“Hey, what’s up with you and Sherry?” I tried again now that I had him where he couldn’t easily escape. I felt his body tense beneath me before I found myself being pushed onto my back with him looming over me in the dark. “You really want to talk about her now?” Before I could answer, he was slipping back inside me, and I lost my train of thought.
TYLER
Shit Ty. I was on my third stroke into her when I remembered the damn condom again. Common sense told me to pull out and grab, but she felt too good, so I told myself that I’d pull out at the end. Besides, I’d already cum in her a ton for the night, so one more shouldn’t hurt. Just the thought of cumming inside her made my nuts tingle, though, and I ended up fucking into her harder than I’d planned.
I caught her screech of surprise in my mouth and held my cock still inside her to let the pain subside. “Still hurt?” I whispered against her lips as her pussy clenched and released around my rod. “No, it’s better now.” She moved around beneath me until she was comfortable and wrapped her legs around my ass, pulling me in.
She grabbed my hand and placed it on her tit, and I squeezed while going after her lips again. I like taking my cues from her because she can be so shy one minute and a total tigress the next, like now. As soon as my fingers grazed her nipple and my tongue dipped into her mouth, I felt her pussy juice, and she lifted off the bed, taking me with her.
Having to fuck her slow and gentle had its own element of excitement though we’d both enjoyed the two nights our parents had spent in the hospital after the baby was born, and we had the house to ourselves. I won’t ever look at the dining room table the same again. In fact, I think we’d fucked each other blindly in every room except the master bedroom and the nursery. Nothing else had been off-limits those two nights, and we’d even got to sleep the whole night in each other’s arms, something I am looking forward to doing in the future.
I started this trying to distract her from asking about Sherry, but it wasn’t long before I was lost in her again. I can’t get over and doubt I ever will, the fact that this one person out of all the others in the universe does it for me. I never believed in such things before.
After seeing the destruction of my parents’ marriage as young as I was, in my mind, if my own parents, the two people I thought would last forever, couldn’t make it, then no one else ever would. I’d carried around those thoughts my whole life, until now, until her. Now I’m coming to believe that my parents were never in love, that no one who ever gets a divorce could’ve ever loved the person the way I now love her.
I could be wrong, but it just seems impossible to me that I could ever not want her. That I could ever be this way with anyone else, or heaven forbid, see her with someone else. When I’m with her, when I’m inside her like now, I don’t ever want to stop. Even when I’m cumming in her, my mind is already moving ahead to the next time I can have her. It’s like an obsession.
And she doesn’t help matters when she makes those cute little noises while digging her nails into me like she’s doing now. Outside, the wind picked up, knocking against the windows as we moved together on the bed with just the sliver of moonlight coming blanketing us in the darkness.
I kissed her moans away as I moved inside her building once again to that sweet release. “I have to pull out.” I slammed my cock into her a little harder going deeper, prolonging the agony for those last few strokes of bliss. Instead of letting me go, she held on tighter and fuck if that didn’t make me want to say fuck it and just let loose inside her.
It was the thought of our little sister asleep down the hall that brought me back to my senses. I’m not ready for that shit, and neither is she. “Let go!” She giggled like she thought it was funny, and her pussy went on lockdown. I nipped her jaw then moved on to her nipple, where I sucked way too hard before biting her teasingly.
Her pussy relaxed, and I was able to slip out of her just in time. I damn near fell off the bed when she pushed me out of the way only to get on her tummy in front of me and take my cock into her mouth. I knelt over her with my mouth hanging open in shock. It was the hottest thing I’ve ever seen and so very unexpected.