only two Cynster females of their generation yet unwed, her prediction of her spinster-forever state seemed well on the way to becoming fact. She was already twenty-nine and had never been even vaguely tempted to consider marrying any gentleman. Conversely, no one in their right mind would imagine that twenty-two-year-old Mary, dogged, determined, and unswervingly set on defining and forging her future life, would not achieve her already trenchantly stated goal—namely finding and marrying her hero.

Sliding her shawl from her shoulders, Henrietta shook her head. “I told you—it’s never worked for me. You may take it with my blessing. I presume that’s what this is about—that you want to use it to find your hero?”

“Yes, exactly.” Mary’s expression hardened. “But I can’t just take it. It doesn’t work that way. You have to wear it and find your hero first, and then hand it to me just as Angelica handed it to you, and Eliza handed it to Angelica, and Heather handed it to Eliza before that—on the evening of your engagement ball.”

Turning to set the shawl on a chair, Henrietta hid a smile—that of an older, more mature sister at her little sister’s enthusiastic belief in the charm. “I’m quite sure it’s not that specific. There’s nothing to say it has to work for us all.”

“Yes, there is.” There was no mistaking the crisp certainty in Mary’s tone; as Henrietta turned back to her, she went on, “I asked Catriona, and she asked The Lady, and it’s The Lady’s charm, after all. And according to Catriona, The Lady was very clear. The necklace has to go from one to the other of us in the stipulated order. Specifically, the necklace won’t work for me if it hasn’t already worked for you and you haven’t had your engagement ball. So!” Mary drew in a breath and, jaw set, held the necklace out to Henrietta. “You have to wear this. From now until you find your hero—and pray to The Lady and all the gods that that will be soon.”

Frowning slightly, Henrietta reached out and reluctantly lifted the necklace from Mary’s fingers. Refusing it . . . wasn’t really an option. Henrietta might be older, more mature, more experienced socially; she might be taller by nearly a head, and she certainly wasn’t any weak-willed miss, but the entire Cynster clan knew that attempting to deny Mary something she’d set her heart on was a fool’s endeavor, and that was doubly true if she had a logical argument to bolster her case.

Letting the links slide through her fingers, Henrietta once again studied Mary’s face. “Why are you so eager to have the necklace now? You know I’ve had it since Angelica’s engagement ball, and that was nearly eight years ago.”

“Precisely.” Belligerently, Mary narrowed her eyes back. “So you’ve had eight years to wear it and find your hero, and instead you’ve put it in your jewelry box and left it there. That didn’t matter while I was still in the schoolroom. Even after I was presented, I wanted to look around myself, so you not wearing the necklace wasn’t a pr

oblem. But I’m twenty-two now, and I’m ready to take the next step. I want to find my hero forthwith, and start my marriage and set up my own household, and all the rest that comes with marrying. Unlike you, I don’t want to spend the next seven or more years doing other things, which means”—Mary jabbed a finger at the necklace—“that you have to wear that now, find your hero, and then pass it on to me. Only once I have the necklace can I get on with my life.”

Others might have accepted that at face value, but Henrietta knew her little sister just a little too well. “And . . . ?”

Mary held her gaze, vivid cornflower-blue eyes steady and unyielding.

Henrietta tipped her head, arched her brows, and waited. . . .

“Oh, all right!” Mary flung up her hands in surrender. “And I think I might have found my perfect hero, but I need the necklace to be sure. The necklace is supposed to come to me, work for me, and then go to Lucilla, so it seems I’m supposed to wait for the necklace before I decide on my hero, and, well, it would seem to be flying in the face of fate and The Lady to make any final hero-decision before I get the necklace, and I have to have it in the proper way.” Mary’s expression firmed; her eyes bored into Henrietta’s. “Which means you have to wear it and find your hero first.”

Henrietta looked down at the necklace, at the innocent links draped over her hand. And sighed. “All right. I’ll wear it tonight.”

Mary uttered a whoop of delight.

Henrietta held up a staying hand. “But I don’t expect it to work for me, so don’t get your hopes up.”

Mary laughed and darted in to plant a quick peck on Henrietta’s cheek. “Just wear it, sister-mine—that’s all I ask. As for it working”—eyes twinkling, Mary swung toward the door—“I’ll put my faith in The Lady.”

Smiling, Henrietta shook her head.

Mary paused at the door. “Are you joining Mama and me at Lady Hammond’s tonight?”

“No—I’m expected at Lady Montague’s.” Given Henrietta’s age, she often attended different events than those to which their mother escorted Mary. “Have fun.”

“I will. I’ll see you tomorrow.” With a wave, Mary went out of the door, shutting it behind her.

Still smiling, the necklace in one hand, Henrietta turned to discover that Hannah had put her new gown back in the armoire and instead laid out a gown of purple silk.

Catching Hannah’s gaze as the maid turned from the chest of drawers, a purple-and-gold silk shawl in her hands, Henrietta arched a brow.

Correctly interpreting the gesture, Hannah assured her, “The royal blue won’t do, miss, not if you’re wearing that.” Eyes bright, Hannah nodded at the necklace. “And if you’re going out looking for your hero, we want you to look your best.”

Henrietta inwardly sighed.

Two hours later, Henrietta joined Mr. and Mrs. Wentworth by the side of Lady Montague’s ballroom. After exchanging greetings, they stood and watched the Wentworths’ daughter, Melinda, who was dancing a cotillion.

Melinda’s partner was the Honorable James Glossup.

It was James’s motives in paying court to Melinda that had brought Henrietta there; she found herself studying him, absorbing all that his appearance and his expertise in the dance conveyed, and wondering—as she had for the past several days—why, given his transparent attractiveness and accomplishments, James had taken the tack he had with respect to finding a bride.

Mrs. Wentworth, a short, comfortably rotund lady in brown bombazine, sighed. “It’s such a shame—they make such a handsome couple.”

“Now, now.” Mr. Wentworth, a solid, conservatively dressed gentleman, patted his wife’s hand where it rested on his sleeve. “There’ll be other handsome bucks that’ll come sniffing around, and as Mellie’s of a mind to find a gentleman who loves her . . . well, I’m just grateful to Miss Cynster for finding out what she has.”

Henrietta smiled faintly and quashed an impulse to squirm. She didn’t know James well, but he was her brother Simon’s closest friend; James had been Simon’s groomsman when Simon had married two years ago. Consequently, James’s and her paths had crossed at several family functions, but beyond what she’d gathered through his association with Simon, she’d had no reason to look more closely at James.