chapter ten
Aston
“After you, Finny.”
Convinced this night couldn’t possibly get any weirder, I follow Knox over to his bed, where Nicole is as naked as the day she was born, looking positively drunk on all this attention.
This is so not where I expected this night to lead, but I suppose I can’t complain.
Knox climbs on the bed, going to the right side of where Nicole is lying, leaving me to take up residence on her left side. He still has his pants on, but Nicole is making quick work of fixing that. I stroke my own cock lazily while she gets his pants unbuttoned and pulled down, urging him to fully take them off, which he obliges.
I shamelessly zero in on his now exposed cock—I mean, he did it to me, so fair is fair—and Jiminy Christmas, he’s fucking big. I thought for sure he’d be average at best. No one that bitter deserves a large cock, it’s science.
Dragging my gaze up to meet his eyes, which, sure enough, are on me, I tilt my head to the side, raising an eyebrow. He’s full of fucking surprises tonight, so I’m eager to see what he’ll do next.
Not needing to wait for his move, Nicole reaches up and palms both of our lengths in her tiny hands, stroking us firmly. Her boobs bounce slightly with the movements she’s making, and Knox reaches down and takes one of her nipples in between his fingers, twisting and playing with it. I bring my hand down to her bare mound, slipping my fingers in between her lips, finding her dripping wet for us. Thrusting two fingers into her wet heat, she moans loudly.
Then, she moves without direction, adjusting her position between us so she can wrap her lips around his cock. She grips my dick harder, causing a hiss to escape my lips, and I watch as she takes as much of him into her mouth as she can. She gags, as I would’ve expected by the size of him, her pussy clenching around my fingers at the same time Knox groans.
My eyes are locked onto the sight of her full lips stretching wide around his length. It’s hot as hell, and my hips thrust slightly of their own volition into her grip. His breathing has picked up, cheeks and neck are flushed, eyes glossy and heavy, as he thrusts into her mouth even deeper. His dark gaze collides with mine, making my pulse race.
She takes her mouth off him, looking at me and saying so matter-of-factly, “I want you to fuck me.”
Looking over at Knox, waiting for the moment when this becomes too much for him and he kicks us both out, I don’t see any of that yet.
“You got any condoms?” I ask him.
Nodding his head, he points behind me and murmurs, “Drawer.”
Sitting back on my heels, I open the drawer, pulling out a few condoms and the bottle of lube in there for good measure. Ripping the condom open with my teeth, I roll it onto my hard cock, stroking myself a few times once I’m fully sheathed.
“Can you get on all fours for me, baby?” I ask Nicole, tapping her thigh with my hand.
She happily does as she’s told, wiggling her ass toward me in a silent invitation.
“Sit in front of her, where she was,” I instruct Knox, positioning myself behind Nicole, rubbing my hand lightly up and down her pussy.
He does so without even a grumble, laying in front of her, legs spread wide open with her still in between them, his cock standing proud.
“When I seat myself inside of you, baby, I want you to put your mouth around Knox and suck hard. Can you do that for us?”
“Mhmm,” she moans out, nodding her head.
Not willing to wait a single second longer, I line myself up to her pussy and begin to thrust in while she takes him into her mouth.
The entire time, Knox and I are holding eye contact, and it is fucking heady.
Gripping her hips, I thrust harder, fully seating myself inside of her, letting out a deep groan at how tight she feels around me.
Knox lets his head fall back as I start to move, causing her mouth to slide down his length. Once I give her a moment to adjust to my size, I quicken my pace, making her choke on his cock. I watch him, mesmerized, as his eyes roll back, sweat glistening his forehead and chest, his hands gripping her head, holding her in place.
Reaching out, I grab the headboard, putting me basically right on top of Knox, pumping into her hard. She’s moaning out loudly in between having her throat filled up with him.
The intense eye contact going on with us is driving me absolutely wild. It’s unlike anything I’ve ever experienced, and I don’t quite know what to do with it.
Widening my hands on the headboard, I lower my body so my front is almost flush with her back, bringing me even closer to Knox’s face. Too gone to overthink anything, I drop my forehead down on his, and continue to fuck Nicole’s pussy hard and fast.
Our breaths mingle, becoming one, and my eyes fall closed, one of my hands coming to rest on his shoulder. He brings his hand up to hold the arm I’m touching him with, causing my eyes to open, watching him intently.
He’s thrusting up into her throat in time with my thrusts into her pussy, her moans becoming increasingly loud and needy, letting us know she is loving everything we’re doing. His heated, hungry gaze on me is becoming too much for me to handle, and an idea pops into my mind.
“Nicole, baby,” I say to her, while maintaining eye contact with Knox.
“Hmm,” she practically whines out.
“Think you can take both of us?”
“Aren’t I already doing that?”
