Her eyes closed and her teeth sank into her lip. The look of pleasure passed across her face, making his balls ache just to watch her. She really was a sight to behold.
Up and down, Scott bounced her on his dick.
“Are you ready?” Beau asked.
“Yes, please, I want to feel you both.”
After grabbing the tube of lubrication they’d left on the bed, he smeared a lot of the gel, covering his shaft. Climbing on behind her, it was Scott’s turn to open her wide.
“She’s still going to be tight,” Scott said. “The plug is designed for her to get accustomed to us.”
“I know.” He winked at his best friend.
“You’re ready for me, aren’t you, baby?”
“Yes,” she moaned.
“Good.”
He nibbled on her neck as he pressed the tip of his dick to her anus.
Slowly, he pushed past that tight ring of muscles, sinking into her ass, and he gritted his teeth as pleasure overtook him.
It was insane.
The pull.
The heat.
The need.
Inch by inch, he filled her ass, gripping her hips as he pushed in. As he did, Scott and Connie both moaned.
His senses went on alert.
“Are you okay?”
“I feel … wow,” she said.
“She’s so tight. I can feel you on my dick,” Scott said.
“You’re both inside me together.”
Pushing her hair off her shoulder, he kissed her neck, biting down on her pulse as he began to pull out of her.
She whimpered his name and then Scott’s as his friend began to suck on her nipples, taking each one in turn. They fucked her body, sharing her, filling her. With Scott’s balls deep within her, Beau pulled out. Then as Scott eased out, Beau pushed in.
They built up a pace.
He ran his hands down her body, going to her clit. He fingered her nub and she cried out. This time, as she got closer to her orgasm, he didn’t stop. No, he brought her to release, feeling her entire body tighten around the both of them.
He closed his eyes, loving the feel of her as she came. She did so again and again.
Finally, Scott was the next to find release and after he came, he eased out of her. Beau held her hips and rode her ass, finding his own orgasm as he filled her ass with cum. Unable to hold himself up, he collapsed at her back, panting.
“I knew it was going to be hot, but not that hot,” Connie said.
Scott laughed. “Do you want to do it again?”
“Not yet, soon.” She pushed some hair off her face. “Have you guys done this before?”
Beau tensed.
“Done what?” Scott asked.
“You know, seduced women. Taken turns.”
Scott looked at him. “Beau and I have shared women before but it has never been like this. We never cared about a woman. It was always a bit of fun.”
“And I’m not a bit of fun?”
“No, you’re not,” Beau said. “You’re everything.” He cupped her tit as he took possession of her mouth.
He didn’t want her to think for a single moment they were using her.
“You’re ours, Connie. You mean more to us than any other woman could possibly mean to us.”
“You’re charming me.”
“I’m doing what I have to so you know you’re everything,” he said.
She smiled. “You know, I could get used to this.”
“Then why don’t you?” Scott said.
He looked at his friend.
“What?” Connie asked.
“Beau and I aren’t going anywhere. We both want this with you. There’s no one else, so why not take us? Have us both.”
“You really want to consider this full-time?”
“Baby, I already do,” Scott said.
“And I do. this is serious to us. You don’t have to pick because Scott and I, we like sharing.”
“And what about in a few months, or years?” Connie asked. “Not everything lasts forever.”
“Not everything but there are a lot of things, baby,” Scott said. “You didn’t stop thinking about having this bar because it might not work, did you? You’ve worked your ass off for the past five years, and look at it now. You’re thriving. It’s a damn good bar. Don’t underestimate us. We’re all good together, don’t you feel it?”
She nibbled on her lip. “I’m scared.”
“There’s nothing to be scared of. I promise.” Scott tucked some of her hair behind her ear. “We’re all here for you. We’ve got nothing to hide.”
Beau didn’t want to point out how the town already knew and they were hiding it from her.
“At least think about it. You can do that, right?”
“Sure,” she said. “I think before we have any dinner, we need to clean up.”
They all chuckled and the tension in the air moved.
Connie was the first to pad out of the room. Beau watched her. “What are we going to do about everyone else?”
“We’re just going to have to be careful,” Scott said. “She wants us. You can see that. We’re not going to fuck it up. I promise.”
He hoped his friend was right.