“Ohhh.”
“Yeah,” I say as I stand from the bed and strip off my clothes.
I almost rip off a few buttons in my hurry to get my clothes off, but soon I’m naked and crawling back on the bed to where Hartley is still sprawled.
I slip between her spread thighs. My cock rubs along her skin, the inside of her thighs already drenched and glistening for me.
“Are you ready for me?” I ask, my voice coming out deep and husky.
“God, yes,” she says, hooking her heels around my hips and trying to pull me forward.
My cock lines up with her opening and I meet her dark gaze as I slowly push into her. Her pussy is so slick and hot and it clenches around the head of my cock as I sink another inch into her. She’s so tight that it’s almost painful but that doesn’t stop me.
I’m about halfway when I encounter some resistance. I frown, not realizing what it is, and thrust forward, filling her completely and popping her cherry in the process.
She cries out as I stuff her full and I feel her pussy squeeze my dick, almost to the point of pain.
“Hartley, sweets, you should have told me,” I say as I lean forward onto my forearms and pepper kisses all over her face.
I do my best to distract her from the pain, staying perfectly still even though the pressure in my cock has me close to passing out.
When her grip on my cock finally eases a little, I start to move. It’s slow and tentative at first. I want to make sure that she’s used to me filling her before I take her harder.
Hartley sucks in a sharp intake of breath and I rest my head against her chest, gritting my teeth as I try to stop from coming already. My lips find her nipple again and I suckle on one and then the other as Hartley adjusts to my size.
Sweat breaks out on my forehead and I mutter a curse as I do my best to take things slow. When her hips start to move with mine, begging for me to give it to her harder, faster, I snap.
“Oh god, Eli!” Hartley cries out as I take up a hard, punishing rhythm.
I know that I should go slower, get her used to me stretching her like this, but my control snapped as soon as I sank inside her.
Hartley’s moans grow louder until it’s like a symphony just for my ears.
I can already feel fireworks starting at the base of my spine. My balls grow heavy with seed and I know that I’m close to coming already. I need to make this good for her though.
I reach between us, my fingers finding her clit and rubbing over the sensitive nub in short, tight circles. Hartley cries out at the contact, her pussy walls clenching and pulsing around my thick cock.
“Fuck, fuck, fuck,” I chant, closing my eyes tight.
“Don’t stop!”
“I don’t think that I could if I wanted,” I admit, my pace growing erratic.
If I see that look of pleasure on her face for another second, I’ll come before I can get her off.
“Eli,” Hartley cries out and it’s the only word on her tongue as she starts to come apart under me.
I bury myself deep inside of her as I find my own release.
“Sweets, fuck,” I grit out as my cock jerks and I come deep inside of her.
I kiss her softly, gently, as we both try to catch our breaths. I notice her wince when I pull out and I head into the bathroom to grab her a warm washcloth.
“That was…” she says, dazed.
“Incredible,” I supply and she nods.
I clean up the small traces of blood from the inside of her thighs.
“Do you want me to grab you anything?” I ask, suddenly feeling shy.
“No, just you.”
She holds out a hand to me, and I take it, sliding into bed beside her. My arms wrap around her without a second thought and I hold her tight against me as her breathing evens out.
Soon, I know that she’s asleep and I smile, burying my nose in her hair and breathing her in. She smells like me now and I like it.
I close my eyes and fall asleep with a smile on my face.