Freshman (First Time 3)

I’d barely finished saying it when I realized how true it was, and just how much I’d meant it. It really was okay. Actually, it was more than that. And suddenly, all my conflicted thoughts about her, and about Tyler, and about the guilt I’d felt about somehow not including her in that monumental first time, came crashing together in my head, and it all clicked.

It all made sense, and suddenly, I knew exactly what I wanted.

I turned to tyler, biting my lip and almost afraid to say it out loud. "I- I want her to watch us.”

He froze as he stared at me with mouth open; "Are you serious? Chris-“

"Nothing more than that; you're all mine,” I said firmly, which made him grin and kiss me. “But just watching - if she want's to.” I took a deep breath. “Please?"

His eyes looked at me wolfishly then, and I could feel his cock actually throb deep inside of me. “You are just full of damn surprises, you know,” He smirked at me and I blushed. His cock throbbed inside of me again, and I bit my lip again, our eyes saying everything as I turned back.

“Anna, come out; please?"

Slowly, the closet door opened, and she stepped out.

My friend’s face was bright red, and her eyes wider than I'd ever seen. She was clutching her discarded dress to herself as her eyes darted from my eyes to to Tyler’s and then back to me, looking almost teary-eyed; “Oh my God, Chris! I’m- I’m- ohmygod I’m so embarass-”

“Anna.”

Tyler’s deep voice was both commanding and soothing at the same time, and just as my friend was about to start crying, she stopped and gasped at the sound of it.

“It’s okay, we’re not mad.” His hand trailed up and down my side, teasing my skin and making my nipples stand out rock hard on my chest under the sheet. I felt so fucking naughty just siting there on his cock while Anna stood right in front of us with only a sheet covering us.

“Aurally,” I took a deep breath and met her eyes - my best friend in the whole world - with mine. “Actually I want you to stay,” I swallowed heavily, my heart racing. “I want you to watch us,” I said quietly.

Anna’s eyes went wide, her mouth opening in shock. “Chris?” She looked at me pleadingly, almost like she was looking for a reason not to break down.

I felt my cheeks burn bright red and my pulse skip a beat as I locked eyes with my best friend. “I- I really do,” I breathed it out, feeling my whole body clench up in excitement as I did; “If you- I mean, if you want to.”

I watched her eyes get even wider as a blush crept into her face. “Are you sure? Christina, you’re my best friend, I’d never want to-”

“I’m sure.” And I’d never been more sure of anything in my life.

She swallowed heavily and looked at Tyler. “Mr Wea-” she blushed and shook her head. “I mean, Tyler? You’re okay with, um, me being here?”

He chuckled, and I made a small noise as I felt the reverberations rumble through me through his cock still balls deep in my pussy. “Like I said, the cat’s already out of the bag, isn’t it?”

Slowly, I watched a sly grin creep across her face and a twinkle shine in her eye. Now there was the mischievous, daring Anna I knew and loved.

“She wants you to be a part of this, Anna,” he said, his voice dark and so damn sexy.

Anna took a deep breath and nodded, as if transfixed by his voice - something I could definitely sympathize with. She bit her lip and slowly took a few steps towards the edge of her bed and sat down on it, facing us.

We had our audience.

“Okay,” she said quietly, her face red. “I’m ready.”

Tyler chuckled behind me and I drew a long, shaky breath as I turned to look at him. “Is this crazy?” I asked, raising my brow at him.

He grinned and kissed me. “No crazier than anything else you and I have managed to get ourselves into.”

I nodded, and before I could do any more debating, he smirked at me and let the sheet covering us fall to the side.

I turned back at Anna’s gasp, seeing her eyes wide as saucers as she stared at us, now totally and completely bare for her. Her eyes dropped immediately down and her jaw dropped as she stared right towards were Tyler and I met; to my tight little pussy stretched around his big, thick cock.

We all sat there frozen for a minute, everyone’s heart beating a million miles an hour and unsure of what to say, until Tyler decided to take matters into his own hands. He held me tight, his firm hands cupping my ass, and slowly, he began to slide me wetly up his cock.

It was my moan that broke the silence; my soft, mewling moan as I felt him slide me up his thick girth.