Noelle (Babysitter’s Club 4)

“I’ve missed you so much.” I wrapped my arms around her tight until there was no space between us, our hearts beating wildly together as one. As I felt her body coming down I started moving again.

“Go up for me again. I need to feel you cumming over and over again.” I didn’t give her time to question my earlier slip, but instead carried her away with my kiss as my body got reacquainted with hers.

I had a decision to make, now that I knew she was no longer afraid. Do I fuck her all night and into the early morning? Or should I let her rest? I already knew the answer even before I asked myself.

It’s always been hard for me to leave her. And even though I know she’s going to hurt like hell come morning, there’s no way I was going to leave her now.

Besides, she didn’t want me to. She was moving again, pulling at me with her arms and legs as her pussy did what it does best. Captivating me with its tight softness.

As lightning flashed across the sky I knew I had to cum soon. Everything had to be perfect, there could be no slip-ups.

I knew that when I cum in her this first time that in a few months her belly would swell with my sons. I know that I’d done all within my power this time to give her and the children a chance.

The thoughts in my head made my hips move faster and I pounded into her no longer worried about hurting her tight pussy. I knew no matter how sore she became she’d never turn me away.

The question is, would I have enough control to keep her off my dick so she didn’t hurt herself. Or will I give into her lustful pleas when the time comes?

Whatever the answer, I put it out of my head now as I felt my body begin to tingle as I slammed into her. I released her lips and let her cries ring out as I shoved my cock as deep inside her as it would go.

“Cum with me. I want to feel you.” I reached between us to find her clit and teased it with my thumb as my cock shot the first volley into her womb.

Her eyes rolled back in her head and her body stiffened as my cock blasted off inside her so hard my sight went dark for a split second. I was no longer in control, my body had taken over; doing what it was meant to. Breeding its mate.

Her pussy sucked and pulled until my balls were dry and I was drained of all strength. Even when I dropped my head on her shoulder, all energy gone, her pussy was still trying its best to get the last of my seed from my sac.

I should roll away from her and let her breathe, but even before I tried, I knew she wouldn’t let me. She wrapped me up tight with her arms and legs and I understood when I felt her warm tears against my flesh.

I laid there for the next ten minutes, until my cock went down enough for me to pull out without hurting her. I looked down between her thighs and the sight of the blood splattered there made me sick.

I hate that I hurt her, but there was nothing to be done. Each time we meet it’s my duty to take her maidenhead. I’m the only man to ever have her and no one else ever will. Not in this life or the next!

I dropped down beside her and drew her into my chest. This was as much a part of our lovemaking as the act itself. That sweet moment that comes after.

As we laid there with her head on my chest enjoying the euphoria of the afterglow, I let my mind drift to the days ahead. There was much that needed to be done. Much I had to tell her.

With one last kiss to the top of her head I tried moving her off of me, but she clung. “I’ll be right back Noelle, I need to go run you a bath.” Her answer was to throw one of her legs over both of mine and hug me tighter.

She whined a complaint and I smiled over her head. Always the stubborn one; that too never changes. “Let me up love or you’ll hurt for sure tomorrow. Come on!” I tapped her shoulder and eased her off of me before rolling away.

I never forget that I’m the one who has to take care of her even when she fails to do so herself. In the bathroom I ran a hot bath and poured the healing salts I had on hand for just this purpose.

She was half asleep when I returned to get her and just curled into me when I lifted her from the bed. She barely stirred when I stepped into the steaming water and sat with her on my lap.