The Slaying of the Shrew (Shakespeare & Smythe 2)

“There is an entire company of players who would give you a good argument upon that score,” said Smythe, with a self-deprecating grin. “And as my Uncle Thomas used to say, ‘ ‘Tis a wise man who knows his limitations.’ I am well aware of mine, Elizabeth, for better or for worse.”

“Then why do you persist in your desire to be a player? You told me once that you had learned the craft of smithing from your uncle, and that he had also taught you how to forge fine blades. Both pursuits are honorable trades. Why, a good armorer could, with the right patronage, achieve a reputation and advance himself into the gentry. That would not be out of your reach, you know. My father is already indebted to you, as is Sir William. Both men, I am quite certain, would be more than willing to assist you if you wanted to set up in trade. And if you were to become a gentleman, why then, Father could have no possible objection to our seeing one another.”

“ Elizabeth,” said Smythe, squeezing her arm gently, “your father has objected to more than one gentleman already. And aside from that, becoming a gentleman does not always solve one’s problems. My father is a gentleman, with his own escutcheon, for all the good that it has done him.”

She stood and stared at him, startled. “What! But you have never told me this!”

He merely shrugged. “I saw no reason to make mention of it.”

“No reason! No reason, indeed! You mean to tell me that you come from a good family? That your father is a gentleman, a country squire, and you came to London to become an ostler?” She stared at him with disbelief.

“I came to London to become a player.”

“Well, you were an ostler when we met and, in any event, a player is not much better than an ostler in my father’s eyes. But do not try to change the subject! Why did you not tell me?”

“Because I do not see what difference it could possibly have made,” said Smythe.

“To me, none,” Elizabeth replied, “but ‘twould have made a world of difference to my father!”

“Methinks not,” said Smythe. “ ‘Twould only have made matters worse, if your father knew the truth of it.”

“Whatever do you mean? What truth?”

“My father is a very vain and foolish man,” said Smythe, without any trace of bitterness or rancor. “I know ‘tis disrespectful to speak so of one’s parent, but if it makes me a bad son to speak the truth, so be it, then. The truth is that my father wanted so to be a gentle-man, to have an escutcheon of his own that he could blazon upon the windows and the mantle and the entryway, embroider upon the blue coats of his servants and gild upon his coach, that he spent a goodly portion of his inheritance in currying favor and paying bribes and buying influence. In time, and at no little cost, he was able to achieve his goal and was eventually granted his escutcheon by the heralds, which he then proceeded to affix to everything you could imagine, from his pewter cups to his gauntlets and his handkerchiefs of Flemish lawn and sarcenet. Meanwhile, my Uncle Thomas, to whom I had been sent for rearing, had no such lofty ambitions or pretensions. Even if he had, he could ill afford them, for ‘twas my father as the eldest who had been favored in the will.”

“And you mean t

o say he never helped your uncle?” asked Elizabeth.

“That matter was never formally discussed with me, but I am as certain that my uncle never asked as I am that my father never offered,” Smythe replied. “Who is to say but that had my father raised me, instead of Uncle Thomas, then perhaps I might have turned out more like him, so I am grateful that my uncle was much more of a father to me than the man whose name I bear.”

“But it nevertheless is the name of a gentleman,” Elizabeth said.

“Aye, a gentleman who was not satisfied with having achieved the rank that he had bought so dearly and instead newly set his sights upon a knighthood. To which end, he spent himself very nearly into debtors’ prison. He is now little better than a pauper, and the truth is I rather doubt your father would find very much about him of which he could approve.”

“For all that they seem to have so much in common,” Elizabeth said, wryly, referring to her father’s own considerable social ambitions. “Oh, but Tuck, why did you never tell me this?”

“As I have said, I saw no reason for it. My father is my father, for better or for worse, as I am myself. I have no part of his accomplishments or failures. I prefer to be judged on my own merits, or the lack of them, whichever the case may be. And ‘twas never my desire to be like my father, or my Uncle Thomas, for that matter, for all of the respect and love I bear him. Toiling at a forge is hard and honest work, good work, and I believe I am an able craftsman, but the truth is that it has never been my passion. Ever since I saw my first play acted out upon a tavern stage, I have wanted to become a player. ‘Tis all I ever wanted. Nothing more.”

“And your father did not approve, of course,” Elizabeth said, nodding with understanding.

“Aye, he did not. He stormed and thundered, threatened to disown me, but I would not give up my dream, and in the end, when he had squandered what was left of his inheritance-and mine-I realized at last that there was nothing left to hold me, and so I left home and came to London to pursue my dream. Perhaps I am as vain and foolish in that as my father was in his pursuit of social position and a knighthood, so who am I to judge him?”

Elizabeth smiled and placed her hand upon his as he held her arm. “I would not call you a bad son,” she said, softy. “I think you are a far better one than he deserves.”

“Well, that is neither here nor there,” said Smythe, a bit uncomfortably, though it felt wonderful to hear that from her. “The point is, whatever I am to make of myself, I must do it by myself.”

“I understand how you must feel,” she said, after a moment’s pause, “but I do not think I can agree.”

“Indeed? And why is that?”

“Because I can see no particular virtue in refusing help when it is offered, or in refusing to take advantage of social connections. We live, after all, in a society where such connections are pursued with vigor and people are often rewarded not for merit, but for the relationships that they have cultivated. Why, even the queen bestows rewards upon her favorites, who vie with one another for position. I have seen my father thrive in such a fashion, which is how he has built his business and his fortune.”

“And I have seen my father bring himself to ruin doing just the same,” said Smythe.

“Because he did not do it wisely,” said Elizabeth. “You said yourself that he had tried to buy his way into a knighthood. I was not trying to suggest that you should attempt to purchase favor, as he did, merely that you should not scorn the favor you have already earned. Consider your friend, Will.”

“What has Will to do with any of this?”