Without pause, Stefano spread my cheeks and pulled the plug out of me, which nearly hurt as much coming out as it did going in. “I’m a fair man. I may be cruel and heartless at times, but I am fair.” I heard the heavy metal as it was tossed to the floor.
I took a deep breath as if I could finally breathe freely. I hadn’t expected mercy from Stefano, but I was all the more grateful.
“Thank you,” I said. I was tempted to rub my ass just to feel the sensation of normal again but thought better of it. I remained in position in fear that Stefano would change his mind.
“Don’t think this means you can get away with anything when it comes to me or my brother. Don’t take advantage of my momentary softness. It’s very momentary.”
I nodded. “Yes, sir.”
“But we must replace that punishment with a new one.”
I swallowed hard, staring ahead at the corner, feeling Stefano’s breath against my neck.
“And when I’m done, you may wish for the plug instead.”
Without warning, Stefano placed his finger at the entrance of my pussy and pressed firmly inside. The invasion had me tensing and gasping but I refused to break position.
“I have to be honest with you, naughty girl. I’ve never had another woman respond to me in the way you do. I love how wet you get for me and with little effort on my part.” He pumped his finger in and out as he spoke, and all I could do was close my eyes and bite back the moan that wanted to break free.
He should be wrong. I shouldn’t be aroused. I shouldn’t be wet. Stefano should be wrong, but he wasn’t.
The building orgasm told me just how right he was.
“I can tell just how easily I could make you come right now simply by finger-fucking you,” he said, his breath hot against my face.
As his fingers slid out of me, I struggled not to whimper in need. He moved his two slick fingers from my pussy to my anus.
“My brother and I both plan to fuck this tight little ass of yours. But like I just said, I’m a fair man. I have no desire to cause permanent damage or to make you scream in agony. The only screams we want to hear will be screams of pleasure as we fuck both holes at the same time.” He pressed a finger past my tight opening. “So, I’m going to stretch this hole of yours. I will train your asshole to willingly take our cocks.”
I shook my head though I knew deep down it would do no good. He pumped his finger a few times, moving it side to side to stretch me further.
“Some anal discipline for my naughty girl.” I started to close my legs only to hear, “Stay in position or it won’t just be fingers stretching you.”
I opened my legs even wider in hopes that he would reward me by feeling he had stretched me enough.
I was wrong.
“That’s one finger inside of you.” I felt his hand move and more pressure added. “This is two fingers.”
I gasped as I opened my eyes wide in shock. The biting sting was too much. My hole wouldn’t be able to take both fingers without…
“Deep breath,” he said as he lowered his lips to my neck and kissed. When I didn’t do as he asked, he kissed my neck again. “This will be easier if you relax. I’m not going to stop until this ass of yours is properly punished and trained to accept something much bigger than just two fingers.” He kissed behind my ear, only heightening the confusing emotions and feelings ravaging my body.
He worked his two fingers in and out, in and out, in and out. I whimpered as he went deeper, and I cried out when he spread them apart, opening me for further invasion.
My knees threatened to buckle, and my hands could barely remain behind my head. With every thrust of his fingers, my body seemed to be melting in place.
“Have you ever had a cock in this ass of yours?”
I shook my head. I knew he wanted a respectful no, sir but I could barely breathe let alone speak.
“I can tell. This little hole is virginal, but not for long.”
He pulled his fingers out all the way, but only to push them back in, triggering all the sensitive nerves of my opening once again.
“Can you imagine my cock buried inside your ass?” he asked as he thrust hard enough that I raised up on my tiptoes.
“Yes, sir,” I barely whispered. I could picture his penetration vividly. It not only terrified me but excited me.
“And can you picture my brother fucking your pussy at the same time?”
I nodded as I closed my eyes and imagined the wicked act.