Sharing Her

I hated them...but they were also the reason I had this stupid fantasy of getting taken by two guys. They joked about both of them taking me out on a date once, and the thought never left me, even though they were being mean.

“You’ve certainly changed, Maddie,” Mike says, drinking me with his eyes. “Come on in, let’s see you.”

I blush furiously. I’m wearing nothing under my big fur coat and high heels, just like the contract said, but I feel so embarrassed I want to run away.

“What’s the matter, Mads?” Brett teases, taking my coat and pulling me inside. I don’t stop him. “Having second thoughts?”

“I didn’t know it would be you two.”

“So you’d do it with strangers?” Mike says as he closes the door behind me, trapping me in this massive, lavish manor. “That’s not the Maddie I know.”

“Wait, you still want this? With me?” I ask in disbelief.

“You didn’t know we always liked you, Maddie?” Mike says, and I’m shocked when he comes up behind me and puts his hips against my ass. I feel his cock thick already, and I go redder than my hair. “We both did, we just didn’t want to share back then.”

“We’re more open minded, now,” Brett says, stepping forward and cupping my face in his big, rough hand. I’m getting wet already, and I hate myself for it, but this is a fantasy coming true. “Why’d you think the contract asked for a redhead just your height? But I never thought we’d land the actual Ma

ddie.”

It all made sense now, and there was no backing out. One night, anything they wanted, no condoms, and all my tuition would be paid off by the huge paycheck they were giving me.

“You can still leave,” Brett says, running his thumb over my lower lip. “Says so in the contract. But as soon as this is off and little Maddie shows us what she’s got,” he says, bringing his hand to my coat, “you’re all ours.”

He says it in such a husky tone that my head swims. I bite my lip...and before I can give myself time for doubt, I shrug the coat off my body.

I’m on the short side, and I have pale skin with freckles on my shoulders. My breasts are round and firm, and I’m a little proud of my ass, which my long red hair almost touches. I can still smell my strawberry perfume. All in all, I think I look okay, but Brett is looming over me with a look on his face like he wants to tear into me right then.

Imagine my surprise when he does just that.

Brett steps forward and presses his lips to mine, and I suck in a sharp breath as he grabs my tits and squeezes. I’m ashamed to realize my nipples are already stiff and probably have been since I saw these two again.

He backs me up into Mike, who’s like a stone wall, and I feel his thick cock on my naked butt.

What are you doing, Maddie?!

I’m living out my teenage fantasy, that’s what.

“Someone’s happy to see us,” Brett says as he rubs his thumbs over my nipples in little circles. I can’t hold back a groan as he does, because Mike’s hands are holding my hips to his, and I feel his mouth on my neck, ravishing my soft skin.

“Has little Mads been thinking about this?” Mike whispers into my ear.

“I bet she studied for this,” Brett says when he breaks away from my lips.

All I can do is whimper, I can’t even defend myself against their incessant teasing. Suddenly, I feel like an awkward, gawky teenage nerd again, wishing the big jocks would pay attention to me.

All that time, I told myself it wouldn’t be worth it.

But with Brett’s hands fondling me and Mike’s on my ass, I know my expectations are already blown out of the water.

Mike slips his hand around my hips, and I whimper when his finger touches my clit. He starts playing with it as if I was just another one of his conquests, as if it comes naturally to him. I squirm and writhe, but Brett has my breasts feeling electrified, and I’m utterly helpless in their hands.

“Hold up, the contract said she has to be a virgin,” Mike says as he sticks his finger a little deeper into my wet pussy, discovering how ready I am for them. “Does that mean…?”

“Aww, Maddie was too shy to get a little action!” Brett mocks me as he takes a turn kissing my neck. I give a whimper of protest and try to squirm away, but they have such a hold on me that I’m totally theirs now.

“Waiting for us, Mads?” Mike growls into my ear, and while he moves his finger around my clit, he starts grinding into my ass. “Well you might like to know that no matter who we’ve dated all this time...we’ve just had you on our minds.”

“God, you’re so much hotter than I fantasized,” Brett adds, giving my breasts a squeeze that makes me melt in Mike’s arms. “You wanna take her upstairs, bro?” he asks Mike.