You Break Me (The Prospect 2)

“No sea to it, it is all dry land.”

“Nothing about me is dry right now,” she says on a groan.

She’s got that right her juices coat my fingers as I pump two in and out of her. “That what you want. The three of us tangled up together in your bed fucking.”

“Yes,” she hisses, squeezing my hand tight with the walls of her sweet pussy.

“One of us behind you and the other in the front. Or you want a dick in your mouth while I eat that pussy? Hmm, baby. Tell me what you want, and I’ll think about giving it to you.”

“Fuck that’s hot,” she coos. I pull my fingers out and lick them.

“Get over here and cum on my cock,” I demand.

She straddles my lap after I have unzipped my pants. Her hot little pussy sinks down on me, grinding warm and needy so fucking greedy. “Cruiz is gonna shove his dick down your throat.” I thrust up inside her. “I’m going to stick my tongue in your pussy and suck your clit until you cream on my mouth while he cums down your throat. Then we’re going to fuck you so damn hard.” I picture it in my head as Nikki rides me and much to my surprise the image gets me off.

“Oh God. Please, Grady.” She throws her head back and cums on my cock.

Chapter 30

Cruiz

Nikki called me said she needed to talk. What I wasn’t expecting is for Grady to be here when I get to her apartment. Sophia is gone to a sleepover or some shit with one of the girls on her cheerleading squad, so I guess Nikki has made a decision. Guess she wants us both to hear it at the same time.

She offers me a beer, but I decline. Ready to get this bullshit over with.

“So, what’s up? I’m here. Tell me whatever it is you gotta say to the two of us.” I’m not leaving without a fight, Grady can have her over my cold dead body.

“Grady and I have been talking and well we have come to a decision. It’s something we both want but we aren’t sure how open you’ll be to the idea.”

I squint unsure if I am hearing her correctly. “What are you asking me, Nikki?”

“I love you both and I don’t want to choose. I want to be with you both of you…together.”

I stare at her in shock. The fuck kinda shit she thinking? Is this just because of the pregnancy hormones? “What the shit? So, what? You want to date both of us? Basically cheating on me with him, with him on me, and if we cheat on you, you’ll kick us to the curb?” Which would be my second time seeing the damn curb after I fucked up by not being able to wait for Nikki to finally put out, and I fucked Susan.

“Yes,” she says, firmly.

“That’s fucked up. If you can fuck both of us, we should be able to be with others too.”

She shrugs. “I don’t see why you can’t when you’re on the road. Just wrap it. I don’t want to know about it. When you’re both home—you’re mine, and only mine.”

I can’t fuckin’ believe she’s okay with this, and Grady is looking smug about it too. If he thinks I’m gonna bow out of this so he can win, he’s got another thing coming. “So, what? You want tag teaming and shit?”

“Think of it as reverse Polygamy. I would never say no to having you both, at the same time, but I think we also need to have our relationship with each other defined more too. Rotate nights, basically we’re monogamous in a way.” She bites her lip, looking shy about saying this but also firm at the same time.

Grady speaks up. “I’m possessive as fuck, but I’m down for this. I’m down for a threesome, but I wouldn’t want it often, not a fan of fuckin’ a woman with another dude, but if it’s what Nikki wants, then that’s what she’ll get. But you and me will never be touching or shit if I can help it. Don’t even get it in your head that I’ll suck your dick or fuck you in the ass and no, motherfucker, I don’t want your dick near my asshole.”

I get what he’s saying, I’m possessive as fuck too, and what she’s saying makes sense. Except part of me hurts like fuck that she can’t choose between the two of us. I vowed that if I ever got her back, I would be faithful. I’m worried that at some point she’ll change her mind about letting us fuck around on her on the road. She says she’s fine with it now, but I can’t help feeling like it’s a test. A test I know Grady won’t pass at all.

“I know I vowed to never want either of you again, because of the Susan shit, but when I think of not having you, either of you, my heart breaks and I feel sick. I need you both in my life, and no matter what you will be because of history, this child, just everything. You know?”

Fuck, her words break me, Grady even has a look of remorse on his face, something I’ve never seen from him before. The room is blanketed in silence, no one speaks. I know I need to speak, I just can’t find the words. Will seeing her with him kill me? Would I be able to reel in my jealousy? Only one way to test this out.

I reach towards her, grabbing her hand and pull her towards me, making her straddle my lap. Her pussy sits directly on my cock, making me harden instantly. I cup her face, bringing it towards me and press our mouths together. She moans as my tongue finds hers. She grinds on me, seeking release—a release right now, I won’t let her have, so I push her away and look to Grady. Hunger lurks in his eyes as he stares at her. Finally, he moves, taking her off my lap and doing the same thing I just did. Well fuck me, watching them together doesn’t hurt. Jealousy is there, but all I feel right now is horny as fuck. I want my dick in her mouth. Want my cum running down her throat and leaking from the corners of her mouth. I just want her and if right now that means Grady comes as part of the package. I will have to suck it up and be a man about it.

Chapter 31

Nikki