If You Dare (Dare 3)

But how would she feel if I said those words to her? Her imagination isn’t nearly as dark as our actions are. “Demi—”

“I’ll be here when you get back tomorrow.” She interrupts me. “Waiting on you.” Then she hangs up.

I drop the phone from my ear and walk over to the door of the clubhouse. Cole stands over at the table, leaning up against it. Shane sits on the couch typing away on his phone, and Bennett is standing in the small kitchen area looking down at a piece of paper in his hands.

“What’s that?” I ask him.

He looks up at me and lets out a long sigh. “There’s something I need to tell you guys.”

“What is it?” Cole asks, pushing off the table.

“I received this right after you guys moved to Texas.” He hands me the paper.

“This glass can break as easily as your promises. What would you do to keep them both intact?” I read the typed letter out loud.

“What the fuck is that shit?” Shane asks, jumping up from the couch.

“I don’t know.” Bennett shrugs. “Another cryptic letter.”

“And you’ve had this the entire time?” Cole growls.

“I didn’t say anything because it didn’t have my name on it. It could have been to any of us or all of us.” He sighs. “I honestly thought it was for you, Cole, since you own the place. I figured it was someone who knew what you did to Kellan.”

“It was just sitting in here. Waiting on you?” I question.

He nods. “It was in the glass bowl. On the table.”

“Fuck!” Cole growls.

“So why tell us about it now?” I rip the fucker to pieces and throw them in the trash.

“Well, ’cause now I think it was Becky who gave it to me,” he answers.

Cole shakes his head. “She didn’t know anything. And why leave it in the bowl? People knew we did dares but not specifics.”

“That’s not true,” I argue. “He said he received it after we left for Texas. Becky got Austin’s journal while Austin was still in the hospital. We waited three months after she was shot before we moved.”

Cole nods once and growls. “So the bitch has been playing us for six months now? And none of us saw it?”

“The letter has to be for me.” Shane speaks.

We all turn to face him. “What makes you think that?” Cole asks him.

He squares his shoulders and takes a deep breath. “Because … I know some secrets. Some that would totally change how this night is going to go. And that letter was threatening me to keep my mouth shut.”

I frown. “I don’t understand, Shane.”

“We all have secrets,” Cole grunts. “Why you specifically?”

“I know something that you guys don’t. And if I told on the person who I’m guessing sent me that letter, I would also be implicating myself.” His eyes go to Cole, and I stiffen at the challenge in his eyes.

What the fuck does he know? And why hasn’t he told us?

Cole takes a step forward, closing the distance between them. “Just what in the fuck do you know, Shane?”

And with that, he informs us of something he should have told us a long time ago. With each word, the room grows smaller. Colder. I watch Cole’s body tighten, his fists clench, and his breathing picks up. I cuss, Bennett kicks the table. Shane was right. Tonight is going to go differently than we had planned, but I have no problem adjusting it accordingly.

BECKY

I sit at my father’s kitchen table eating a piece of pie. He’s out of town for the week so I have the house to myself. It’s actually nice to be alone. I’ve always had to share. My school. My space. My car. My father made me take Demi everywhere. I was so fucking happy once she turned sixteen and could drive herself to school. I should have told my mom to let her stay here while I moved to Texas by myself.

Finishing off the pie, I place the plate in the sink and make my way upstairs. The thunder shakes the walls, and I hear the rain pick up. Typical Collins. This place is such a downer.

I enter my room and fall onto my bed. I close my eyes and let out a sigh. But they snap open when I hear a noise. “Hello?” I call out, looking outside my room but see nothing.

I remove my shirt. Tossing it onto the bed, I undo my jeans and push them down my legs. Standing in a black bra and matching thong, I enter my bathroom to take a bath. I need to relax. My entire body has been tight for days. I’ve been in a bad mood. Nothing has been going right, and I don’t like that.

I hear another sound and walk back into my bedroom. “Hello?” I ask again. Silence follows. My clock on my nightstand shows it’s a little after midnight. The thunder rattles the walls again and lightning flashes, lighting up my room. I shrug it off, knowing it must be a tree branch hitting my window or something.