Always Be His Baby

Just as I'm about to punish her for laying hands on her puffy aroused cunt, I hear a voice clearing at the door over my shoulder.

Shelby's eyes flutter open, but her fingertips are still working at her wet cunt. I turn to find Gio and Rafe standing at the door, eyes riveted on our girl.

Gio already has his cock out and he's stroking it softly. Watching him watch her makes me so hot, makes me wanna bury myself inside her pretty wet cunt while he watches. Rafe catches my eye, and I nod once before he quietly unbuckles his belt and shoves his own hand down his pants, beginning to rub himself before taking his thick cock out into the air.

It's not the first time I've seen my brothers get off, it's not the first time I've seen a girl go down on both of them at the same time. But no girl ever made me come like the one before me now. It’s been so long, a decade at least. Shortly after her mom died, Gio hooked me up with one of his frequent fuck buddies, but I couldn't even come. Shelby's soft eyes haunted my mind as the fuck buddy did her best to suck me off. She talked dirty, told me how she wanted to milk me dry. But Shelby doesn't even have to say a word and already I'm at the edge, trying to hold myself back.

"Daddy needs to feel those pretty lips wrapped around the base of his cock."

Shelby seems eager, crawling over my thighs and making contact with my dick for the first time with her pink-tipped fingers. I husk in a breath, trying to measure my body's uncontrollable reaction to her.

"That's it, sweetie, now take Daddy to the back of your throat."

She hovers over me for a moment before licking my shaft from balls to tip once and then sucking me in fully. She hollows her cheeks and sucks so forcefully I think she must've done this a hundred times before, and that thought alone makes me angry. But she says she's a virgin, and I believe her.

"Fuck, baby girl. Fuck."

She sucks softly at first, tentative but eager.

"Fuck that pussy with your fingers. I want you to come with my dick buried in your throat."

Gio moves over my shoulder, then and I can hear him grasping at his cock and barely hanging on to his own release. Rafe comes around the side of the bed, getting the perfect view of her ass, perky and round, thrust in the air and glistening with her soaked pussy arousal.

I'd like to see him lick her clean, but I need her first.

She seems to like performing, her hips gyrating and her fingers moving quickly between her puffy lips as my brothers’ eyes caress her skin. She's creamy and round and soft everywhere, and I can't help but think that just the four of us could stay locked in this apartment forever, fucking her until she's messy and used with that pretty smile on her lips for the rest of our days.

I'm so goddamn horny. I've never felt this way. And knowing they are so turned on by her too drives my release closer to the edge. Her tongue trails along my balls then, and before I can think about it I thrust a hand down to her pussy and slap so hard she yelps with the pain of it. I almost cum again, but manage to hold it back before slapping her once, twice, a third time. Then I thrust my fingers deep into her juicy cunt and fuck her hard and fast until I feel her cream and quake around my digits. My cock is leaking and wet with her saliva.

"Clean her up," I instruct my brother.

He nods eagerly, bending over the bed, and with his hand still fisting his thick cock he starts licking the cream up from her thighs and soaked cunt. I groan as I watch, eager to fuck her perfect pussy, eager for my brothers and I to fill her hungry holes. She's everything to us. I vow to spend the rest of my days showing her just how much she means.

Her hips swirl and her breathing is raspy as she seems to grow more turned on watching me fist my own dick as my brother cleans up her glistening pussy.

"That feels so good," she murmurs.

"Good, baby. Because we're only just beginning."

I wrap my hand around her throat, squeezing tightly until I'm restricting her air just enough to make her eyes widen. I pull her to me, then loop my other arm around her curvy waist. I grab her ass as Rafe sits back on the bed, his own eyes fluttering open and closed as he thrusts his dick into his hand. I can tell he's right at the edge but who wouldn't be—she's so beautiful, her curves so soft, her ass bouncing with every movement of the mattress.

"I'm going to fuck this pretty pussy, and you are going to say thank you to Gio for licking you clean by sucking him off. Does that sound good, baby?"

She nods, eyes round and hungry.

"Christ, you're so goddamn perfect." That's Rafe, humming as he grips his cock and begins to tremor, a sure sign that he is close to coming hard and fast.

Hearing his words over her shoulder seems to turn her on more as she grows more aroused, her irises darkening with hunger.

Unable to wait any longer, I yank her down by her hips, impaling her on my rigid cock. She screams at the forceful intrusion, and then I remember that I am the only one that's been here. I should be soft and gentle, I should give her what she deserves, but part of me thinks she deserves this for prancing around in those short little crop tops that play peekaboo with her perky, full tits. I'll give her the aftercare she deserves, I'll wait on her hand and foot, I'll suck that pretty pussy until she's like putty in my hands, but right now I need to come hard and deep in her virgin cunt.

She seems to adjust to me quickly as her hands wrap around my neck and her fingers tangle in my too-long hair. She's all soft and gentle with me, and I'm like a caged animal needing a release.

Rafe approaches the side of the bed, his heavy cock hard and throbbing as it nears her lips. Her eyes gleam greedily before she takes it into her mouth, tentative at first, before deep-throating him to the base.

I groan loudly, the sight of her pleasing my little brother is the biggest turn-on. Rafe grunts and grits his teeth while he holds the base of his cock and pushes his other hand into her soft hair. She hums eagerly around his shaft, and as I'm pounding her into oblivion, Rafe begins to quake and jerk with his impending orgasm.

So turned on I can't think straight, I land a hard smack on her right ass cheek, and this makes Gio grunt with pleasure as her ass wiggles around my fat dick. He's jerking his fist up and down his cock with speed, eyes fluttering open and closed as he fights himself to come with his eyes wide open, taking in my beautiful baby girl.