“You are, but I mean in your pussy and here.” I rub my thumb over her puckered hole.
A deep, throaty, primal growl comes out of Knox, and fuck, it’s enough to make me come right now.
“Mmm, let’s do it,” Nicole finally says, a whimper to her words, and I drag my gaze from him to her.
“You’re sure?”
“Yes, please. I want it.”
“Okay, keep sucking him, and I’ll continue to fuck you while working you open back here.”
She wastes no time latching onto his cock again, and I swiftly lube my fingers up and start prepping her ass for one of us. Stretching her carefully, encouraged by her increased moans, I eventually seat three fingers into her, while pumping into her pussy with my cock, feeling confident that she’s ready for us both.
Tossing the other condom at Knox, I instruct him to put it on, while I pull out and lube my condom-clad cock up further. Since I’m already behind her, I may as well take the ass.
Once he has the condom on, she looks between us and asks, “Where do you want me?”
“Climb on top of Knox and sit down on his cock for me, baby.”
Quickly lining herself up, she sinks down, moaning with every inch. Knox’s jaw goes slack, his hands gripping her hips. She rocks on him for a minute, getting used to his considerable size.
“I’m going to come up behind you now, you okay?” I ask her, wanting her to be sure.
“Mhmm,” is all I get from her as she stills on top of him, waiting for me.
Adding a bit more lube to my cock and her hole, I come up behind her and line myself up. Torturously slow, I begin to push inside, making it past the first ring of muscle, and holy fucking shit, it’s a tight fit.
Knox starts to rock into her from below, and with every inch I get in, I can feel him moving inside of her. It’s a delicious feeling.
After several moments, I’m finally seated inside of her to the hilt. We both pause, letting her adjust to the full feeling on both ends.
“You doing okay, baby?”
She nods, breathing out, “It’s a lot, but in a good way, if that makes sense. Keep going, please.”
Knox and I begin to work into her in tandem, our balls rubbing and slapping against each other’s with each thrust, and that, mixed with the feeling of him sliding against my cock on the other side of her wall, is out of this world amazing.
As if unable to control ourselves any longer, we both thrust in and out of her hard, her moans and our grunts the only sounds filling the air.
The party sounds like it’s still going out there, but I wouldn’t be at all surprised if people could hear us. She isn’t quiet and none of us seem to care.
Before long, Nicole’s ass starts to pulse around my cock and her moans turn into screams, letting us know she’s coming. I pick up the pace, my balls drawing up tighter with every graze they make against him, and I know I’m close.
Nicole has collapsed onto his chest, moaning loudly, but with her new position, I’m able to see his face again and he looks as gone as I feel.
Pulling his bottom lip in between his teeth, he grips her hips harder, picking up the pace. The sight of him biting his lip and getting lost in pleasure is too much.
“I’m… going to… come,” I groan out, thrusting erratically while never taking my eyes off his.
“Me too, fuck!” he shouts, as if his orgasm is taking him by surprise. His body visibly tenses, eyes rolling back, and I know he’s coming hard. His release is enough to set mine off, and I let out a deep groan as I empty my load inside of the condom.
Continuing to thrust into her through our releases, she tenses and yells out, “Fuck! Coming again. Don’t… fucking… stop!”
Riding out the rest of our highs, we all collapse onto the bed, attempting to catch our breaths. I’m the first to get up a few minutes later, taking off my condom, tying it closed, and tossing it in the trash can across the room.
Knox gets up and does the same, finding his clothes and getting dressed.
Nicole looks about ready to pass out, but she eventually drags herself out of the bed and finds her dress, putting it back on, along with her shoes.
Throughout all of this, no one has said anything, and it’s becoming awkward.
Finally, once fully dressed, Nicole looks up at both of us before laughing. “Well, this has been fun. I’m going to head out, though.”
This cuts through the awkwardness, and we all laugh together, heading for the door.
I’m not sure what time it is, but there are still a handful of people here hanging out and drinking. Luckily, they are all pretty engrossed in their conversations, and they don’t seem to see us all walking out from the direction of the rooms.
“Pretty sure I’m going to bounce too,” I tell them as we get closer to the front door.
“Cool, have a good night, guys,” Knox says, opening up the door for us, refusing to make eye contact with either of us.
Once outside, I suddenly have no idea where Nicole is going or how she’s getting there. As if reading my mind, she speaks up. “I have my rental car. Want a ride?”
“Nah, I’m good, but thanks. The walk is only about ten minutes, and I like the fresh air.”
“Okay… well, it was nice meeting you and, you know.” She giggles.
“Yup, you too. Maybe I’ll see you around sometime.”
With that, I turn and head in the direction of the dorms. My mind is racing about the events that transpired tonight, but I’m too fucking tired to analyze it all.
Future me can deal with that tomorrow, once I’ve had some sleep.
Not thinking about it tonight.